will tehelka/ NDTV step in pl. and unravel the truth in nandigram..........wonder where rajdeep sardesai and his pals are right now. they were all over the TV when the gujarat incident happened....not a whimper in the recent times on the nandigram events.......OK maybe taking a diwali break ??
RE:where is tehelka....
by Lekha Menon on Nov 16, 2007 03:23 PM Permalink
you fool, didn't u watch TV? the channels were trying their best to show what happened in nandigram? There were discussions, debates, even citizen journalist reports...it was there all over...just like the Gujarat 'incident'. rest assured, it will continute...debates, discussions, big fights and all. but of course just like the "gujarat Incident", nothing will come out of it. Who knows, like your God, Narendra MOdi, Buddhadeb too might be elected with a majority for the next 10 years!
RE:where is tehelka....
by RAMESH MENON on Nov 16, 2007 03:37 PM Permalink
Yes! Modi is our God! You have a problem with that? If they are elected, they deserve to rule. Thats what is called democracy. So how is life in Kerala? Happy under christian - muslim rule? Should be!
RE:where is tehelka....
by Kaushik Barua on Nov 16, 2007 03:32 PM Permalink
How Does BORKHA do a story, it will show her masters in such poor light, prannoys siter-in-law and co brother-in-law (the KARATs). PLUS its not fashionable ..not enough muslims have been killed by hindus. Bunch of spin doctors should be hung by lampposts
RE:RE:where is tehelka....
by RAMESH MENON on Nov 16, 2007 03:38 PM Permalink
The funniest event was when an NDTV crew was attackede by the goons of their masters (Communits that is). Poor guys. Even in Gujarat they were not manhandled like this.
RE:where is tehelka....
by Haatim on Nov 16, 2007 03:23 PM Permalink
YOU NEED TO BRIBE THEM THEN THEY WOULD DO IT AND YES THE MONEY HAS TO BE MORE THAN WHAT CONGRESS OFFERS
Nandigram according to me is a bigger riot as it was fomented by the state of west bengal against its people. The state wanted to forcibly grab the land of farmers and handover to Tata. Poor farmers were not getting right price. Here a rich killed a poor. A goon killed an innocent. Whereas, in Godhra, 50 hindu were burnt alive by a mob of fanatic muslims. The place was Godhra, place which had the goodwill of housing ISI agents and fomenting communist riots. After killing of 50 hindus, problem started after 40 hours as such fanatics were to teach lesson. Whatever, Narender Modi did was fully justified. Why muslims living in gujarat and godhra didn't come out and name people who killed 50 hindus. It was their fault and therefore they have to pay and they paid.
This a true state-sponsored killing and its parellel in history is the riot of 1984 riot when congress three muskeeters killed 1800 innocent sikhs.
RE:Nandigram Vs Godra
by Lekha Menon on Nov 16, 2007 03:27 PM Permalink
yes, mr bond. How right you are. Gujarat is totally justified. "they" have to be taught a lesson. Even if it means by killing men, raping women and hacking babies. Yes, yes... they are not innocent at all. all of them deserved to be butchered. Modi is God, he has every right to take lives and commit the most henious and barbaric crimes.
RE:RE:Nandigram Vs Godra
by RAMESH MENON on Nov 16, 2007 03:45 PM Permalink
No Lekha madam, only muslims have the right to take lives, like in Marad. What happened to the CBI inquiry? Oh sorry, that Kunnjali patty forced congress not to for cbi probe , right? Also, is kunjali patty party still fluring its party flag in the airport by pulling down indian flag? anyways, all the best to you! 20 years and you will see how life in kerala is, ok madam?
RE:Nandigram Vs Godra
by on Nov 16, 2007 04:28 PM Permalink
please step into your backyard Malapuram district and try and say something like this and you will find yourself lynched the next day... Gujarat although unfortunate, happened thanks to all these years of injustice to Hindus in Gujarat. Please understand ground realities before you talk loftily...
RE:Nandigram Vs Godra
by James Bond on Nov 16, 2007 03:33 PM Permalink
Dear Ashok,
Correct your facts. When riots took place Manmohan Singh was at 50's and was not part of Congress party. He was included in the party because Congress lost its usual middle class base and they wanted to impress upon Sikhs. So the guy who had not fought a panchayat election, who himself was not sure whether he will be given any ministry was made Prime Minister. We saved many sikhs in 1984. Congress three muskeeters, like Sajjan, Jagdish and Bhagat did it and god in return will give them a cruel death. See how Bhagat has gone, they will also go the same way.
RE:Nandigram Vs Godra
by Ramesh Koushik on Nov 16, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink
true-one more fact is ignored - majority of the Indian media is supporting CPI(M) and the ir masters-ie the evil empire of the past
In Gujarat never any media was blocked or no oppositions or social activist blocked or attacked or arrested.. In Bengal Media cannot enter Nandigram blocked all oppositions and social activists. In Gujarat no NGOs or social activists or opposition leaders attacked or manhandled In Bengal Meda Patkar, Mamtha and intellectuals and social activist and media people are manhandled and arrested.
Still the people of Nadigram suffering without approving and signing CPM conditions (Not to talk media work for CPM fly CPM flag on top of house) no one can go back to their homes.
Anything such happened in Gujarat?
Gujarat riot was the after math of Godra carnage, and 790 Muslims and nearly 400 Hindus died, but anti national Media and anti-Hindu parties are just highlighted only Muslim sufferings.
Nadigram ruling party goons killing poor people for evacuating them from their home and land making land for MNC.
RE:No comparison at all
by bagsnsave on Nov 16, 2007 03:11 PM Permalink
You better be in Gujrat. MOdi and co need you . THey are ready to for outsource for election campg. let me tell tu Medha is an idiot ..good for nothing. she is not there in Vhidharba where thousands of farmers are commiting suicide. she need media coverafe issues. Mamata - a mad every bengali knows.( who are not politically baised like me). Even intelectuals are now divided, there always personal gain matters and they switch over.
Better donot support any politician..all are the same. THey donot think about common man
RE:No comparison at all
by bharat on Nov 16, 2007 03:27 PM Permalink
People are missguided by anti-indian media and anti-indian politicians. At least try to know the truth, Try to be an Indian and prowd to being an Indian in all aspects. Jai hind.
RE:RE:No comparison at all
by Chinmoy Nandi on Nov 16, 2007 03:33 PM Permalink
yaa Okk- I agree abt two person? But why do unot say abt CM? By whhose direction this operation was held on?
he have any feelings Opposition ? Nadigram is the gift of Centre Govt. to W.B. Govt? he is Brand
None of you who have written a msg actually know the ground reality. Let me tell u, I donot support the way Nandigram issues has been handled by left. But this doesnot necessarily mean we should blame along Buddhadev. 10 thousand people were hoemles for 1l months due ot moists with Trimool support. Now poeple will try to save there life and stomach after things goes beyond and that has happened and this time left to a chance to hit back. I must balme all the political parties of Nandigram happenings. Its a shame
RE:Nandigram issue
by Chinmoy Nandi on Nov 16, 2007 03:13 PM Permalink
who r u? who did u tell this news? i am not tmc supporter. but do u know what happend in kesh pur/ garhbeta? then Nandigram? I have enough knowledge abt. Garhbeta.
yaa if u tell CPM cader is right then evey thing is right- they tell water flow down to up.-yaaaaa - u r correct because u r cadder.
do u know what r they preparing during 11-month? that time thir cader have bnn triend by out sider such that they can kill so many people- who r not agree about their philosophy.
pl 1st try to understand this truth.
u do not tell like rolling party - water is floww down to up
RE:RE:Nandigram issue
by bagsnsave on Nov 16, 2007 03:18 PM Permalink
Mr. i donot support CPIM either. Read thru the msg properly. I want development for commons and donot support any political party or ecentrics. Neither CPIM not Trinmool..all are the same. Raja gele Raj aashbe, Rani gele Rani Aashbe...but tumi aami proja...u better think twice before supporting any political party. Check out Derek Obrain....how he is ruininh his career....in another 5 yrs he will be out of ET
RE:RE:Nandigram issue
by K.L. Kashyap on Nov 16, 2007 03:20 PM Permalink
CPM has been given the reins of power. They have the state machinery at their beck and call. West Bengal govt should have initiated action rather than letting loose of their cadre to settle the score.
RE:Nandigram issue
by on Nov 16, 2007 03:32 PM Permalink
If what you say is to be beleived then why didnt your CM allow the media or any one for that matter to enter Nandigram and see the situation for itself. And if the situation was so bad then why didnt he ask for CRPF 10 months back.
Sorry to say but your defence for your CM is very hollow.
RE:Nandigram issue
by bharat on Nov 16, 2007 03:17 PM Permalink
bagsnsave, As per your argument itself if a government cannot provide 10 thousand people security then Buddadeb or CPM has no right to rule that state. Who was blocking Media and opposition leaders and social activists then? Last 11 months no media reported CPM workers and families are suffering in Nadigram under the CPM rule. What is the difference between Maoist and CPM? Yechuri and Karet objecting Center when other states were asked more trops to deal with Moist. Yechuri travelled Nepal to talk for maoist. do you have any explantions?
RE:Nandigram issue
by bagsnsave on Nov 16, 2007 03:24 PM Permalink
No dear a common maan. who donot suport any political parties but want development for commons. u must be a fab of that eccentric women
RE:RE:Nandigram issue
by Chinmoy Nandi on Nov 16, 2007 03:37 PM Permalink
Are year who do not want development? there r so many district like, paschim medinipur(Salboni-garhbeta- chandrakona), bankura, purulia , whic r so many land r not good for agriculter, why not there?
1st want preventive acton-- we do not want like corrective action-thir need development transport- why they donot start
How can you compare Gujarat and Bengal as well Modi and Buddadeb. There is no comparison at all.
Gujarat is most developed state under BJP and Modi in India. As per the Central government various statistics Gujarat is far ahead than any other states in all spectrum of developments. Even central government is taking Gujarats project as mode for poverty eradication for other states. After 30 years of communist rule Bengal stands last in the list of development. There is no development plans at all. Poverty crippled life of common people. Unemployment is high. No proper electricity. People rioting for ration supplies no good road no new industries. As per Sachar committee report Muslims living conditions in Bengal is the worst in India %u2013 Gujarat Muslims had much better living conditions than any other state.
Gujarat violence is aftermath of Godra carnage and the pointing mistake of Modi is delayed controlling the riots. Modi never supported riots or never guided.
But in Bengal Chief Minister proudly announcing our boys recaptured the lost ground Killing poor villagers and raping women and killing who opposes CPM is controlled by state Chief minister and CPM leaders.
In Gujarat never any media was blocked or no oppositions or social activist blocked or attacked or arrested.. In Bengal Media cannot enter Nandigram blocked all oppositions and social activists. In Gujarat no NGOs or social activists or opposition leaders attacked or manhandled In Bengal Meda
I would like to ask a simple Question to the author If you are thrown out of your home and nobody from Police to Judiciary to State Government are able to give justice what would you do???? Wahtever happenned in Nadigram had to happen and it is easier said than done that wait for justice, restraint etc. Once it happens to you than only you realise otherwise you can write anything ranging from It is Goondaism, Communalism etc etc.
The communist always talking about the genocide in gujarat but they always doing a gunndagiri in the state like Bengal thats why state is not in a compitetion of Industrial growth while Gujarat is faar more ahead in the Industrial growth.This communist has a history of anti-natioanl . In our freedom fight they also fevour Englend. During war against CHINA they also fever China. What u call such a anti-natioanl element like COMMINIST. THROW THEM IN THE BAY OF BENGAL.
RE:RE:NANDIGRAM KILLING
by joshi mansukhlal on Nov 16, 2007 03:01 PM Permalink
Yes dear ur right this is the tendency of Communist. I am from Gujarat and i better know my state. My state doing best under leadership of Mr MODI
RE:NANDIGRAM KILLING
by prakash rao on Nov 16, 2007 03:03 PM Permalink
jyoti basu ruled bengal so many years by the votes of bangladeshi, they are ant-national
