RE:123-Deal is not a national deal, only between Indian-American leaders' Deal. Common man will not get any benefit. Nuclear energy is 2 times costlier than water/coal/thorium.
by girija sankar on Sep 21, 2007 12:47 PM Permalink
Sahadevan's contention that 123 agreement is not national deal only between Indian-American leaders and common man will get any benefit out of it shows his ignorance about the subject. May be he is using his office coomputer and sending rubbish information. Can you tell me something about you. We want to know about you. A wonderful guy.
RE:123-Deal is not a national deal, only between Indian-American leaders' Deal. Common man will not get any benefit. Nuclear energy is 2 times costlier than water/coal/thorium.
by sanjay rathi on Sep 21, 2007 12:21 PM Permalink
If you have found a way to get energy out of thorium economically please share with the rest of the world. Other than that your points are stupid. Nuclear energy is cheaper in long run than water and coal. Also more cleaner.
RE:123-Deal is not a national deal, only between Indian-American leaders' Deal. Common man will not get any benefit. Nuclear energy is 2 times costlier than water/coal/thorium.
by Chanakya on Sep 21, 2007 12:19 PM Permalink
Mr. Sahadevan - let us keep our arguments on whether or not the deal is worthy on cost - your contention of the Neuclear deal is of no help to common man is totally incorrect. the reason being: 1. Neuclear energy may or may not be costlier (debatable later) 2. Water/coal/thorium energy may or may not be cheaper (debatable later) The present situation in India is ENERGY CRUNCH with Water/coal/thorium or without Neuclear. The pace at which India develops now, needs more and more energy to reach towns and villages, for which we do not have the catalyst. Once Nuclear engery is made available, it could be used for urban sector and the available water/coal/thorium energy could be diverted to towns and villages Thus making India shine everywhere with lights, water, industries etc. Just for the sake of opposing the deal is not right - ofcourse, if the agreement contains any clauses, warranties and guarantees which jeopardises India self defence mechanism, then those particular areas needs to be safeguarded, before operationalising the agreement. Once we reach a stage where dependability to US is no more necessary, we can do away with the 123...right?
RE:123-Deal is not a national deal, only between Indian-American leaders' Deal. Common man will not get any benefit. Nuclear energy is 2 times costlier than water/coal/thorium.
by Anil Kumar on Sep 21, 2007 12:33 PM Permalink
THE COMMUNISM WAS BORN AT EUROPE. BUT NOW IT WAS SWEEPED OUT FM ALL EUROPIAN RICHEST COUNTRIES. NOW ONLY SOME EUROPIAN COUNTRIES STILL KEEPING THE COMMUNISM( BULGARIA, CROATIA,SERBIA,YOGOSLAVIA,MOTINAGRO ETC.. AND THESE COUNTRIES ARE ECONOMICALLY VERY BACKWARD IN EUROPE
Left parties is wasting time in N-Deal debates. Communist says they are the GOD of poor. Communist Party wanted to avoid debates on major issues. Major Issues in India. 1) How many jobs Communist Party has created for poor since they are in power. 2)How many poor become rich in West Bengal & Kerala. 3)How many industries closed after commies comes in power. 4)How much money is wasted after every agitation by communist. etc....etc....etc.....
RE:No interference in India's N-deal debate: US
by bandu bondu on Sep 21, 2007 12:20 PM Permalink
u for got one thing that They are killing Farmers in NAndigram and Singur. Again they said they are for POOR. Mister u see nxt election result. CPIM will lose 50-58% seats in election.
RE:No interference in India's N-deal debate: US
by girija sankar on Sep 21, 2007 01:29 PM Permalink
I am keralite worked in Kolkata. Mr Raj you are hundred percent correct. There was hail of destructin (closing down of industries) in both the States. Gheros, intimidation, unjustified strikes, etc. The industrialists did not loose anything. They went out and started elsewhere. You know, the High Court in Kerala was the first declare hartal, bundh illegal. But in very same State it is called at the drop of hat. We are disguested. But we want only one party rule which will be pave the way for all round development. Congress is also responsible for this coalition. Now these left parties and other reginal parties like DMK, ADIMK, are really blackmailing us in the name of democracy. Constitution should be amended so that all these parties should have at least one MP in all the States to have a "say" in govt formation.
RE:No interference in India's N-deal debate: US
by smarajit sarkar on Sep 21, 2007 02:37 PM Permalink
Hi Raj,Bandu bondu,Giriga sankar, Yes you are right the only country you can trust is us. They are our master. Bush is more powerful than god. He is so innocent that he is destroying one country after another. We should adore US for killing millions of innocent people right from Hiroshima to Vietnam to Iraq ? Any body who is opposing the almighty Bush is a traitor, chamcha of Chinese. Let us worship Bush. You are right commies are loyal agents of Chinese govt. what about BJP? are they agent of Pakistan? The only poor state of our country is W.B. and Kerala. Bihar UP, Rajasthan, Orissa are very rich state. What about India? According to a shocking recent report, 836 million Indians live on a per capita income of less than Rs 20 per day. For 40 million Indians per capita income has improved only from Rs 9 per day to Rs 15 per day. So rational people our only aim should be eradication of leftist from this country. If any body thinks other wise we should use harsh personal word against him. Is this the essence of democracy?As per as foolish Bengali is concerned, who have again and again elected left, I will say what Bengals think today India thinks tomorrow. So Chamchas of US , undemocratic (majority of parliamentarian think deal is not good for India) capitalists, imperialist people think again
RE:No interference in India's N-deal debate: US
by raj on Sep 22, 2007 01:24 AM Permalink
smarajit sarkar Go get a life. your head is in the shithole called communism.
US democracy is much senior to us, they should/will not interfere in our affair. Our democratic set up is based on vote bank not on nationality, as such it is a balancing exercise by Congress with Left.
Debate should go into the parliment and between the parties who has more concern on there political well.Let governament make understand then the importance of energy and governament should also explore other energies aspects(solar and wind).As of know it has so many concerns on the destorying the used uranuim as it is difficult to process. One thing the Left should understand if they think by opposeing the deal they will be superstars in indian politics.they are making a big mistake as indians will never forgive them for this.As West bengal CM itself has indicated as nuclear civilian is important for us to fuel our growing economy.
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by girija sankar on Sep 21, 2007 01:20 PM Permalink
Hello Sahadevan, you think you are the only citizen concerned with fate of this country. So, we should all respect you and put your picture after Mahathama Gandhi. Come on ya, will you keep mum. Don't expose yourself too much.
RE:RE:RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by ProudIndian on Sep 22, 2007 03:17 AM Permalink
For GOD sake, try to be a human being Sahadevan. Normally we see lot of people use some extra words to express emotionally. But you... I dont know what kind of person you are, still posting same shit again and again.
If you are not a coward come up with more personal details in this forum and stop this non sense, instead of Ctrl C & Ctrl V shit express your argument sensibly.
Look again don't take it personally, we are not offending you personally, but just got irritated with your attitude.
You are welcome to share your views, we will listen, now start say something meaningful at least from now.
If you like this deal not to happen, explain why and reasons with complete facts, I am sure you could have searched something valid or could have copied from other in different forum/news site to stand your point.
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by Chanakya on Sep 21, 2007 12:22 PM Permalink
ha ha ha they can only ask Congress and BJP because LEFT is LEFT OUT in forming a government with majority FOREVER in India... soon you have hear Congress left the LEFT...
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by arun patwardhan on Sep 21, 2007 12:23 PM Permalink
Truth about left.. they do not want the deal beacuse it has smell of Americanization even it will serve the purpose of very energy need. Truth that these leftist don't read and learn. they cried about WTO.. Which proved benefitted India bigway. they cried american investment.. you see the result, b'lore taken ahead of Kolkatta. they do nto understand povery can not be erradicated with out having money-- simple truth - You have to eat even to produce a shit.. Check you want to be health or die of hunger because yu can't and/or don't want shit
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by Mohan Kumar on Sep 21, 2007 11:33 AM Permalink
Left is anything but truth. Left is bunch of backward, objectionists, blockers, chockers, traitors, blinded by unpragmatic, dead and failed ideology, unpatriotic yet wear the sheep's skins. Their interests is served by keeping the nation backward, poor, struggling.
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by Pranay Mehta on Sep 21, 2007 11:41 AM Permalink
The same is true for congress, "purane gulami wale din vapas aayega"
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by anjan sengupta on Sep 21, 2007 11:22 AM Permalink
JAI SRI RAM
RE:RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by Chanakya on Sep 21, 2007 12:23 PM Permalink
Anjan...beware Karunanidhi is listening/reading
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by stav on Sep 21, 2007 11:29 AM Permalink
What is your point ? JAI RAM< JAI ALLAH, JAI STALIN
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by bandu bondu on Sep 21, 2007 12:22 PM Permalink
Do u know what happend in NANDI GRAM?? AND SINGUR?? I think u r the DALAL of CPIM.
RE:RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by jay krishnan on Sep 21, 2007 11:41 AM Permalink
Sahadevan, I got to hand it to you. You are a real joker repeating the same lines over and over. Ok we get it. And I am afraid what everyone gets from this is that you don't have real arguments to make against this deal.
RE:Left is the truth. US started to frighten Manmohan Singh that India should clarify the Iran-India relation. This world notorious criminal can ask these things only to Congress and BJP.
by arun patwardhan on Sep 21, 2007 12:23 PM Permalink
Truth about left.. they do not want the deal beacuse it has smell of Americanization even it will serve the purpose of very energy need. Truth that these leftist don't read and learn. they cried about WTO.. Which proved benefitted India bigway. they cried american investment.. you see the result, b'lore taken ahead of Kolkatta. they do nto understand povery can not be erradicated with out having money-- simple truth - You have to eat even to produce a shit.. Check you want to be health or die of hunger because yu can't and/or don't want shit
