When I look today to some so called intellectuals protesting against nandigram I question - Why they are called as intellectuals? Are they too intellignet to see the real face of CPM in last 30 years or does it take such barbaric incident to happen to unmask CPM. I am sure the act of voilence unleased by CPM is not new and is happening since past 30 years. Why people didnt unite and bought the bull shitt logic of CPM . Till Yesterday , Budhadeb was darling of the \'Bengalis\' and media. Sorry but to me it looks like - the intellectuals were the fools who got blind by their own wisdom and who didnt recognise the \'wolf\' who was roaming in the form of \'goat\' and was worshipped by all. CPM as per their idealogy has nothing to do with democarcy. In Westbengal in every street corner the congress workers fight with cpm and In delhi Prnab and team bragains things on their dead body. Prnab mukherjee has won so far with the blessing of CPM . Sorry to say but the well famed intelignetsia is too late to react -Its crying over split milk- Where you when the incident was hapeening -I am sure if such a protest would have happend in Kolkata the day voilence started in Nandigram -Budhadeb would have reacted? The Matter becomes worse when I see leftist intellectuals protesting -- ARe u shedding crocodile tear so that u can restore the glory of left again? If you are courageous -leave the left idealogy which lost relevance in China and Russia and work for restoring true democrac
RE:BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY
by Haatim on Nov 16, 2007 03:36 PM Permalink
Please dont advertise to get people into illegal profession of P*ROSTIT*UTION & GIGOL*O because that suits you only
You want to say that homeless person who were at camps for 11 months, should have styed there lifelong. You have not mensioned that from Jan 3 more than 28 persons has been killed by TMC-BUPC goons. You have not stated that during the last 11 months no journalist could enter Nandigram without permission from them (with assurance that they will only right from them). You have not mensioned that they have burnt more than 800 houses in Nandigram? Your article lacs statistics except propagnda. How much have you got for writing this?
RE:What you say?
by kalyan chaubey on Nov 16, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
Why the homeless people had to stay in the relief camps for 11 long months? What Buddha's administration was doing? It was their job to send these people back. They just sent cadres to give the people of nandigram(once a CPM base) a "right" lesson. Is it a rule of law? CPM sympathasizers do not like the very idea of media to discuss the subject. They cry foul as you have done disguising yourself under the name of the last non-CPM chief minister of Bengal, equally remembered for his unnecessary use of force. That "Siddhartha" is todays "Buddha". This article is representing the questions which are in the mind of all peace loving people of the world. You did not like it and cried foul because you are CPM first, human being second. It is not who has burnt whose house. It is what the administration was doing then? Why Buddha did not bother to visit Nandigram once after 14th March? It is not that what CPM has done or what the opposition has done. It is what Buddha has done under his oath. After Gujarat, atleast Bajpayee told Modi to do "raj Dharma". That means that man was humble enough to acknowledge what has happened in Gujarat was not right. But Buddha and the whole CPM leadership is arrogant even to acknowledge their mistakes. But it is altogether expected from a party of maoist/leninist or Statinist ideals. I want to ask you, how much you are paid to voice CPM point of view while it is out of the logical sense of every peace loving individual of this country?
RE:What you say?
by reet singh on Nov 16, 2007 03:51 PM Permalink
It was a law and order problem, to be handled by the police and not by goons from CPI-M. Buddhadeb Bhattacharya is worse than Narender Modi.A Hitler from Bhadralok
RE:What you say?
by nilmadhab mandal on Nov 16, 2007 03:46 PM Permalink
You are exactly talking like Modi and Buddha - the action reaction theory!
Never the less I want to contradict your false propoaganda! Here is point by point answer to your allegations! BUPC always agreed to take back all CPM caders except 35 CPM goons. It was for CPM interest that they kept ppl in the camp. Dont forget CPM also killed 100s during 14 th march. Never ever any journalist was stoped to enter Nandigram. on the contrary they were blocked to enter Khejuri
RE:What you say?
by Siba Mishra on Nov 16, 2007 03:30 PM Permalink
Why CPM cadres attacked and captured Nandigram? Why the policy and CRPF were not used? Its WB CPM's private property?
RE:What you say?
by SSS Roy on Nov 16, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
Homeless people has returned to their home after 11 months of misery. Is it illegal? Why CRPF took more that two weeks to come? Why TMC and other have not allowed police to enter Nandigram? Among the 28 killed one police person is also there.Do you know that?
RE:What you say?
by Samir Sharma on Nov 16, 2007 03:53 PM Permalink
Roy I like to point out that this article by Sumit Bhattacharya is one of the best which actually shows the true image of Bengal.I will ask Roy plz go just few kms outside Kolkata , you will feel how CPM cadres do to ordinary people.Roy please hear the song from Bob Dylan "Blowing in the wind". One more thing do you really think you are proud what CPM(This party started first) done to Nandigram ? Why the people of Nandigram gone suddenly mad ? CPM has MP and MLA from Nandigram so what CPM did that all their supporters turned against them ? It is not just "Amar lok tomar lok" -- the fact is because of this state Govt(CPM) many innocent people has died/ruined in Nandigram and you should be ready for getting paid back by some bombs exploding suddenly in the heart of city. And then you will all cry MAOISTS.And this is the reason how the Maoists ....takes birth !!
RE:What you say?
by Dipyaman Mukherjee on Nov 16, 2007 03:54 PM Permalink
You seem to be one of those born 'premeditated',loyal Communists. Humanity doesnt seem to have any place in your agenda. I personally beleive this article has been written in true spirit, it is only 'born' communists like you who are now searching for words and means to justify what your dear CM of CPM and teh party as a whole has done! When u talk about the last 11 months, do you who started all this? Every citizen should return to their homes, irrespective of party affiliations, but when u have started the blame game, please know your facts correctly first. Go and ask the Home Minister of West Bengal what did his force do on the eventful day of 14 March. And yes one request,before writing another article please get your English and spelling both correct!
RE:What you say?
by subhankar choudhury on Nov 16, 2007 03:55 PM Permalink
dear mr sss roy , why your cpm govt still keeping the police in the state? let them out , creat your own police force with the cpm cadres.
our chief minister(half cpm leader) said people from BUPC got the training from maoist , but where from cpm cadres got the automatic rifles and training to recapture nandigram?
Please dont forget young generation , students from Jadavpur University & from IIT karagpur students came and joined in the mahamichil dt. 14.11.07, so hope cpm cadres will understand times are coming when " they will also payback their coin soon ", this is not my line , this is the line of our chief minister Mr. B.Bhattacharya(who is first a CPM leader), and history taught us that.
Gujarat is the no.1 state in terms of investments.all the people in the state have prospered.West bengal on the other hand do not contribute even half by way of taxes of what Gujarat does. If given a choice would any Indian prefer Gujarat or West Bengal to stay.I am sure more than 90 % would say Gujarat.
CPI (M) and Buddhadeb on the other hand have killed innocent farmers shot them blank dead, raped their women killed their childre, stopped the media and other social organisations from entering Nandigram.CPI (M) has alot of bangladesh supporters some estimate it to be above one crore as it allows them stay illegally and uses them to do criminal activities by way f extortion and land grabbing. Poor Farmers of West Bengal we all Indians feel sorry for you.
RE:Dont insult Modi by comparing him to Buddhadeb
by Allah Talah on Nov 16, 2007 03:30 PM Permalink
What Haatim said is absolutely correct, this is the fact in WB, thanks.
RE:RE:Dont insult Modi by comparing him to Buddhadeb
by Shweta on Nov 16, 2007 03:36 PM Permalink
if God say some thing there is no reason for not to belive. but when you say you are God no one can believe.
RE:RE:RE:Dont insult Modi by comparing him to Buddhadeb
by Haatim on Nov 16, 2007 03:41 PM Permalink
shweta i sincerely hope you understand what you have written because I am totally lost by what you have written
RE:Nandigram
by Haatim on Nov 16, 2007 03:22 PM Permalink
for them Power is more important than farmers lives.Look in Maharashtra farmers are committing suicide and in West Bengal they are killed.You can understand how important farmers are to the Congress and CPI (M)
RE:Nandigram
by Chinmoy Nandi on Nov 16, 2007 03:25 PM Permalink
he was not sleeping when Hanif is arrested by Austrelia govt(I have feelings also Hanif).
