Kolkata can not justify that Rabindranath, Bankim Chandra Chatterjee, Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Netaji Subhgas,and such grand people .....citizens of the world were real thinkers if real thinkers like Taslima can not be accommodated. Briitish accepted thes ekind of intellectuals when they were a hindrance for THEIR rule in India.
Govt.of West Bengal should honestly try to bring Taslima back and give protection.Govt. cant succumb to the pressure of some Fundamentalists.They even dont represent the total community.Govt.should learn from the serious mistake already commited.Its a shame and cant be supported.Here every body has right to express his/her opinion.How you say its not Gujrat?If Taslima is not taken back we will think its worst than any state in India.
a) BJP's spoke person is a Muslim "Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi"?
b) There is already an alternative to Petrol. Tata and ISRO are designing first Indain car based on Hydrogen Fuels.. No need to worry about Muslims domination of Oil..
c) Taslima or other Muslims need to have guts to face the problems and do something about it. If Sharia has laws which are anti-women or which are not suitable in 21'st century then somebody has to take a stance.. If that stance is justiful then Non-Muslims have to support these effrorts.., That's how civil societies progress.. If Lungis are using language of threat then they should be dealt with strong law and order enforcement..
d) People cannot have 2 types of teeth. One for eating and one for showing.. Either people love India and keep it above religion or vice versa..
e) If a leader tries to lead a society in 21'st century and wants to improve the state of women in India does he have to plan as strong leader for all or does he have to plan on a communal basis. One plan for Hindus and another for Muslims..
f) Aftre 60 years there are still riots and bandhs, Isn't it is high time that disputes should be settled fast in court of law and not on streets...
g) Indians work together under foreign corporations, when would this situation occur in India?
i) Is it OK for people to vote across part lines or should people vote on the basis of economical agenda?
It's pretty obvious that fiction writer Taslima Nasreen invited by the Hindu fndamentalists to India is misusing the visa granted to her by hurting the religious sentiments of 200 Muslims in India and trying to vilify the atmosphere here.
Can she dare question the caste system in Hinduism , the rights of women and dalits in Hinduism , untochability in Hinduism , pratices like female foeticide in Hinduism no she wont becuase she has this nexus with the Hindu terrorist parties like VHP Bajrang Dal etc and is providing them fodder with her baseless,blasphemours,superficious,fictious writings based on lies and words cherry picked from those strewn by the media vilifying Islam and Muslims.
One can only imagine what happens when fiction is mixed with hatred, the result is losers like Taslima who have to resort to fiction to vilify Muslims to please her masters in Hindu terrorist parties like VHP , Bajrang Dal , RSS etc.
Its a shame that Hindu denigrate their own religion , now the Hindus of rediff have taken the stand that Taslima stands for Hinduism what a shame that Hinduism in India is really denegrated to writing and propagating blatant lies like millions of Hindus were killed in India and Taj Mahal is a Hindu Temple , Babri Masjid is Hindu temple etc etc, I have no more respect for Hinduism as a religion for the definition of Hinduism has changed to being mere vilified of Islam to take advantage of the international scenario.
RE:Its obvious
by QandA on Nov 25, 2007 11:47 AM Permalink
1) Your opinions are not supported by any facts.. So they don't have any substance..
For eg. Please answer this question, If Islam is a religion of Peace or is even better than Hiduism them how come it doesn't even allows non-muslims to enter Mecca. Read this link and also see the photo as evidence
2) Vinoba Bhave already started a struggle against untouchables and Hindus don't need any Muslims to improve them..
3) Sati practised was already challenged by Jyotiba Phule who married a Brahmin Widow.
First of all these are social issues which are there in every society and they are NOT HINDU issues. Don't equate Casteims with Hinduism, it's like equating seggregation with Christianity.. There is not a single Hindu scripture which endorses Castism.. As there are Shai and Sunni casts there are many sects in India who happen to follow Hinduism as a way of life...
4) Hinduism is the only scientific thought process which concludes that Human's can become GOD. It has no messiah, no preacher hierarchy and no concept of conversion or kafir..
5) If you are proud of your religion Islam then please share with us the most ADVANCE thought which is written in Koran. I will complement it by what is written in Vedas..
Well what can I say about the blatant lies that you have quoted with a layer of Hindu lies that are part of Vedas I guess.
Racism is the gift of Hinduism to this world where the four different castes are born from different parts of the HIndu god with lowest inferior caste born from the feet , the highets caste in Hinduism is born from the head and a Brahmin can be only a Brahmin by birth, any inferior caste who raises his voice against Brahmin will have hot oiled poured into his ears , so much for Hinduism being a SCINETIFIC religion which has space crafts what some MIliion years ago.
So much for being scinetific that the natural formation of shoals in the Arabian sea is projected as the man made bridge of Ram with the help of Monkeys to get his eloped wife sita from lover Ravana who took her again on a Space craft.
Dont be under the illusion that I am comparing HInduism with Islam for Hinduism is a socila system developed to supress the inferior castes of Hinduism by the micro minority Brahmins , as for as you asking me for one thought of Islam , its the egalitarian nature this one thought should be enough for you, though there are many .
RE:Its obvious
by rangarajan dikhata on Nov 25, 2007 01:47 PM Permalink
What is egalatarian , Islam He he . if it is what are the sunnis and shias fighting for. What about the Mohemmadis and the Baahai faith ? Please visit saudi / any gulf country . U will know what racism is . By being islamic uhave the right to subjugate women by marrying 4 at a time or kill them for honour . At least hinduism thought of space crafts which are a reality today but tell me one scientific invention by a muslim . 3 hindus have awardedthe Nobel prize for scientific invention what about themuslims ? apart from sending the people back into the early ages like living in caves islam has not achieved anything .
Your question has repeatedly been asked by many non-muslims "how come it doesn't even allows non-muslims to enter Mecca?". Well...lets simplify it in this way, do you all any stranger to go to your kitchen or bed room in your home. In our society we dont allow any stranger to trespass our homes ethics. We respect guests but it has its own limit and boundaries. With the same theme. We dont exhibit or prefer to exhibit macca or even any masjid. Because this is only meant for prayers in which human beings talks directly to Allah, the creator. We dont blend materialistic things to the spirituality when it comes to prayer. Thats the idea behind separating non-muslims from mecca but it welcomes you when you feel that you reached that level of divinity to pray in kabbah. To add in this I would like to ask one thing "Have you ever been to varanasi or illahabad in festive season. Have you ever noticed behurmati ( disrespect) of your own religion by your own people. Well I have seen it closely. We prevent people who doesnt have faith in Allah by not allowing them to enter Mecca because such people will have different intention other than spirituality. But yes we are human beings, we do mistakes, we have only screening system that is passport of an individuals. If you are really curious to know what is there in Mecca or Madina which we muslims are hiding. I would say get a passport of muslim name and you can bluff the authority to enter in mecca. (Allah forgive me for this
RE:Its obvious
by papun on Nov 25, 2007 01:41 PM Permalink
"Babri Masjid is Hindu temple"
Hey, what about the Gyan Vyapi mosque in the Kashi Vishwanath complex in Varanasi- check your history facts mister- It is historically recorded that it was built by Aurangzeb after pulling down a Hindu temple - do you or other lungis have any historical proof to counter that ?
He is just like Taslima Nasreen, insulting and hurting the sentiments of millions of Hindus...
But is UNPA/Faruq Abdulla ready to condemn him?
Before trying to start a debate on rationalism, social justice, evil brahmins etc, remember that Karunanidhi is 100 times worse than Taslima and that he has made whole state of TN a private property of his family members. His concern for Social justice is a joke, his whole party is now made property of his family, Karuna is the worst Manuvadi in whole of India.
Yet while some Muslim leaders are condemning taslima, they are silent about the Evil Karuna. They should change their views and oppose Karuna and his family business in equal measure
RE:WHAT ABOUT KARUNANIDHI ? HE IS 100 TIMES WORSE THAN TASLIMA...
by Proud Brahmin on Nov 25, 2007 11:59 AM Permalink
Atleast they are silent and not supporting Karuna, not like a loser like you who is all sucking up already with joy for Taslima has uttered crap about Islam , that enough to make you feel that you are a Hindu, Hinduism has been renegated to being a mere system of hating muslims void of any substance.
taslima, listen for your good. go to china, continue your writings there, nobody will harm you unless you. but you cannot even 'think' of writing against the CPC in china.
if u stick to the rules, you can perceive your writing.
by doing so you will be bringing peace to our nation also.
