tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka ??? for all men ignorant abt hsitory it was British unified india in the present form
RE:RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 06:18 PM Permalink
I also studied a bit of history. Can you remember a person by the name of Pramod Dasgupta? And the comment he made in 1962, that a communist country can never be the aggressor. He also implied that the Indian Govt was lying to its people when he said that what was happening at the height of 20000 ft could not be determined from the plains. How would your communist countries handle this? They would have put him in front of a firing squad from treachery.
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 06:21 PM Permalink
maan...dont be foolish...gurudas dasgupta is a very prominent trade union activist and intellectual kind of patriot...what we need is india-china alliance as that will finish of american imperialism from entire asia !!! making some compromise for making that alliance come true is perfectly ok
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Bharat Nesan on Apr 09, 2008 10:00 PM Permalink
Are you a Chinese spy posing as an Indian? Either that or you should be a communist. Know this - the day is not far off when China will disintegrate. Only countries like India or USA that recognizes and accepts diversity will florish with a diverse population. Contries that does not honor diversity like China will break away.
RE:RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 06:29 PM Permalink
Learn your history first. I am talking about Pramod and NOT GURUDAS. This PDG was one of the founders of CPI(M). And, where does Uncle Sam come from? It was a war between India and China. You, as an Indian, MUST support India. Otherwise, you are a TRAITOR. As simple as that.
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by counter view on Apr 09, 2008 06:59 PM Permalink
Narayan is no Traitor, he is doing his duty as assigned to him by his masters from Dragon land.
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by arayan singha on Apr 09, 2008 06:25 PM Permalink
i think you have missed your weekly scheduled visit to the Physchiatrist. Please contunue taking the prescribed medicines regularly
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Netra Maithun on Apr 09, 2008 08:22 PM Permalink
Topiramate 100mg BID he he he
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 06:10 PM Permalink
You did not reply to my query. How come the people of places like Tawang don't think so? Logically they would have liked to join a Superpower (sic!) leaving a poor country like our own India. But if you go and ask any person in those places, they will only tell you that they are Indians and the land belongs to India only.
RE:RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 06:14 PM Permalink
how come u know that ppl of Tawang is upporting india ???? answer this first...many ppl in Tawang area must b supporting china..i am cent % sure
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 06:24 PM Permalink
I had written that "Go and ask any person". You guys, of course, don't trust freedom of speech. But can actually try it out to see in what view people held your superpower(?) China.
RE:RE:RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 06:19 PM Permalink
Don't be so sure. Travel to those places. I have been there many times and know it well.
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if else what abt tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir which never where part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka
by arayan singha on Apr 09, 2008 06:03 PM Permalink
narayana ur a full time paid staff of left party
RE:tibet was always a part of china...if then was tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir ever part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka ???
by arayan singha on Apr 09, 2008 05:54 PM Permalink
narayana we know ur a commie but ur a indian first so plz put indian interest first don't make such statement just only because ur beloved leader said so.
Sitting in your AC office, writing fantasy story is easy job Mr Bennet. Clearly you have no experience whatsover except- googling. So dont try to look smart by discrediting others.
You are like those hoax mongers who said US never went to moon, 9-11 was carried by America. A conspiracy theory churner.
RE:CIA ,communists and terrorists are the biggest threats the world facing today
by Raghav Shastri on Apr 09, 2008 06:17 PM Permalink
Let's Go. Have you taken your stick?
RE:CIA ,communists and terrorists are the biggest threats the world facing today
by ashok patil on Apr 09, 2008 05:49 PM Permalink
I fully agree with you.
"the CIA can expect a significant level of support from a number of security organisations in both India " The author is day dreaming that India will support CIA on Tibet. For that to happen Guts are required which indian politicians dont have. India which can't raise a strong protest when china says that arunachal doesn't belong to India can't do anything for CIA as far as CIA is concerned.
RE:No guts
by ashok patil on Apr 09, 2008 05:52 PM Permalink
Can we say it is our inferiority or weakness while dealing China frequent claims and intrusions.
tibet is an integral part of china and noone need to bark on the internal affairs of china..COMMUNIST CHINA...his holiness dalai lama must plz go back to china and live in his residence in lhasa instead of wasting poor indians money
RE:tibet is an integral part of china and noone needs to bark on the internal affairs of china..
by Nitin Karwa (in Germany) on Apr 09, 2008 05:31 PM Permalink
Narayan, you seem like a expert in international affairs and world history:) Any thought about China's claim on Arunachal Pradesh!
RE:tibet is an integral part of china and noone needs to bark on the internal affairs of china..
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 05:35 PM Permalink
arunachal pradesh is an area which india claims ours and china theirs....actually if iam writing in an impartial manner then half of ap belongs to us and the other with chinese..there is no use of abusing me bcoz this is the hard truth !!! tawang monastery is a prt of china while itanagar belongs to us
RE:tibet is an integral part of china and noone needs to bark on the internal affairs of china..
by Erasmus on Apr 09, 2008 05:37 PM Permalink
Narayan where did you learn foreign policy? By Google correspondence course Inc. ?
RE:tibet is an integral part of china and noone needs to bark on the internal affairs of china..
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 05:40 PM Permalink
How come the people of those places don't think so? Logically they would have liked to join a Superpower (sic!) leaving a poor country like our India. But if you go and ask any person in those places, they will only tell you that they are Indians and the land belongs to India only.
RE:tibet is an integral part of china and noone needs to bark on the internal affairs of china..
by sickularindia on Apr 09, 2008 05:21 PM Permalink
so do Afgahnistan used to be integral part of USSR in 1980
This guy is another of those commies. A writer who styles himself to be a security analyst based in the UK, actually works for the bloody reds. The problem, through out the history, has been that these people have got the necessary intellect to paint any story in their style. From this article, it seems Tibet was always a part of China. What a pity! These preposterous guys are given the space to write pieces of craps.
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 05:18 PM Permalink
tibet is an integral part of china dn noone need to bark on the internal affairs of china..COMMUNIST CHINA...his holiness dalai lama must plz go back to china and live in his residence in lhasa instead of wasting poor indian money
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by Piyush Bhargava on Apr 09, 2008 05:26 PM Permalink
Go drink the holy piss of the chinese,Mr.Narayan.
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by Shovon Chakraborty on Apr 09, 2008 05:23 PM Permalink
Yeah. Like Tawang and Aksai Chin, Tibet is also an integral part of China. China once also called Sikkim as its part and when Sikkim chose to join us instead, threw a great tantrum. Without your election machinery in W.B. you guys would not have had a place to run and hide in India today. Sick of guys like you. If the govt can ban SIMI then why not these commies?
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 05:27 PM Permalink
first govt must ban fasicsts/american stooges like bjp/rss before organisation like simi
RE:RE:RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by Nitin Karwa (in Germany) on Apr 09, 2008 05:33 PM Permalink
Narayan, Commies, RSS and SIMI all are on the list. Don't worry!
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by phartha sarathy on Apr 09, 2008 05:29 PM Permalink
TIBET WAS NEVER A PART OF CHINA.IF SO JUSTIFY
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by narayan on Apr 09, 2008 05:37 PM Permalink
tibet was always a part of china...if then was tamil nadu,kerala entire north east,andhra pradesh or kashmir ever part of india except in the time of some rulers like aurangzeb and ashoka ???
RE:Richard M Bennett stated For US: India's Untrustworthy
by Raghav Shastri on Apr 09, 2008 06:19 PM Permalink
Get educated kid. Learn to understand as well.
