First of all, I pity the plight of Taslima and I just wonder why she wants to stay in INDIA and it is better for her if she try WEST just like Mr. Rushdie did.
I just wonder whether it is ISLAM or muslims (who practice ISLAM) is scared of some books and writers?? Is this religion really that fragile??
Attacking her physically and now asking her to leave the country, are we really practicing FREEDOM OF SPEECH in INDIA??
RE:Islam religion - scared of some books and authors??
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:17 AM Permalink
And to think that we have a "secular" government at WB and Center. Had the same thing happened in Gujrat, Narendra Modi and BJP would have been castigated all over again. What debauchery and hypocrisy!!!
RE:Islam religion - scared of some books and authors??
by RKrishna on Nov 24, 2007 12:21 AM Permalink
Agreed, secularism practiced with double standards in India, recent Karunanidhi episode is also a good example.
RE:Islam religion - scared of some books and authors??
by Indian on Nov 24, 2007 01:10 AM Permalink
The FREEDOM OF SPEECH IN INDIA applies only to Syed Shahabuddin (who openly declares that he supports Pakistan against India), Imam Bukhari (who openly challenges delhi police to arrest him if they can) and M F Hussain who paints nude Hindu Goddesses while Communist and congress' twin fathered mo fo's stand with flags in his support.
RE:Islam religion - scared of some books and authors??
by RKrishna on Nov 24, 2007 02:21 AM Permalink
Well enough with the mockery of the GODs but can you answer me why you hate Rushdie and Taslima?? Why you people cant even stand slightest of the criticism??
RE:India Should Help Her
by Rakesh Nair on Nov 24, 2007 01:03 AM Permalink
IF WE CAN GIVE REFUGEE TO THOUSANDS OF SINDHI'S CAN WE GIVE REFUGEE TO 1 BANGLADESHI WOMEN AND SAVE HER LIFE.
Why should she run? So many terrorists staying in India from Bangladesh..So what if one women ask for shelter in our country Her sin is speaking the fact in Bangla.The only thing is Muslims never ever agree Women as equal citizen. They treat women as Second class.
RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by Rakesh Nair on Nov 24, 2007 01:02 AM Permalink
hi have u ever been to calcutta people there still now say taka for money which is bangladeshi term for currency and not indian as indian currency should be call as rupees or paise
RE:RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by anilkumar vijaykumar on Nov 24, 2007 01:32 AM Permalink
So What?Please take calcutta we will be free of this so called politicians belongs to you
RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by haresh jagtiani on Nov 24, 2007 12:08 AM Permalink
well said. but they should also think that they all were borne of their mothers. and mother is supreme. why dis discrimination against muslim daughters, sisters, wives and mothers?
RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:18 AM Permalink
This is an expression of the insecurity Muslim males suffer from.
RE:RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by vijaykumar vk on Nov 24, 2007 12:26 AM Permalink
Mothers don%u2019t have Voting power and daughters can not get driving license, don%u2019t have access to higher (co)education and can not go alone out of home. Even after a century nothing can be done to improve these Women status like Talisma..
RE:RE:RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:32 AM Permalink
Talking about it - this is happening in a country which has a "secular" woman President and a "secular" woman super prime minister. At the end it took a woman chief minister from the communal party BJP to save a Muslim woman from across the border. To pay lip service to secularism is one thing and to actually stand up and do something when the time comes is absolutely different.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by anilkumar vijaykumar on Nov 24, 2007 01:27 AM Permalink
I agree with you. Rajasthan govt. should have given the protection but I don%u2019t know the reason for not helping her.May be for security reasons or political reasons. We as such a big Democratic country we can not go out of principles. Either a Rajasthan CM or Indian PM obliged to protect Bangladesh ,If not then why you leave Tasleem Nasreen alone?When you can not help a single Bangladesh women writer why did you parted bangladesh from Pakisthan?
RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by shafi rehman on Nov 24, 2007 12:23 AM Permalink
this is not the question of descrimination its the question of setting things in to equilibrium, which you could understand if you understand the meaning of Mother , sister. just dnt talk if you dnt know plz
RE:Taslima, the writer-in-exile, is on the run now?
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:27 AM Permalink
How would you like to explain the concept of mothers through the mad chase that is on after Taslima? She has a point of view which she expresses. If the mullah does not agree with it, they can debate (assuming they are intellectually capable of anything except rabble rousing)! Why do these safekeepers of religion across two nations have to chase one woman. As if killing her or making her run from one place to the other will clean their religion of all problems?
We as Indians believe "atithi bhavti deva" Tolerance,is our cultural heritage.Let's show our humanity,empathy, compassion and broadmindedness in dealing such issues by guiding misguided and ignorant people.Let's talk of national integrity,unity in diversity and multi religious, ethenicity and varied cultures as our strength of thisvastcountry. JAI HIND
RE:Dr Tasleem Nasreen should be treated as guest of honour
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:34 AM Permalink
But do you think it is taught in Italy? How would our Italian import of a super prime minister know that? In any case she is more busy trying to secure her son's political future at this time than saving a woman!!!
RE:Taslima
by prakash on Nov 24, 2007 03:01 AM Permalink
Jeeo meri Curd N Lassi, your this statement is the best statement in last 14 centuries. All the awards must be given to you without any second thought.
just as taslima nasreen has been targeted by her own community, it is advised that even the Madhuri Fida Hussain (who is insulting hindu religious sentiments by drawing nude pictures of goddesses) also shud b hounded by the same community.
RE:RE:taslima nasreen
by Haresh G. jagtiani on Nov 24, 2007 12:13 AM Permalink
this old m.f.husain will not be hounded because we silly indians appreciate his doubly dirty so called paintings fit to be cleaned the toilets with.
RE:taslima nasreen
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:20 AM Permalink
Chasing down a hapless woman is macho but hunting down Madhuri Fida Hussein would be communal!!! Where are all the so called intellectuals who are willing to run out on the streets against BJP and Narendra Modi??? Hiding behind Italian Petticoat or Lal Dhoti?
Get The bangladeshi immigrants (illegal) out of the country (only lip service by polititians as its their vote bank) Mumbai, Kolkota & where not these people live off our land & shit all over the place.
RE:Taslima
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:29 AM Permalink
He just stated a problem. Can you help by providing a solution instead of gunning for him?
RE:RE:Taslima
by Indian on Nov 24, 2007 01:21 AM Permalink
Why dont you guys show your intellectual and writing skills on places where they help change mindset. I invite you ALL to come and write at Wikipedia on Indian topics. Myself and one more, we have been struggling for last one year to keep (what Indians think) correct version of Indian history, and you people are wasting time writing on pages that may not even be stored after an year. come to enDOTwikipediaDOTorgSLASHwikiSLASHIndian_Rebellion_of_1857 . Wikipedia can be edited by anyone and is considered by far as reliable as Encyclopedia Britanicca nowadays. Only thing is, write what you can prove, and discuss before making a major change otherwise someone will remove your edit just like you remove someone else's.
She atleast voiced against the islam, a desart base culture run by mullas. She is not running, the so called uncultured dogs are hunting her. She should adopt sanatan dharma of religion of human or hindu dharma the only true thought for all. She knows that all muslims are basically hindus. One such fine day all will get back to original dharma.
It is a shame for entire humanity, perticularly for Indians, more so for Bengalies and Rajputs. If we can give such a high place to Sonia, why can't we save Taslima ?
RE:Taslima on the run
by Passionate Indian on Nov 24, 2007 12:23 AM Permalink
Because the Italian petticoat allows some useless congress people to cling on to power? Can Taslima do that?
RE:Taslima on the run
by Manvar Rawat on Nov 23, 2007 11:43 PM Permalink
we have already given them pakistan and bangladesh ..... sabh de do phir hum kahan k jayengey
RE:Taslima on the run
by prakash on Nov 23, 2007 11:50 PM Permalink
Don't worry, Manvar Rawat. Very soon you have to give up Central Kolkata aslo as a new Muslim country.
If india is really a liberal country then it must give shelter to women who is afraid of fundamentalists. If thousand of illegal people can live then y cannot a lady. Muslim fundamentalist should not be so much harsh.They should not show foolishnish by sticking to their fatavas etc.
RE:liberal india
by prakash on Nov 23, 2007 11:58 PM Permalink
First you try the same with your m--, you perverted exploiter. Taslima is not like your s-----, she is an aclaimed writer of class, a dareing creative person. Her safe survival is a must for human mistory.
