RE:Hats off
by Raju Dalit on Nov 26, 2007 09:58 PM Permalink
YES, SHE SHOWED GUTTS MORE TO OUR COWARD GOVT., WHICH IS BOWING DOWN TO EVERY THING THE INDIANMUSLIM DOES NOT APPROVE, AND INSPITE OF THEM BOTH, SHE SHOULD AND WILL STAY WITH US.
OUR LEANED MUSLIMS ALWAYS LOOK THE OTHERWAY WHEN SUCH PERSONALITIES ARE TO BE PROTECTED. THE REST WANT TO KILL HER.
BUT IF MF HUSSEIN PAINTS A DEITY OF "KNOWLEDGE" IN VULGAR, THEY TAKE AN OPEN OR HIDDEN PLEASURE...
SORRY, BUT VERY SHAMELESSLY SICK MENTALITY INDEED.
Would you support the freedom of speech for a Hindu, if he or she were to claim one of the following,
- Sri Krishna was nothing else but a womanizer and an Adulterer - King Rama did not trust his wife, instead mistreated her with the entire "Agni-Priksha" - The existence of King Rama is a big Question Mark ? - Sri Krishna is NOT really god as he was NOT able to stop the masaacer in the Mahabharat
I agree that Taslima is being treated unfairly. She has a RIGHT to speak her mind. Muslims on the other hand have a RIGHT to protest, using all the tools that do not violate the law of the land.
Hindus seem to support Taslima, ONLY because she has managed to irk the Muslims.
If you want to support Taslima, base it on a principle.
"The enemy of my enemy is my friend", is not exactly a principle.
Think about it. Sooner or later there will be some Hindu who will question the teachings and beliefs of Hinduism. What do you think will be the reaction of the Hindu Fanatics ?
RE:Hats off
by Raju Dalit on Nov 26, 2007 10:21 PM Permalink
I just came back. Imran, tasleema never said a dirty word about Islamic Gods, like you imply in your msg. It is not a message, but a cheapman, streetboys abuse to Krisha or Rama in the garb of discussion.
Besides, you are not my enemy, but the enemy of yourselves.
RE:RE:Hats off
by imran patel on Nov 26, 2007 10:25 PM Permalink
Raju, I am not saying Taslima said anything bad about Islam. But her implication is that Islam is the cause for her problems and problems for other Hindus in Bangladesh.
I do not deny what she went through of the issue of non-muslims in B'desh. But cleverly concluding that Islam is what needs to be looked into in a stretch. She is neither a scholar in Islam. She is saying what she experience in her life and the same can be said about a Hindu woman who was abused by her own Hindu relatives. Will you blame Hinduism in tha case ?
RE:Hats off
by sahi on Nov 26, 2007 10:07 PM Permalink
- Sri Krishna was nothing else but a womanizer and an Adulterer - King Rama did not trust his wife, instead mistreated her with the entire "Agni-Priksha" - The existence of King Rama is a big Question Mark ? - Sri Krishna is NOT really god as he was NOT able to stop the masaacer in the Mahabharat
I am a hindu with his own personalized belief system. I personally have no problems with above. No protest needed for me.
If you think your God is God why worry about words from mere mortals.
Only when you are afraid that your God is not God you worry. All believers think they are so big that they need to protect their God from Taslima or Salman Rushdie or MF Husain. Come on your God has been around for long enough.
RE:Hats off
by imran patel on Nov 26, 2007 10:22 PM Permalink
Sahi, Critisizing Hindus does not make me a better Muslim.
My question is, why is the Hindu community supporting Taslima.
If they are supporting her right to express her opinion, then I am with you all. On that same principle we have to Support MF Hussain, even though we may NOT agree with what they are saying/doing ?
But if you are supporting her only because she has managed to Irk the Muslims, then we need to take a deeper look into ourselves.
Are you being better Hindus by suporting someone who seems to criticize Muslims ?
No banglasdeshi has ever left India on their own, thats y Indian population is rising day by day. So its not a big deal if you say "I did not leave Kolkata on my own", we only have to pull you all k_twa outof India
RE:Taslima Nazneen
by imran patel on Nov 26, 2007 09:53 PM Permalink
Well Om, I agree with you to a certain extend.
My question to all is, Why are we not enforcing our immigration laws ? Why are we not pushing our MLAs and MPs for action between the India - Bangladesh border ? Why are we seeing all these Bangladeshis in India ? Why don't we have the ARMY guarding our border ?
Here we are debating on Taslima, but don't you all think that the border is the bigger issue.
And please do not blame the WB government. They are idots of the highest order, BUT international borders is a responsibility of the Central Government. We saw no ENFORCEMENT when the BJP was in power and same under the congress.
And you know why ? Because as citizens on this nation, we do not give a DAMN !!!
When was the last time we asked our elected representative tough questions on bread and butter issues, education, border security, economy.
We have become like dogs who wag their tail as soon as some politician throws a bone of words at us, promising things that are un-realistic.
This non Hindu courageous soul did for your brethern in Bangladesh what ANY Indian leader or the Bengalis across the border in W Bengal ever did !! India has a shameful history of abandoning its own people just like Nehru made that Liaquat Nehru pact and forgot about Bengalis living in E Pakistan or the complete evacuation & terror of Sindhi Hindus in W Pakistan...The strangest thing is the lethargy with which a once proud Bengali nation switched over to being Progressive Communists and adopted a completely fake ideal of secularism....You will never hear any Bleeding heart Bengali from W Bengal talk about the genocide of Hindus in 1971...today a brave woman Taslima who writes about Hindu plight is hunted down by Islamists in no other place but West Bengal...shabashhhhh Bangali
RE:LOOK & LEARN Benglis
by imran patel on Nov 26, 2007 09:46 PM Permalink
Are you telling me that no Muslims were killed during partition or other communial riots ?
Tell me why you support her ?
Would you support the freedom of speech for a Hindu, if he or she were to claim one of the following,
- Sri Krishna was nothing else but a womanizer and an Adulterer - King Rama did not trust his wife, instead mistreated her with the entire "Agni-Priksha" - The existence of King Rama is a big Question Mark ? - Sri Krishna is NOT really god as he was NOT able to stop the masaacer in the Mahabharat
I agree that Taslima is being treated unfairly. She has a RIGHT to speak her mind. Muslims on the other hand have a RIGHT to protest, using all the tools that do not violate the law of the land.
Hindus seem to support Taslima, ONLY because she has managed to irk the Muslims.
If you want to support Taslima, base it on a principle.
"The enemy of my enemy is my friend", is not exactly a principle.
Think about it. Sooner or later there will be some Hindu who will question the teachings and beliefs of Hinduism. What do you think will be the reaction of the Hindu Fanatics ?
RE:RE:LOOK & LEARN Benglis
by Abhijit on Nov 26, 2007 10:00 PM Permalink
Yes Imran Bhai,
I agree you on all issues, including what you said about Rama & Krishna.
Hindu's are always open for discussions, when you say Rama & Krishna did great mistakes in their lifes, we also agree. But remember why they did mistakes, they did because they came on earth as a Human Being & a man has every right to err.
Now consider this, Prophet Mohammed has raped an 11 year old girl, hence in many Muslim countries that is considered as age of marriage for a girl. Isn't it true?
But why we need to explain this to you? You know it better than Hindus. Don't forget that your forefathers were Hindu only. They got converted by Muslim invaders, now as a Converted Muslim, you have become more 'FANATIC MUSLIM'.
Remember only one thing, MUSLIMS is a PROBLEM in every part of the globe. Get educated, try giving respect to other Religions.
You are the only hope for minorities in Islamic countries. The stupidity of Arabs has ruined the minds of one fifth of humanity. People don't realize how can God send messenger?How ca he send a book?How can he create everything for human beings? How can he be king of word.
God is mere an imagination of curious human mind. People don't realize this and do all stupidity in name of this imagination.
All religions are mere political gangs. Their so called God does not have any problem with your or anybody's writings thats why you are as healthy as anybody is.
Stupid fanatics just make it a question of ego.
Its the time humanity should get rid of religion and God
However, i just wonder where are our secularists when muslims hurt journalists and writters??/ Maybe they think it is brave and profitable to condemn hindus here and there.
also, muslims can kick their butts in their offices, so they keep mum,.,,,and make money.
RE:Long Live Tasleema!
by imran patel on Nov 26, 2007 09:44 PM Permalink
Mr. Pandit, You said, "Maybe they think it is brave and profitable to condemn hindus here and there".
Let me ask you one thing, How is it profitable to hurt the sentiments of 80% of the population and still be profitable.
You seem to be a learned man. But I am not sure if your above conclusion makes any sense.
