I am wondering if the China is working behind the scene through the left parties in India to block the Indo US Nuclear co-operation. I believe and sincerely hope this is not true and that the left parties are working in the national interest of India or at worst are playing a political game which has nothing to do with China. ------india unwire . com
RE:Are the communist actiing on behalf of China?
by Cape Comorin on Oct 30, 2007 09:55 AM Permalink
Which country is working behind BJP to stop this deal?
RE:Are the communist actiing on behalf of China?
by Krishna Prasath on Oct 30, 2007 10:17 AM Permalink
Do you know BJP would have supported the deal had Cong taken them on board at the beginning. They are not against the deal they want our nuclear weapons program be not affected by this deal.
RE:Are the communist actiing on behalf of China?
by selah on Oct 30, 2007 10:40 AM Permalink
dear commies are also not against the deal . they are also asking to change the hidden agenda by USA
RE:Are the communist actiing on behalf of China?
by raj on Oct 30, 2007 06:29 PM Permalink
selah, First of all keep in mind no country on earth going to give some thing with out any restrictions. US did changed their rules for India and Bush administration came under fire from many democrats as well as Republicans. So they bend rules. NO BALL IS IN OUR COURT. COMMUNIST IS HELPING CHINA. AND BJP IS SELFISH. Thats all.
RE:Are the communist actiing on behalf of China?
by Krishna Prasath on Oct 30, 2007 03:00 PM Permalink
Dear Selah, If you read the left's open letter to MP's you can see they want fuel enrichment, reprocessing and heavy water production technologies which no one will give(other than Russia and may be France not sure but may be possible), they are saying duel use sanctions will continue so there is no full civilian nuclear co-operation. Don't the term civilian means only civilian and no dual use? They also claim that we will not get thorium based reactor technology so we have to develop it ourself so no use in n-deal do you think a proven thorium based reactor is in this world? sorry buddy they did not make it quite good, if you take their agenda is India should not get close to USA as it will affect china. Thats all.
India is a resilient civilization and has faced innumerable massacres and injustices. There is nothing by which India canont go without. N-deal is not critical yet can be helpful. US should not put time limits and barriers for further negotiations onesidedly and slowly ensure amendmending the Hyde Act in such away that it may not lead to perception that US can interfere in India's sovereign choices in view of India's track record of a disciplined developer of nuclear energy as a soverign nation with malice towards none right from the time of Bhabha -Nehru regime. The deal should be made such that under all situations that can break it are taken care of in such a way that even in the worst political situations both countries continue to ensure energy security to each other through nuclear power and nuclear energy infrastructure developed under the deal. Both countries ,however, should commit themself to work in some structured manner to denuclearise all non-civil activities in their own countries and in other countries using UN agencies in a time bound fashion to ensure to the world that both the democracies truly stand for world peace and work together in company of all nations of the world to minimize old uncivilized concepts of ensuring regional balance of military might while ensuring total security of only one or two nations. The security of US is as much precius as security of India or and other nations. The concept of minmum nuclear deterrant should also be phase
Congress should have approached the BJP in a friendlier manner and taken them on board on such an important national and foreign policy. Instead the PM calls them names and makes outrageous allegations like a third rated politician. He does not care about the national interest and all he cares is Congress/Sonia's interest.
RE:Arrogant Congress
by gautam roy on Oct 30, 2007 10:26 AM Permalink
I agree with Mahesh`s contention, after all respected PM does not have this much sense when it`s the question of national policy for long term then BJP being a mature political party who has also run the country should have been taken into confidence. Rather Nuclear power aquisition was initiated during BJP rule, instead of relying on left who are only criticizer rather than any positive thinking. That`s what left party has done to the state where they have ruled for about 30 years. Mahesh, our political system looks for short term personal gain and not for long term national interest as such.
RE:Arrogant Congress
by deepak bhatia on Oct 30, 2007 10:52 AM Permalink
How can they? These people are opportunistic politicians. Recently even a person like Manmohan Singh hurled abuses on BJP. These people consider BJP as enemies. They can kneel before leftists, who, if you go into history, have always blackmailed the parties they have supported. Nobody can trust leftists. Their only funda is unionbaazi. They are not interested in the growth of India. Now a days there is almost 12 hours electricity cut in north India, when its requirements is not at all at peak. How will they manage electricity supply during winter, nobody knows. And still these people are opposing civilian nuclear deal. What will happen if india conducts another nuclear test in future if need be, NSG will impose sanctions. What are we upto? We are already under nuclear sanctions. It can not go worse. We should go ahead with this deal pusuading all like minded people and political parties. Just for the sake of opposition, we should not oppose it. Congress should consult and discuss all political parties, except leftists. They seem to be working on the behest of China. Sonia - rahul, it appears, went to china to pursuade their leaders to direct indian communists to follow the congress line, it seems.
RE:Arrogant Congress
by raj on Oct 30, 2007 06:33 PM Permalink
Mahesh , I agree. They should have included BJP in the talk. That what they do in the US. Bipartician deals. BJP is the one started this deal. BJP and Congress should iorn out their differences and work towards nation's futrue. And defeat the COMMIE BSTDS.
India has made itself mockery in global stage. One side we want to creat perception that we are rising economic power and other side whole world is watching how our politicians cant generte an agreement over a deal which is so essential for india's growth. China's trustworthiness has increased, more foreign investment will go to china now, since multinational will always choose china better than india. China has total focus on growth. No great ideology and pseudo big talk politicians.
