What a shame - asking Digvijay Singh whether nuclear deal is good or not ? Diggy doesnt know what is a good road in MP and after he took charge of AP - there also he has screwed up all the roads. First understand road technology then raise yourself to Nuclear Technology.
RE:First understand road technology then raise yourself to Nuclear Technology...
by Akhilesh Soni on Oct 10, 2007 05:31 PM Permalink
Excellent Sanjay,,rightly said :)
RE:First understand road technology then raise yourself to Nuclear Technology...
by Vijay urf Teesmar Khan on Oct 10, 2007 05:28 PM Permalink
Good comment.
123 Nuclear Deal is Best For Indian Economy. Suman Sibal.M.Tech Civil 123 Nuclear Deal is Best For Indian Economy. I really appreciate Manmohan Singh,India's visionary,for having made this biggest effort for India to become Developed Nation by 2020.Nuclear Deal will be benificial in all these ways: 1)India to attain Civilian Nuclear power for self sufficiency in Nuclear Energy. 2)Good Relations with America & all friendly relations taking India's Foreign Policy to New heights. 3)Pave the way to Attain permanent relationship at UN. 4)Become a Developed Nation by 2020. Best of Luck to Congress & Manmohan & Sonia Ji. Suman Sibal Highly appreciate Congress's stand. Congress should remain firm on nuclear deal. With Best Rgds,Suman Sibal.M.Tech. Mob:9910237788.Posted from Delhi. Email:sumansibal@yahoo.com website: http://sumansibal.freeservers.com
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by safarulla sherule on Oct 10, 2007 06:35 PM Permalink
I am M.Tech Chemical. Nuclear reactors are not good for India, America is a non trustworthy ally.
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by raj on Oct 10, 2007 09:15 PM Permalink
safarulla sherule Seems like you have half a brain. You damn Muslim fellow you hate everything . You born from hated. You guys kill each other. Killing is you prime job. You are nothing but murderers. Actions speak louder than words.Nobody respect you around the world.
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by uddhav raj on Oct 10, 2007 04:40 PM Permalink
suman , are you a son of kapil sibal
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by rabinarayana mishra on Oct 10, 2007 06:01 PM Permalink
are u son of any bihar goon????????/
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Sahadevan KK on Oct 10, 2007 05:19 PM Permalink
MOBILE NUMBER TO COLLECT BUSH MONEY EASILY.
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 05:01 PM Permalink
Balakumran does you Karunanidhi of TN is a disgrace to India
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by sai on Oct 10, 2007 05:28 PM Permalink
hahaha... diggi has fooled us(the people of India) again, he has got the discussion to point 0 ....the whole mess was about losing sovereignity and everyone knows that if India were to testfire we wudnt get the fuel ..now diggi and his hand party are fooling people by saying india wouldnt lose its sovereignity... In this world even brothers are going by the law(wats on paper) when they share wealth of their father,now sonia wants us to believe that the USA(criminal no1 of the world) would write one thing on paper and do the other thing i.e not stop supply of fuel and tech to India...
The congress party cleverly never lets rural India mature in thinking coz thats their strategy for a prosperous Congress party..
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 04:47 PM Permalink
2020 is vision of APJ Abdul Kalam, Congrees(sonia) lacks vision, they donot have any ideology and are devoid of any sense. This deal was for the future and not for today. BJP didnot go ahead withit because nation is not yet mature, it needs super raods first vision of BJP to have expres corridors. The Congress is trying to implement rejeted projects like seethusamudram an 123, since there are more kickbacks and less gain from economic point of view, yes if u require spend uranium dumps from US its fine, they will dump all the garbage in the name of uranium for india to deal with. Best of luck for blind people like u.
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 05:03 PM Permalink
Yes u r the only grace to TN and Karuna's b'son
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by on Oct 10, 2007 06:10 PM Permalink
BJP didnot go ahead , because BJP is not metured yet.
RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Himanshu Nijhawan on Oct 10, 2007 04:42 PM Permalink
Hey u r talking about 2020.. we have already achived that in 2007 by winning T20 cricket world cup. ( jus kidding). Yes i appreciate ur views , we need nuclear energy to increase our infrastructure and for growth of our economy. Manmohan singh is the person who knows econmy very well. Where ever he goes he talks about economics and developement even in "gurudwaras" he talks about business ( saw his speech at delhi's bangla sahib ) Indians should favour him for nuclear deal as its right step towards economy. And LEFT ,, what is left .. nothing. They should understand the demand of current society rather then jus saying no to each and every thing
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal is BEST FOR Indian Economy.Suman Sibal.9910237788.
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 04:49 PM Permalink
Taking is one thing and doing thing for real development is another. We need nuclear energy for meeting quick energy needs if that is possible with current infrastructure and the deal. You can have deals with other nations without this 123 can't u.
Kauya bhi pakshi - Diggy bhi leader! These rediff people publish all the interviews of bullshit people. Diggy is better known for his corruption and his obedience to Gandhi family.
Congress is pushing for nuclear deal for national interest. They are pushing it for their own interest. Seeing the reaction of rediff readers and various other news channels, they assume, it left withdraws support and there is an election they will capture the power of their own. They got lot of opportunity to change India aince independence - there was no left party to oppose them. But what have they done in last 60 years. They have given the country only corruption and corruption. It doesn't sound credible when the same party talks about nation interest.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by uddhav raj on Oct 10, 2007 04:15 PM Permalink
IT IS CONGRESS WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR DIVISION OF HINDUSTAN. SARDAR PATEL WANTED TO MAKE ONE INDIA BUT GANDHI & NEHRU KHANDAN WAS AGAINST ONE HINDUSTAN, OTHERWISE NEHRU WOULD NOT BECOME PRIME MINISTER OF AKHAND HINDUSTAN
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Balakumaran on Oct 10, 2007 04:26 PM Permalink
Uddhav are you the brother of Goatsy. You prove you are a BJP/RSS/Bagrandal cadre.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by uddhav raj on Oct 10, 2007 04:38 PM Permalink
I am not from Ravna Khandan( Rakshsa) like you, I am only HINDUSTANI & NOT FROM ANY PARTY,
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Akhilesh Soni on Oct 10, 2007 05:36 PM Permalink
history said ,its fact,, Nehru was biggest hunger of power and can't imagine his life less than PM chair, Overrule the national interest,,, and a failed prime minister of 1962 war with china
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Typical Jaat on Oct 10, 2007 05:06 PM Permalink
you are right uddhav congress is cancer in our india they are killing ourself.
they made pakistan for their personal intrest and now they also doing this deal in pressure of america
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by sai on Oct 10, 2007 05:36 PM Permalink
balakumaran this udhav is either communist or from dmk cadre,he is no hindu or anything ... nasthik udhav stop ur stupidity,look at the rakshasa in you,ur filled with evil...vishnu will surely take a new avatar atleast to kill people like you...
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Mahendra Patel on Oct 11, 2007 10:42 AM Permalink
How about GARIBI HATAO, THEY HAVE NO INTEREST IN GARIB ONLY WANTS VOTE,SAME WAY THEY USE OTHER MINORITY FOR VOTES.
Now, If we really want to Develop, Nuclear Tchnology Lets assign
16 BILLION DOLLAR FOR FAST TRACT RESEACH DEVELOPMENT ON NUCLEAR AND ALL OTHER FORM OF EXISTING POWER SUPPLY AND IMPROVE BOTH IN EFFICIENCY AND CONSTRUCTION/MAINTENANCE/POWER DESTRIBUTION and PRODUCTION.
I BET WE CAN GET THING ROLLING IN TWO YEARS.
ALSO SET UP 2-IIT's ,2-IIM, 2-IID in EACH STATE, MONEY WILL BE WELL SPENT, CONSTRUCT THESE IN SMALL BACK WARD AREA,SO RURAL AREA BENIFIT BOTH ECONOMICALLY AND LEARN FROM SMART STUDENTS.AND DOnot TROW AWAY EVERY ELECTION ON "GARIBI HATAO"-I DO NOT KNOW WHERE THOSE MONEY ARE GOING.
I think Nation BUILDING is priority, and not deviding nation on Phoney Scheme to Like-QUOTA FOR ADMISSION,BUILD MORE IIT'S, MORE MEDICAL SCHOOLS, BUILD TECHNICAL SCHOOLS IN VILLAGES-the YOU DON'T NEED SCHEME LIKE "QUOTA SYSTEM"
BUILD NATION ON NATION'S POTENTIAL, THEN IF WE DEAL WITH USA, RUSSIA, CHINA or for in that case ANY COUNTRY DOES NOT MATTER because we will be dealing on base of Strength.
I am For NUCLEAR POWER, BUT WE NEED TO BE CAUTIOUS,and need to understand what we are signing to ,we as Nation need to know, so that incase we fall in trap, atleast we find out ways to get out of it,rather than get despaired and fall flat on out butt, as it happened in past DURING TARAPUR FUEL SUPPLY.
So here is advice,DEBATE,PLAN FOR EVENTUALITY,BE VIGILENT,
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Mahendra Patel on Oct 11, 2007 11:02 AM Permalink
I lost part of what I wanted to say -But here is conclusion,
HERE IS MY ADVISE, DEBATE,PLAN FOR EVENTUALITY,BE VIGILENT,PLAN FOR EVENTUALITY,SO THAT IF FALL IN TRAP, WE HAVE SOLUTION,WAY OUT STRATEGY,RATHER FALL FLAT ON OUR BUTT, AS WE DID WHEN TARAPUR FUEL WAS CUT OFF.
IF WE REALLY WANT TO SIGN DEAL GO FOR IT, BUT HERE IS WHAT WESHOULD DO.
SETUP NATIONAL AGENDA,CALL AL NATIONAL PARTIES AND PROMINANT INDUSTRIALIST AND SCIENTIST.AND TELEVISE NATIONAL AGENDA,SWORN BY ALL PARTIES TO PURSUE RIGARDLESS OF WHO IS SELECTED/ELECTED TO RULE NATION. ALL PROMINAT RELIGIOUS LEADER OF ALL MAJOR AND MINOR SECTS
RE:RE:RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Mahendra Patel on Oct 11, 2007 11:12 AM Permalink
ALL PROMINAT RELIGIOUS LEADER OF ALL MAJOR AND MINOR SECTS and AGREE ON NATIONAL AGENDA ON EDUCATION,POWER, INFRASTRUCTURE, AND SWORE TO IT THAT REGARDLESS OF WHICH PARTY IS IN POWER THIS MINIMUM NATIONAL AGENDA THEY ARE GOING TO FOLLOW.
LET'S BUILD NATION ON UNITY STRENGH WISDOM, DON'T EVER PUT DOWN OUR BROTHERS ON NAME OF RELIGION, RACE ,CAST, OR POLITICAL AFFILIATION, UNITED WE PROSPER AND NOT OTHERWISE OTHERWISE.
LET MOTHER INDIA WE PROUD OF US ALL. AND BLESS US ALL.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Praleed Suvarna on Oct 10, 2007 04:49 PM Permalink
Dont see what mistake has been done in the past. See what is the need of the hour.
Power is the main issue in this country. Global warming is the main issue throughout the world. And for these issues Nuclear power generation is the only solution.
Irrespective of which government gets the deal done (Left, Congress or BJP), this deal is important for our country.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Dharmesh Patel on Oct 10, 2007 05:26 PM Permalink
Praleed,
You are wrong. Nuclear Power option is not the best option for future generation. For your kind information, Many European countries are shuting down their Nuclear Power Plant and looking for Alernative source of Energy because of safety (and cost of safety is also high) risk involved in Nuclear Power Plant and also waste disposal problem. Instead of paying huge amount for Nuclear Reactor and Nuclear fuel, why congress government is not developing infrastucture to utilise natural resourses for power generation? Why they are not adopting Efficient electricity distribution system? Why they are not spending money on to aware people about how to live low Carbon emmision life? Nuclear deal will contribute only 3% need of power and we can generate this much power by Alternative sources in less investment. Congress government is only interested in this deal because they can take some "Katki" from Fuel supplier group and USA is eager to make this deal because their traiditional market (France, UK, Germany, Denmark) for nuclear fuel are shuting down their nuclear plant so they want to creat a new market.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 05:33 PM Permalink
Because they think using Natural resources will be desi and Pollution spreading Nuclear reactor will be developed, Moreover the amount of kickbacks also differ.
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by Chaitanya on Oct 10, 2007 05:50 PM Permalink
This discussion reminds me the disastrous Nuclear Power leakage at Charnyobil in the earstwhile USSR sometime during 1960s. (If I am correctly remembering).
RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by raj on Oct 10, 2007 09:23 PM Permalink
Dharmesh Patel , European countries have reached their developing stage. They all have Nuclear plant and they are operational. Dont compare India with them. THey are self sufficient in energy. , (fance, UK, Germany, Denmark) for nuclear fuel are shuting down their nuclear plant so they want to creat a new market)PURE BULLSHIT STAEMENT. THEY ARE NOT UNDER THE CONTROL OF USA. YOU ARE A COMMUNIST. IT IS SO OBVIOUS IN YOU STATEMENT. IF YOU ARE THAT WORRIED ABOUT POLLUTION WHAT DO YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT OTHER FORM OF POLLUTIONS. ASKING PEOPLE TO STOP DRIVING THEIR CARS AND STOP FLYING? GET A LIFE. INDIA NEED NUCLEAR ENERGY.WHY IRAN IS GOING AFTER NUCLEAR ENERGY WHEN COUNTRY HAS SO MUCH OIL????? THEIR MOVTIVE IS CREATE A NUCLEAR BOMB AND BOMB ISREAL. INDIA IS TOTALLY A DIFFERENT STORY. SO MOVE FORWARD.
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal in the interest of Congress Party
by sai on Oct 10, 2007 05:41 PM Permalink
yes power is the main issue for India but not just the electricity power ...India has to be a super power,to be a super power we dont lick someones boots... look at what happenned to germany ,britain,to some extent even russia..If u look to the USA for help,it will surely misuse you till ur destroyed...coz americans care more about themselves than us.. well if India was in USA's position it wud be the same tho..
BJP will appose anything and everything the Govt offers. Its their policy to oppose everything. Only when in Opposition they take Rams name. BJP has fooled and betrayed all Hindus in the name of Ram. (Its a good deal - being a minority Govt congress cant do anything but its a shame on us electing the flopin MPs)
you have only one dialouge " you are a disgrace to India" I think your teacher and parents has taught you only this line. Grow up beta and talk like mature people
RE:RE:RE:BJP will appose anything?
by Chaitanya on Oct 10, 2007 06:03 PM Permalink
Ans: Because it is taking always RAM nam. It should sit in the religious functions, conferences.
RE:BJP will appose anything?
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 05:39 PM Permalink
HE is following Karuna. These projects have been rejected by BJP in Nation's interests during their rule, they donot want sick things. Congress isbent upon creating sick things again, which BJP got rid off during its governance. Congress is interested in sick things for getting constant kickbacks which I don't know whether thats in national interest. I thought India is a democratic country and any one must take a majority along to arrive at any decision/deals, majority means national interest, for other they have options to go to Pakistan, China, Gulf nations etc.
RE:BJP will appose anything?
by sai on Oct 10, 2007 05:46 PM Permalink
balakumaran bjp is not as bad as your so called secular education has taught you...i dont know if its really secular or pro-congress(anti india) education... but of course at the end not one student really becomes mahatma gandhis follower
RE:BJP will appose anything?
by Chaitanya on Oct 10, 2007 05:57 PM Permalink
Yes, I endorse your views. It is party of rightist ideology but taking always negative views in the name of Lord RAM. It has nothing except to quote RAM everytime and everywhere. It should not be in the political scenario. It should go where religions functions are being held.
RE:Sonia
by sai on Oct 10, 2007 05:59 PM Permalink
BJP initiated the deal... but didnot do the bargaining..Of course US only wants us into NPT or something as good as it..US wants to control the future course of india in world politics... When we know all this,ask yourself what is the kind of bargaining India neeeds to do???If we are going to end up with loss of sovereignity with no more future chances of being the richest/powerful nation in the world(superpower),why do we need the deal at all,we can all go back into the farms and grow our crops and eat them ,sleep in huts ,we would be living anywayss...Bala you have to realise the congress has got us a deal which would be useful for next 5-10 yrs but after that????what about pakistan ,who would save us from them??
Congress party hasnt done good bargaining,a deal worth scrapping and start the bargaining again... Ofcourse India needs energy but the USA would surely have given us a better deal had we tried every trick ,coz they benefit economically as well..
RE:Sonia
by Lost Indian on Oct 10, 2007 04:35 PM Permalink
yes bala can teach you indian History which revolves around the Gandhiji. So guys its was only gandhiji who gave us freedom. Bhagat Singh, Azad, Bose, Savarkar in short the people who did not go with congress are terrorist. And mind it again it was Gandhiji who gave us freedom so thei entire generations have right to sell our nation, first they sold to the Soviets and now the the Capatalist. In the name of progress we can do anything. First feed the population then talk about power and 10% GDP rise. Sensex has touched 20k but still in interiors of Andhra and Eastern India people dont have food, Proper drinking water. Buy Water harvesting and farming technology from US rather than nuclear fuel.
RE:Sonia
by Arvind Singh on Oct 10, 2007 05:44 PM Permalink
Please donot speak ill about Mahatma, this is not his tradition. Congress is Following Ghandian traditions means Sonia Ghandhi's tradition in this article. Any thing spoken Ghandhian must be thought as Sonia Ghandhi's right. No on can come near the likes of Mohan Das K Ghandhi, he is a genre above humans, he never said he got u freedom....
RE:Does congress works national interest
by Balakumaran on Oct 10, 2007 04:05 PM Permalink
Absoulety for you idiot, but you dont deserve it. U.S.A can make money too nothing is for free.
RE:RE:Does congress works national interest
by Raj on Oct 10, 2007 05:16 PM Permalink
Are you not in India. if it comes, good or bad is for all of us. US will gain money. That everyone knows. India will lose money and national security. No country in world will make a deal for 40 years... Think twice before you write things
RE:123 N Deal
by maruthi prasad on Oct 10, 2007 04:51 PM Permalink
it is a well known fact that all the communists are working for china and payed by them all are traitors
