Aligarh Muslim University should be closed down with immidiate effect.Settle the teaching and non teaching staff issue by giving compulsary retirement and the students should be allowed to take admissions in any other universities across the country.But this university should no more exist in India.
RE:AMU. SHUT IT DOWN.
by Sameer on Sep 24, 2007 02:51 PM Permalink
You dont deserve to be in India, if AMU does not! AMU deserve to be in INDIA, without a doubt! In fact its time now that the government realises and provide the necessary attention to this Great Institution.
RE:AMU. SHUT IT DOWN.
by Satyambada Anand on Sep 24, 2007 04:41 PM Permalink
This Zainul Abedin Sayed is a fraud muslim, a member of sangh parivar who is posting on pseudonym like all cowards. He even does not know how to write his name correctly- hence cant be a muslim- if he claims we have doubts.
RE:why we need AMU????
by MUHAMMED AKHTAR on Sep 24, 2007 02:13 PM Permalink
Mr Prestonboy,Don't try to make hay when Sun shines'Who told you SIMI was found in this institution? You appear to be a BJP hard core who believe all Madrasas are ISI breeding ground,although they don't have any proof.Some of the Bihar versity even Allahabad Versity has higher crimes at times.It has to be tackled.Closing in not the answer which the Sangh parivar seeks for an alibi.
RE:why we need AMU????
by prestonboy on Sep 24, 2007 03:20 PM Permalink
Muhameed Dude,Who told you SIMI was not started in AMU????please check the below link
I never thought and mentioned all madrasas are breeding ground for terrorist and ISI agents--Why do you want to assume something that i never said???why is this Paranoia.
Where did you get the date of crime rate in Bihar and Allahabad Universities do you have any media proofs or any govts datas???
I never mentioned closing AMU down, in my earlier post I have mentioned it should be scraped as a minority institution and made as Public university in line with government rule.
In the very state of Utter Pradesh there are so many educational institutions like IIT-Kanpur,Banaras Hindu University etc you don't come across incidents like student killing and debate about creating a independent nation--Do you mate.
Problem is with the people who are handling the day to day issue of the university. They need to changed along with the setup the university was administrated for the past 60 years that includes changing the special status.
In your post you never answered my question about the contribution made to our country by this so called great university. I am curious apart from politicians and Urdu poets and writers can you please give some examples of the Top Business leaders, acclaimed Civil servants, Scientist who graduated from this university.
RE:why we need AMU????
by Sameer on Sep 24, 2007 02:55 PM Permalink
As a nation too, do we need people who have no intellect on thier own, gets carried away by the communal propoganda and does not feel the need of finding the truth? No we dont, at all! So, Mr. Prestonboy, You go out of INDIA before AMU!
RE:RE:why we need AMU????
by prestonboy on Sep 24, 2007 03:26 PM Permalink
Sameer you don't have to worry about sending me out of India becoz I am already outside India.
There is no communal propoganda influencing my post it is mere logical thinking.
Sameer as a good citizen do you think do we need a university that divided our nation and created organisation like SIMI???
RE:RE:RE:why we need AMU????
by Billy Zane on Sep 24, 2007 03:47 PM Permalink
mr preston boy, ther is enough evidence of higher crime rates in muzaffarpur university, patna university, allahabad university, lucknow university, even criminals have been identified in BHU, IIT kanpur, so dont say that AMU has criminals Who told you that SIMI started from AMU, do u have evidence or any shakha pramukh have informed you Coming to next point, currently 60- 70% muslim civil sevants are from this university, have you heard about Prof. Irfan habib a noted historian is from this university, The first man who have gone to Antartica Dr. S. Zahoor Qasim is from this university, list is endless dont think that I am alumni of AMU, I have never studied there
RE:RE:RE:RE:why we need AMU????
by prestonboy on Sep 24, 2007 04:00 PM Permalink
Billy,If so many great people graduated from AMU then why is so much trouble in the University campus.
The teachers in AMU have become smalltime politician devided between caste, region and state basis.Aligarh being small town is perfect setting for such activity. Being a central University ,there is no transfer , hence the teachers have deep roots in local politics. Inept and coward administration has further added to the miseries of this great seat of learning, which it used to be.Some years back a Psychology Professor used to contest on BJP ticket.Research standard is of very poor quality.It is not uncommon to see Research fellows often doing weekly marketing and baby sitting for their guides.This is the perfect environment for crime.This university has become a adda of votebanks politics.Those who are still doing well from this versity,it is because of their own talent.The sooner the teaching community realises it is better.An Army officer or an IPS as VC is required to set right the things, which needs both brain and brawn.May Allah save this institution,Amen!
Those responsible for the disturbance in the campus should be punished and notorious teachers or students responsible should be immediately suspended.It can only be possible by an impartial enquiry into all the three murders by an external agency. Vice Chancellor should be more present in the campus and accessible to all the students and learn the ground realities of the University in stead of being misguided by a section of techers and students.
RE:AMU Violence
by Abul Hassan on Sep 24, 2007 12:30 PM Permalink
I think this is the problem created by teachers in AMU. As they do not want to teach for full sesssion.Rather, thay have become lazy and work shirker. They want to be paid without working. That is why AMU is closed down frequently in mid-session.
I hope this situation can be removed by recruiting competente teachers only who will be interested in teaching students and wo't be craving for long vacations.
