Right!!?? The article above is written by a JNU prof who also happens to be from Kerala. Chances are at 99% that he is a pure communist. I'm sure he'd love us Indians doing a lot more that just watch China. How about join em? and do what they do? huh? C'mon, gimme a break! Damn JNU commies.
The most imp. thing for India right now is to focus its all energy, resources in building ifrastructure, like china has. Thats vital like oxygen for any country to grow. U look at any rich nation, and u will find that they have made wide roads, clear foot path, comfortable travelling, business climate. Thats why they attracted so much capital from other countries, multinationals came, set up shops, industry and local people started competing with them, and automatically economy started grwoing like crazy.
RE:India must watch, china's progress & learn.
by bihari babu on Oct 16, 2007 12:31 AM Permalink
What manoj is saying is, infrastructure will help india's economic growth, that will creat many jobs and wages will come automatically. Many poor people will move to next middle class. and growth will happen. Otherwise from where is money going to come to distribute to poor. Hawa me se aayge kya ? Govt is already giving it for last 50 years, we all see the result.
RE:India must watch, china's progress & learn.
by Ashwin Praveen on Oct 16, 2007 12:49 AM Permalink
Hi ignorant,
Your philosophy of disbursing to the poor only makes people "equally poor" . Building infrastructure is one good way to make the rich richer and the poor richer, ie, making all of us unequally rich!
RE:India must watch, china's progress & learn.
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 11:09 PM Permalink
for that you need transparent system of WWW..which requires net infrastruture....to disburse wages ...how do you think money can be distributed/resourse w/o infrastructure..please suggest a workable idea....
RE:India must watch, china's progress & learn.
by Deepak MA on Oct 16, 2007 10:15 AM Permalink
Waht is this infrastructure infrastructure that you are blabbering???
RE:India must watch, china's progress & learn.
by bihari babu on Oct 15, 2007 10:34 PM Permalink
Yes, thats only thing to learn. No need to learn more about communism from them, we already have enough communism & headache at our home.
RE:Indian National Congress
by manmohan on Oct 15, 2007 10:41 PM Permalink
so u want congress without gandhi, its like head without brain, party will collpse in single day
RE:Is one child policy correct ????
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 10:06 PM Permalink
NO...support for old age retired persons are given by government..people there get old very late unlike India and also uture young generation couple would be earning atleast 8times more than their parents...
While the changes in China is indeed amazing given its size, there is nothing to ape for India. Considering the rural-urban and rich-poor divide in this communist country, we should be happy we have a society that shows much more concern about inequality and deprivation as indicated by massive targeted programs for employment, food security, education and the proposed social security measures for the informal workers. The open society and the debates (albeit a bit too long) is what makes living in this country any time much more preferable than in China.
RE:China and India
by safarulla sherule on Oct 15, 2007 10:26 PM Permalink
You are ill informed. In India it is much more worse. You don't feel it since you belong to the affluent. There is slavery and bonded labour in India. China thinks about at least reverting this devide and slowing down growth rate.
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 10:16 PM Permalink
I'll like to add if 20crores muslims of china are not having problem with the policy ..then why Indian musliams would have?
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by ghenda on Oct 15, 2007 10:47 PM Permalink
India is declared as a secular country, hence everyone should be treated equal. To achieve this, first and foremost nobody should be allowed to declare his/her caste and we should have uniform civil code for all relegions. There should not be any special or descriminatory treatment for anyone. When we bring true equality we can certainly achieve what China has achieved
RE:RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by on Oct 15, 2007 10:21 PM Permalink
Because in China when the government gives dis-obedient people a bumboo in the behind, they cannot run to Shabana Aunty or Teesta Aunty crying discrimination!!
Read my earlier posting. We created this monster by allowing reservations, special treatment to minorities on the basis of what happened in the past instead of starting fresh with equality for all!!!
RE:RE:RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 10:24 PM Permalink
true and on the top ..not having a unified civil laws and court...and then they want reservation on the name of discrimination..
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by murki suresh on Oct 15, 2007 09:46 PM Permalink
Tomorrow if they say Only One Age Old person in a family ????
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by V S on Oct 15, 2007 09:53 PM Permalink
are you saying only muslims are reproducing fast?
do you have basis for this comment ?
do hindus not have 3 or 4 kids ?
India's problem is the poor quality of education and leaders we have who lack vision.
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by Lalit Sharma on Oct 15, 2007 10:39 PM Permalink
One Hindu male may be having 3-4 kids but Muslim Male may be having 4 Wives and 16-20 kids. That turns to be Hindu - 2 adult and 4 kids Muslim - 5 adult and 20 kids
Hindu Average 2 kids per adult Muslim average 4 kids per adult
RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by on Oct 15, 2007 10:54 PM Permalink
Wrong, Lalit!! Check the comparative reproductive trends.
Hindu Average minus 1 kid per adult.
Muslime Average 4-8 kids from official spouse, 4-8 from each unofficial/auxilliary spouse!!
The whole idea is: Let the hindus multiply their money at the stock market, Muslimes will multiply their population. Ultimately there will be enough muslimes to snatch that money from the Hindus who will be too badly outnumbered even to put up a whimper of a protest, let alone a decent fight!!!
RE:RE:China 1 child policy must be adopted for indian musalmaans
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 11:12 PM Permalink
power is with money not with population..what power do 1.7 billion muslims have in this world?....which muslim country apart from pakistan can match India in military strength?...
Left will black-mailing Government since starting. Left is now successful for delaying the N-deal. Now it is a time for debate real issues in Parliament. Communist Party wanted to avoid debates on major issues. Major Issues in India. 1) How many jobs Communist Party has created for poor since they are in power. 2)How many poor become rich in West Bengal & Kerala. 3)How many industries closed after commies comes in power. 4)How much money is wasted after every agitation by communist. etc....etc....etc.....
We must appreciate how the Chinese people under their single Communist Party rule have achieved remarkable economic progress. We boast we have democracy. But we have made a mess of it. See how democracy works in Karnataka. Deve Gowda and his son HDK have made a mockery of democracy. They have not foolede the public. They have fooled themselves. Both father and son played fraud on the people, one calling BJP communal, the other forming a government with BJP and 20 months later cheated BJP by not transfering power to BJP. All developmnet projects were put on the back burner. HKD and his wife have amassed assets over Rs. 30 crores. Howe did the get it? Even God does not know. Is there a single MP or MLA in India who is poor. Answer is an emphatic NO! Our PM, a puppet PM now surrendered to the threats of Leftists, who represent only 10% of the population and put the 123 Deal with USA on the back burner. A lot can be said about the corruption and incompetence of our politicians. They are not our leaders. Only young. honest and energetic professionals should take over the country. The Presidential form of Democracy with only two or three national parties suits us more than the current system.What do our readers say?
RE:China's Economic Miracles
by murki suresh on Oct 15, 2007 09:27 PM Permalink
If you speak the same thing in china you will be killed immediately or at least put in a labour camp at some remote place !!!!
Hope now U understood the difference between India and Chna!!!!
RE:China's Economic Miracles
by Deepak MA on Oct 16, 2007 10:19 AM Permalink
There is no outcome even if you vote in India alright!!!
I didnt elect a scumbag like Karat or Karunanidhi.. but those rascals are dictating what we need....
What we need is an overhauling of the constitution that was copied from the US and British systems!!! The democracy that we have is actually "DemoCrazy"!!
RE:China's Economic Miracles
by vinamra singhai on Oct 15, 2007 09:26 PM Permalink
totally agree...current system is good for small countries only..not for big countries like us...but who is going to bring Presidential form of Democracy
