India made no protest when China occupied Tibet, East Turkistan, Manchuria and also Taiwan( by Kuomingtang Chinese). These are fatal mistakes by India. India also allows China to destroy our manufacturing industries by having continuous Chinese imports. McMohan Line is not the issue, because that line is the border between India and Tibet, not between China and India. Indian diplomats always made mistake by talking to the Chinese who are not the legitimate authority to decide the border between India and Tibet. India should recognize the independence of Taiwan and take the case of colonialization of East Turkistan and Manchuria to the U.N. Because India accepted colonial occupation of East Turkistan, India also lost a big part of Ladakh connecting Tibet to East Turkistan.
RE:dian policy is totally wrong
by varghese on Apr 03, 2008 03:17 PM Permalink
Well said Bose..u have rightly hit the nail...
India should in its own interest take up the cause of the Tibetans and all nations who have been broken by the Chinese aggressors...
Tibet should be made free and we should get back our Akas Chin...the Foreign Ministers of China should be always told this..
The red comrades in India should be asked on a daily basis their affinity and patriotism...
India should seek to further the cause of Democracy In china..as freedom in china will surely break China into 20 pieces...as far as i see china will last another 20 yrs..by then we will see china split into 20 provinces or states..China right now is run like a Virtual Prision..its people r held together by force
China has shown in history that it is an insincere neighbour.......
by shobana nair on Feb 04, 2008 12:20 PM Permalink | Hide replies
Like pak china is also an insincere neighbour their words and actions keep changing as history shows.They say tibet is theirs thailand is theirs and other parts of other nations beside them are also theirs when will they learn to be a sincere neighbour has to be seen in future.Their behaviour is rediculous at times it is high time they dug into their conscience and asked themself till when will they keep behaving like untrust worthy neighbours to all those bordering their state.India has to be very careful when a matter of trust is placed on such neighbours in future.They will learn their lesson also as time will show.
kanwal sibal has got it all wrong. when china captured aksai chin area of india in 1954 jawahar lal nehru simply looked the other way. being a faithful of the ruling clan he could not have written that fact.incidently this area remains under the illegal occupation of china till this day.-
Government is not serious at all. one should be done immed. All 15 lacs Military soldiers should retire in one shot. let PAK and CHINA distribute India. We will be more safe in china instead of this JOKERS
RE:Simple Solutions
by Neelamegham Ganesan on Feb 04, 2008 11:49 AM Permalink
If the author is a joker as per your joke, what kind of patriotism you have to claim as Indian? It is this lack of seriousness in citizens, we are losing all rights including territorial.
RE:CHINA HAS 3 OUTPOSTS IN INDIA ALREADY..
by ShyamKumar Mangayil on Feb 04, 2008 12:52 PM Permalink
Sir, CPM split off from CPI as a patriotic reaction - they were offended by CPI's silence (actual or perceived I do not know) on Chinese invasion. '3 outposts' shows you are a prejudiced Indian who is clearly not from any of these 3 states .Are you aware that similar allegations can be laid against people of yoir state ? As for prejudice we all have our own prejudices MGR fan ... I dont wish to push you into a corner by talking on MGR . Try to have a mature argument.
RE:RE:CHINA HAS 3 OUTPOSTS IN INDIA ALREADY..
by Dipak Bose on Feb 04, 2008 03:11 PM Permalink
You Mangayil do not know anything. CPI just like the Soviet Union was against the Chinese invasion and that was the reason those who were pro-Chinese mainly from South India( Nambrudipad, Satyamurthi, Basabpuniya, Ramamurthi, Gopalan, Ranadeve etc were arrested and they had formed the CPI(M). however, West Bengal, Tripura, Kerala are not Chinese colonies, I live in West Bengal, we are all against the Chinese.
Indian side area captured by China in 1962 war should be declared and put to UNO . International Community need to understand on what is real. By force China had captured that does not mean it belongs to them. The matter need to be discussed in parliment.
1)China is expansionist china may demand New delhi also. china has territorial dispute with Russia, Burma, Nepal, Bhutan Vietnam,Taiwan etc etc that according to me is Beggar country. 2) You are in Ruling givt but you have to Obey CPI(M) chinese agents Prakash karat and company. if they will tell you (Congress) handover tawang in Rs 100 also or we will withdraw support your govt will do. 3)110 Crore people are not foolish days are gone now we must also have some confrontational approach. tomorrow china will bring another proof or map 2000 yrs old and will say whoe North eastern was in China. china can easlily make fool to our leaders. 4) Nest our Hindu leaders and Parties Like Shivsena, BJP, RSS, VHP and all others when they were in Power they surrendered TIBET cards and result was that 100 crore people gave them Big and Black slap. If congress will handover 1 CM of land of Tawang or Arunachal people of India will not throw but they will approach Supreme Court and let full fledge war breaks out. Dont forget after 1962 war with India, China has to shut down 150000 schools and in 1967 there was small confrontation in which India gave Big punch also to chinese. Indian leader if have GUTS i say GUTS and if they have taken there Mother Milk they must daringly declare support to TAIWAN as Independent country then see chinas reaction. china will forget AP and tawang then India must demand MANSAROVAR AND TIBET.
RE:Mr Sibal few Qs to You also
by Dipak Bose on Feb 04, 2008 03:18 PM Permalink
India should recognize East Turkistan, Manchuria, Tibet and of course Taiwan. India should ban imports of Chinese products and impose 2000 percent Income Tax on Mahindra and Narayan Murthi, who have invested heavily in China.
The best solution is that handover tawang and area along china border to Tibetians.Let Lama and his followers form their Monarch their, till the liberation of Tibet.They will be in better position to retain / defend the given land as they have "cause" for it ,unlike Indian Plolitions who do not have juice in their " " you know where !
