Every new piece of news about this murder makes me sick. India is like this? Ashamed to be an indian. All this talk of India and its great culture stands bared.
Whenever India was compared with other countries for being bad with law, with infrastructure and living conditions we used to showcase our culture, tradition and values as if they substituted for all else.
This incident and other such ones show that all these are only in the talk.
Its shocking here to see ppl equate Scotland Yard and NYPD with Indian police when we know India is the third most curropt country in the world. Let it be known that the police here is most respectful and professional and so are judges. I can say this as I have experienced this twice when I was caught for speeding. In both cases police followed the rules perfectly and they always addressed me as Sir. And having seen how Indian police and courts work, I was pleasently surprised to see that when I went to pay my fine, the court worked more like a private company treating me like a customer. Contrast that with Indian police who will use swear words and lathis even before they find out your identity and fault.
The attitude of police and CBI has often been adversely remarked on even by indian courts like Hawala case where the courts said the CBI was not interested in investigating as Advani and other leaders were involved and had to dismiss the case. It has happened in Ansal, Priyanka Mattoo, Case of a Delhi model....why is it then that people are finding it objectionable when police is being condemned in this case for right reasons. Sometimes think beyond your country and like humans its good for you only.
RE:OMG
by Sid Justice on Apr 14, 2008 11:31 AM Permalink
Well said... There is no doubt.. we can never in a million years compare the indian police to NYPD of Scotland Yard. Fact is that people in such high posts think that they are beyond the law. Fine example is last week, I met some cop in the lobby of my building as I was going to work. He was standing and talking to the caretaker of my building where I rent a flat. I wanted t confirm something from the caretaker, but this cop rudely started asking me questions like where do I stay, who all stay with me, how much rent do I pay, where do i work and stuff like that.. Not that it was any of his business.. Not once did he refer to me as sir or Mister. When asked why he was interested, he just said, I will ask whatever I want to and you must answer.. THis attitude of the indian police is what makes them most corrupt..
RE:OMG
by Karan on Apr 14, 2008 12:11 PM Permalink
I believe you can refuse to answer in such cases. or is there a law that you have to answer all questions posed by the police for no reason?
RE:RE:RE:OMG
by beerappa Gowda on Apr 14, 2008 12:16 PM Permalink
yes he can refuese but he may landed in police station and therse kaki guys put some unsolved crimes on u and make yr life like a hell is is India man not US or UK
RE:OMG
by Sid Justice on Apr 14, 2008 12:15 PM Permalink
My understanding is that if you are arrested, then you can refuse to answer any questions without your lawyer being present.. but if you are not arrested, then it is just like any other converstaion.. only thing is that the other party.. is very rude and obnouxious..
RE:OMG
by JGN on Apr 14, 2008 12:42 PM Permalink
What I can derive from all your srmon is Indians are not even worth living on planet earch. When will the neo-converts have some self respect and proud in our Country?
first of all this lady have to be sick coz how can be the atopsy be done with out the specimens sample.and the doctor who is doing the 3rd autopsy needs to know that the situation!! why create such a fuss.u need the organs go collect it from the 1st place of autopsy..thats it...
I understand that the organs taken out for postmortem are, generally, not put back in their place but a hollow body is returned to the family (please correct me if I am wrong).
If Fiona wanted special arrangements, she should have made made a request for returning any removed organs and ensured that they are there before she left. Why make an issue out of it now ?
Quite a show is displayed already - better leave India alone and give final burrial for her daughter at-least now !
RE:Any Medical Prefessional please ...
by Sid Justice on Apr 14, 2008 10:56 AM Permalink
What comes out must go back in... Same as when a car is given to a mechanic. Just curious though.. What do the Goa doctors what with them organs? Are they trying to hide something???
RE:missing?
by chakra Gudipati on Apr 14, 2008 09:11 AM Permalink
great thinking..shows our level of understanding and maturity. Have you ever heard of compassion?? atleast for the dead?? may be u never got it during u r upbringing..idiot.
RE:What a Standard ???
by yap on Apr 14, 2008 12:36 PM Permalink
you let a 16-year old drug-addict with a drug peddler in a nude beach...what else do you expect? then what "What a country, what a people...." etc nonsense....
RE:RE:What a Standard ???
by Rishi Kanpile on Apr 14, 2008 09:52 AM Permalink
Dont blame the country for this thing,Locals have Goa have always been arrogant coz of the booming tourism industry,firstly they give more respect to foreigners than indians,I accept the whole system is corrupt,money talks.But it is also Fiona's mistake of leaving a minor girl with somebody else,she invited trouble.i know very well when many foreigners go broke they start having a fling with indians to survive their remaining days. I dont want to hurt the sentiments of any foreigner ,but it is true that these things happen all the time in goa,mostly russians.
