Does W Bengal govt. has surplus agriculture land where they are getting surplus food? If not then why Bengal govt take over empty land and give it to farmers for cultivation. It appears that Bengal govt has surplus agri. products and food. that is why they want to remove farm land and give it to industry anf fill their own pockets.
SHAME ON YOU.
BUT THERE IS NO USE OF MY SHOUTING, BECAUSE GOVT. IS SHAMLESS.
The base of the present problem in Nandigram is CPM itself. It is their basic policy to oppose whatever development in spite of the fact that the same will be beneficial to people. Now the present CM of Bengal is a gentlemen who realized the fact that development is possible only through industries and not through trade unionism. But the vision of CM is not understandable to common grass-root level CPM workers. This policy of CPM we are watching in Bengal and Kerala. In Kerala such situation will never happen because the communists there are still living in 18th century blindly following the policies of China. There is struggle in CPM between practical ideology and old theoretical ideologies. Bengal CM is a man of practical ideology. But the majority CPM leaders as well as supporters are still believing in old age theoretical ideologies which is not at all practical in present day. We have seen that China has accepted religion. But the communists in India still fighting for their old age policies which has no practical value at all. CPM should taste the impact of Nandigram also, as such struglles were always created by CPM only in the past. Still they follow such brutal and unpractical struggles in Kerala. They are always against Development of State and country. They know once their followers become literate and get job, they will quit CPM. That is why they are opposing industrialism.
RE:Communists are against Development
by uddhav raj on Oct 29, 2007 11:35 AM Permalink
I am not from any party but i am HINDUSTANI. It is not that only communist are against development but all ruling govts. including Congress, NCP, BJP, CPM, CPI, All groups of JD, RJD, BSP and others are against devleopment of Hindustan but they are interest in development of their own.
RE:Communists are against Development
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 11:33 AM Permalink
very much relevant but beg to differ from you with respect to what is being said about our favorite Cm Budhdhadeb Babu...he had quitted that party after claiming it as a bunch of thieves and dacoits...but he came back and joined these thieves and kept a high look about his so called intellectualism and humanity...how can a so called rational and intellectual digest the mass killing of innocent people for long six months period...either he is spineless or is same as his colleagues...regarding idelogy CPM is now the No. 1 capitalist party in India...its called as the Capitalist Party of India (Milton Friedman)...they prevent Manmohan Singh from getting FDIs but themselves visit to Italy and call US persons to invest in state...what a mockery of politics and democracy...they have turned in to a laughing lot for the entire country...the problem is that Congress has been strengthened at the centre by these hypocrite self claimed communists and they( CPM) in return are getting a spineless opposition in West Bengal so that they can continiue with their anarchy...for the last 30 years they have ruined the state in every possible way and plan to do more in the coming days...in the name of industrialization what they are carrying out is nothing but exercising power in selected areas of Bengal so that their supremacy is maintained...democracy is dead...long live democracy...
Are Indians geared up so much to be ready for fighting? Well, channelize this fire for imparting Millitary Training to them. LET THEM BE USEFUL TO BUMP OFF ENEMIES ON THE BORDER OR WITHIN RATHER THAN SPILLING EACH OTHER'S BLOOD.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by rraazz rraazz on Oct 29, 2007 11:14 AM Permalink
From did You got this Information? can You answer Me-
1 What is ROLE of SO Called -"anti-acquisition Bhoomi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee activists" when the PROPOSED CHEMICAL HUB PROJECT is already Cancelled in NandiGram ?
2 Is M/s Mamta Banerjee is with NDA or Congress ?
3 How can INDUSTRILISATION be done without Acq. of Land ? 4.What is the TRACK RECORD of Other State Govt on Land Acq. - Spl Punjab,UP,HP,Maharastra,TN ,AP Karnataka etc
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by Sahadevan KK on Oct 29, 2007 11:50 AM Permalink
3 CPM cadres are assassinated by Trinamool Congress yesterday. Even then Modi supporters say here CPM are the killers. 3010 CPM cadres are killed for 30 years. Congress, RSS, TC, Naxalites etc. are the killers of CPM supporters there. Mamta is so frustrated. She got there what she has done before 30 years.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 12:17 PM Permalink
thanx for your kind information...why dont Budhdhababu prevent these killings??..is he credible enough to run this state?...silly communists...
RE:RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by antiCongress antiBJP on Oct 29, 2007 01:44 PM Permalink
Modi gets the 'fire' and BJP gets the brickbats throughout India, according to they gave to the people of Gujarat; the Left gets mass support, what they gave to the people of Bengal for last 30 years.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 11:41 AM Permalink
what you people are trying to do is very simple...creating a consensus that Mamata is to be blamed...but friend , do you think people are that much nonsense to argur on these lines rather than protesting the mass killing?????... the party machienery will face more opposition in the near future and its the tip of an iceberg...no rational individual can accept this mock industrialization at the cost of innocent human lives... the silliest part is that , CPM acquirs only multicropping fertile land for industrialization , leaving aside the barren lands...hahahahaha...silly communists...
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by Arindam Das on Oct 29, 2007 11:04 AM Permalink
Mamata should be fired first. One time Uchhed of all the trouble. I am not a communist or something . I am Just a well wisher for our West Bengal's youth. Atleast this industrailism could generate 1000 of peoples job directly/indirectly. See the other state and learn my dear friend. Mamata is just keeping PARDA to the innocent people to gain the Vote bank... Cheer Up and support indutrialism. Before you neighbour states overtakes you. And you need to approch next state for your Jobs.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by biswarup chowdhury on Oct 29, 2007 11:20 AM Permalink
very true my dear friend...but not only Mamata but the main culprits who are creating this anarchy and nuissance from under the veil of communism...people wonder that how can a pro labourer and pro farmer party can kill so many people in the name of industrialization...even if someone claims that it is not state government mechanized , still the Government is to be blamed as beacause it has failed to safeguard the lives of innocent people for more than six months...are we living in democracy or autocracy???...the main thing is that , industrialization is a boon for the state ,,, but friend at the cost of multicropping fertile lands???...its a mockery of politics , democracy and humanity that these so called intellectuals are carrying out there...what about the barren lands of bengal , where these self claimed communist industrial revolution in bengal is still to reach???...democracy and rationality and humanity is dead in Bengal...long live democracy and rationality and humanity...Have we become spineless??????????
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by Dinesh Shukla on Oct 29, 2007 11:16 AM Permalink
Why your above findings do not cover the 30 years of cholbe-na, cholbe-na philosophy of Commies ? Whey Mamata alone is blamed for this state of affairs in West Bengal. You can not ignore your long past, which take the shape of habit or culture of particular area or state. Think WHOLISTICALLY.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by NKnath on Oct 29, 2007 11:26 AM Permalink
Mr. Das , What do you mean by industrialism ? Is it Killing 100 people and give the opportunity 40 people ? What murderer Buddha and janoar Laxan Seth want ? Is an good citizen it is your duty to pray that god would immediately kill the nonsense Budhha and Laxan seth as He killed the Bustard Anil Biswas.
RE:communist arr kiliing the innocent
by Mr S. Pramod Nair on Oct 29, 2007 11:27 AM Permalink
We cant blame Mamta. What she is doing now has been done by the Comrades during the past.
