RE:Taslima
by barun pratiher on Nov 27, 2007 11:13 AM Permalink
previously we know that Mr. Monomohan is very good human being. but nowadays, it is cleared that he is so cruel as like other politicians in India. i dont know why people cast thier vote to UPA ( Ugly people Association) a uncivilized party in india like CPIM.
RE:Taslima
by GN on Nov 27, 2007 10:57 AM Permalink
I look into your message as a good suggetion. As the assets have to be preserved. So both should be kept in some dark room, locked up with security. Vacum chamber will be more better.
Hey I do think we have far better writer on Rediff Discussion Board, they can not only write against Islam but also write again all the religions and abuses them very well, but no one is getting any award any threat, neither name and nor fame. But here all such people feel more safer and far bigger writer than Taslima, Guys keep on writing and attacking on each other religion because you are the real winners who can uproot this biggest problem from the earth that is religion.
RE:Better writer than Tasleema
by GN on Nov 27, 2007 10:54 AM Permalink
With so much hatred, these all people will end up killing each other. No wonder, why pakistanis, chinese know they dont have to worry much about india, becuase, it is already dyeing because of cancer named religion.
Taslima is a symbol of a person who wishes to get out of the establishment. She is a becon of light for true secularists where own faith can not stop you from self introspection. I read her controversial book. It is engrossing and vivid. She writes in different frames without claiming at any point of time that any one frame is untrue. It is a fiction but it reminds us the truth. It may even be truth too. India needs such Taslimas everywhere, in every faith as over the years our faiths have started turning naccistic. We have become blind. It is true that Islamists do not like to listen any evolution in thinking. They are static but what about we, the Hindus? Are we accepting evolution? We too at times do not like to listen to our head and think from heart. We need changes. It is life. Hindus survived over the centuries because of dynamism inherent in our faith. Every generation provides us with new Taslima and we change accordingly. It is unfortunate that Islam and its protagonists do not like changes only because someone 1500 years before forcefully said and claimed to be the last. Why such stppage of messangers? It is these messangers who kept on evolving the faith over a period from Adam. Remember that Adam was the first prophet in Islam. Even Jesus is one accepted prophet in Islam despite his preachings often divergent. Moses is another prophet, though Jews respect him more. Any static thinking is bound to turn into stinking cesspool. You have one Taslima today. There will
RE:We Need More Taslimas to Overcome these pseudo thinkers.
by Shajit Ali on Nov 27, 2007 11:14 AM Permalink
Sir/madam, you tell your view. But i have my own view. 1428 years before it was told (not forcefully). Prophet was the only person who delivered the message from Allah. no one was with him. He could not have achieved without the command of Almighty. The challanges given in Quran has not been met. Most of the super powers tried and trying everyday to change the verses of Quran. They could not. This is not because muslims. It is because the messages given by Almighty to mankind. I challange you is there any religios scripture which has not been changed? I dont want to talk about other religions. There are religions changed their practices over centuries. I am sure the changes will keep on occurng. It is obvious that there were people trying to claim prophet hood. did they succeed? how many prophets you know who has delivered the message from god and it is being practiced in this world?
RE:where are anti-gujarat bitttches?
by parag paranjpe on Nov 27, 2007 10:40 AM Permalink
where is shabana, testa, javed, mahesh???? missing badly in this entire episode.
Because of some of the low class minorties shouting to deport Taslima, why Govt has to act on that ? Who are these minorities ? Will they shout and demonstrate to throw Bangladeshis and Pakistanies who are in India doing illigal activiities ? They cannot and they will not
RE:Deport Bangladeshis
by GN on Nov 27, 2007 10:36 AM Permalink
Its the same india, where there are protest to BAN even Movies which directly or indirectly defaming any religion.
Deport all illegal residents in India, irrespective of their nationality.
RE:Deport Bangladeshis
by Aftab on Nov 27, 2007 11:16 AM Permalink
Oh Mr John ! Please stop this bloody low and high class. People like you want someone from muslim community to hurl abuses on Islam because you have established institutions for this purpose all over the world and the websites are full of such things.
We are forbidden by islam to speak against anyone.
Hazrat Issa was our prophet and we can not even think in our wildest dream about using abusive language against him. Even we are forbidden by Islam to uase fouls loanguage about the leaders of other religion and therefore we do not speak any thing about other religion.
For you it is easy to say that muslims are Bangladeshi/ Pakistani as no body will stop you from writing those tings to spread hatred towars muslims.
Go to Delhi and read the names of those who died for the freedom of India mentioned on India gate. Almost 30-40% names are of muslims.
You will hardly find any christian who fought against britishers.
You are talking about the commitment of muslims towarfds India.
Idiots like you need to read history of Indian freedom struggle before writing such offensive things about muslim.
RE:Deport Bangladeshis
by Deepak MA on Nov 27, 2007 11:13 AM Permalink
If you are a true Khan, they you are also a convert. From which angle do you look like a descendant of Chengiz khan???
Taslima is not a gifted novelist or a serious critique-what she has done is simply wrote some cheap novel insulting muslims and she even don't uphold any moral values..these are the reasons general public are gainst her-Muslims tolerate critisism and there are hundreds of intellectuals in the world who critisize Islam-what muslim scholars do is nicely reply to them intellectually-TASLIMA has not done any serious evaluations of ISLAM she simply ignorant about some basic priciples of ISLAM..why Sang parivar projecting her is simply because she is telling something against Islam..FREEDOM DOESN'T MEAN INSULT OTHERES!!!!
RE:TASLIMA
by Sahadevan KK on Nov 27, 2007 12:47 PM Permalink
Now the Left gets strength in the entire India, so Sangh Parivar loses the strength to do....
They lose the strength to do violence to change the direction from poor people's basic rites. They lose the strength to attack on artists They lose the strength to attack medias They lose the strength to attack Communists They lose the strength to Muslims They lose the strength to Christians They lose the strength to Dalits They lose the strength to escape from corruption charges
