Taslima is being shifted like a criminal. Has she committed any crime. Is writing books a crime? This is shame on secular India. PM should hang his heaad in shame if he has it of course. Singh is the worst Prime Minister India has had so far.
Her anti-Islam writings threw her out of her own country. Because she wrote something in favour of Hindus, he is supported by BJP. We spend so much of time, energy and money for these type of people who are of no use to our country.
Instead of taking care of Taslima by whisking her away from one place to another, security provided round the clock and giving other protections, can't the state and central govenment do something for the poor and downtrodden people who really requires support for ease their living?
RE:Why so much concern for Taslima?
by S R Ganguli on Nov 27, 2007 09:24 AM Permalink
YES FIRST WITHDRAW THE EXPENSIVE SECURITIES FROM ALL POLITICIANS WHO ARE 3RD GRADED AND WHO SCROUNGE OFF THE POOR MASSES.
RE:Why so much concern for Taslima?
by Songadya on Nov 27, 2007 09:28 AM Permalink
perfect point. BJP always play with hot issue. and get our hindu brothers sympathy.
So many people are chanting Taslima's name in TV chanels, news papers, web sites, everywhere. We beleive in democracy, we are Indian. But my friends, can someone explain me what do the words 'freedom of expression' means ? Does it mean that I can use abusive words, slangs, lies against anybody whenever I want ? Expressing of opinion and abusing is not the same thing. Would not you mind if someone uses abusive words against your father or mother. If the freedom of expression means, you are not supposed to react, simply keep your mouth shut and digest even if some one is abusing your father or mother or sister or brother or your friend, then I am sorry to say, there is some problem with the word democracy. Muhammad (PBUH) is much more than one's own parents to the Muslims. Why you never try to understand the feeling of Muslims when she abuses Muhammad (PBUH) ? There are millions of writers in Bengal, why none of those are having such kind of problem as she is having ?
RE:Freedom of Expression!!
by vijay k on Nov 27, 2007 09:29 AM Permalink
dear Ismail,, the problem with Muslims is that they consider relegion more than their own parents... Ur parents have given this life to u.. nobody has seen god... there is nothing called god in this world... The actual living god is ur parents and actual sayings of god is spreading love every where... not what is written our holy books like Geetha, Khoran or Bible... These book are written by some man with good creative thinkings which were suitable at those times when he lived... And we try to follow those things even now... Taliban says that according to koran watching television id unislamic,,, just tell me this... how could phrophet Mohd.. ban TV long before it was even invented... now for god's sake dont tell me that he foresaw the invention...
RE:Freedom of Expression!!
by Observer on Nov 27, 2007 09:37 AM Permalink
You have misinterpretations, Taliban is not an entity for you to have reference . Take reference from a legitimate entity and oberve ? 1.Are Television stations banned there ? 2.Are islamic nations without TV ?
They are much more developed today than your mentality is ?
you are such a sick man you know .
Watching TV is not moral and agaisnt the priciples of Islam , yes but you know what kinda of TV . Content with full of Adult and por**graphic content .
Would you recommend your younger brothers and sisters to watch Adul progrmmes or TV programmes which promotes or are agaisnt moral and social principles ?
Get your facts corrected and then Speak . Dont Mislead like a fool .
RE:RE:Freedom of Expression!!
by vijay k on Nov 27, 2007 09:56 AM Permalink
Dear Friend,,, Why is that u do not want to talk abt Taliban... they r considered the hardcore muslims... when did they become non entity to u...
RE:Freedom of Expression!!
by S R Ganguli on Nov 27, 2007 09:30 AM Permalink
Do you support MF Husain? Does freedom of Expression mean that a husband can utter Talaq 3 times and sens his beloved wife packing home to ther parents? Is this the law of a civil society. This cannot be religion. This is obscurantism. Taslima writes against fundamentalism. she has the right to speak against Muslim fundamentalism as much as a Hindu has the right to speak against Hindu fundamentalism. This is democracy.
how can we accept a writer who is insulting the relegion and wanted to get fame.When millions of people says the writings of the writer is hurting the relegious sentiments then she should apoligise and stop writing .She got all the rights to live the she wants but not this way.
RE:Relegious sentiments
by vijay k on Nov 27, 2007 09:18 AM Permalink
Mr Meer Ali,,, do u have any idea about the book she has written ??? and any idea abt what the story line is about ??? Dont go by rumors or some fanatics statements made by some relegiious leaders...
RE:Send her back to BD
by S R Ganguli on Nov 27, 2007 09:17 AM Permalink
Taslima has done nothing to warrant such a harsh comment. The mailer must be a paranoid or schizophrenic. If MF Husain can be honoured by the PM & the Presiden and his third rated nude paintings can be inaugurted by PM Singh in London, deliberately insulting the majority Hindu, Taslima's crime or statement of unpalatable facts is peanuts. Taslima as writer has only attempted to unfold the truth. Admittedly society is male dominated and the Muslim Society tops the list. 3 Talaqs can send an innocent woman packing. Is this a law of the jungle of a civil society? Taslima has still not got permanent asylum. She deserves it, i not for humanitarian ground then at least to counter Muslim fundamentalism. I ask the mailer to see the NDTV We the People programme shown on last Saturday, if he has any means to see it.
RE:Taslima-- should be honoured with indian Citoizenship>>>>
by zaheen usmani on Nov 27, 2007 09:04 AM Permalink
should all the Bengladisheis who are illegally staying be honoured citizenship?
RE:Taslima-- should be honoured with indian Citoizenship>>>>
by zaheen usmani on Nov 27, 2007 09:13 AM Permalink
Your name show you intelligent but i am sure you are fool or paid masaage writer of RSS or any other fanatic group
RE:Taslima-- should be honoured with indian Citoizenship>>>>
by Meer Ali on Nov 27, 2007 09:16 AM Permalink
why our people allowed her to come our motherland when she got disputes with her own motherland.
RE:Taslima-- should be honoured with indian Citoizenship>>>>
by life on Nov 27, 2007 10:02 AM Permalink
first of all,this is not ur motherland and secondly,her motherland is currently occupied by thugs(no less)
RE:Taslima-- should be honoured with indian Citoizenship>>>>
by Ravindranath M on Nov 27, 2007 11:01 AM Permalink
why? Becoz, she spoke something dearer to our motherland, by calling spade a spade, a shit a shit. And the majority in our motherland welcome it.
