i doubt the intention of BJP by asking for a citizen ship to talseema, purely because she wrote against ISLAM? and purely becasue Indian Muslims did shown their non acceptance to her views?
I NEVER EXPECTED SUCH STATEMENT FROM BJP. I AM PROUD TO BE A HINDU, BUT AGAINST THOSE WHO ABUSE HINDUISM. But somebody try to break the unity of INDIA, I AM A INDIAN.
i have some respect for BJP's some specific ideologies, but this action really made them stand along with other opportunists like Congress and communists
Sumit represents the growing number of brainless journalists and psuedo secularists who don't know which end of their body is up! How do you compare burning hapless unarmed hindus inside a train by a planned attack from a group to state-sponsored media-locked-out armed attack against legitimate land owners who sought help from other armed people to help them? Don't compare Gujarat's spontaneous outrage that subsided within 3 days to continuous armed fighting that went on in WB. CPM has been terrorising ppl into submission for a long time - where were you all these years? You still have a lot of growing up to do!
The discussion board has been communalised. Rationality has taken a back seat. All sorts of messages are being posted to malign one or the community.
Look election will come and go but we have to live together and peacefully for the rest of our life and create a good environment for the generations to follow.
I find that some Hindu brothers have been led to believe that by hating muslims or non Hindus you will become a better Hindu. Read your religious scriptures or listen to the discourses on TV. Hindu religion does not subscribe hate and killings. Those indulging in such acts are committing crime against humanity and Parmeshwar will not spare you from being punished.
Listen to the voice of your religion and religious guru and saints and you will be a good person.
If you will listen to the version of Hindu religion doctored by politicians or religious leaders having political ambitions you will fall in the trap and will become a misguided Hindu or muslim.
Be a good Hindu, a good muslim and good humanbeing and become a torch bearer of peace and not hatred.
RE:What is Happening!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 23, 2007 12:43 AM Permalink
I have made appeal to all including myself! I am also partly responsible to make this meesage board communal & political. I have written political meesages many times in the past & I have written bad about Modi using amny duplicate names like Tataghatta, Contractor, etc. But now I want to improve & hence appealing to everyone.
Dear Ismail, Forget the misguided, the majority of people apposes bloodshed and communalism. Though they are silent self and not necessarily involved in rawdy behaviours.
The comparisons between Gujrat and Nandigram or Modi and Buddha are the outpourings of prejudiced minds and an exercise in prevarication. In Gujrat 10 Hindus were killed and another 16 injured in Police firing on the first day of rioting. On the second day 24 Hindus killed and 40 wounded in Police firing. In all 80 Hindus were shot dead and 207 wounded in Police firing. Shoot at sight orders were issued within 4 hours of the beginning of riots. Army was called on the second day itself.Compare this with Nandigram.4000 strong posse of Policemen sent to aid CPM cadre for "liberating" land from "enemy territory".Home Secretary declares territory as war zone. CM justifies mass murders, rape and plunder as paying back in the same coin. Brinda threatens farmers with Dum Dum dawai.Deployement of Central troops withheld and evaded by state govt.Demonising of Modi is one of the biggest Goebellesian success of Indian Secular left-lib media.
RE:No comparison
by suman on Nov 20, 2007 07:16 PM Permalink
I agree. Army was sent to Gujrat. Why army is not being sent to Nandigram. Even CRPF is being withdrawn for cracking down on marauding biker gangs of CPM.
Seems like the media cant even highlight Congress or Communists wrongdoings without blaming BJP and Modi. If tomorrow CPI(M) cadre get flatulence that too will be blamed on BJP and Modi and somehow linked to it. How about calling Indira Buddhadeb Hitler.
Buddhadeb Bhattacharya is the Indian face of a Fascist. What is happening in Nandigram is nothing less than a holocaust. Earlier in Singoor the comaradres raped, killed and charred young Tapasi Malik simply because her father resisted the loot of his land by the comrades for the Tatas. This time they killed, burnt houses, raped numerous innocent women because they want to live in their own home, subsist on the land they consider their only material belonging. Buddha like Bush divided the people between Us and Them. The dichotomy is terrible. Every crime committed against humanity by the comrades with chilling brutality is termed as 'morally and legally justified.' Buddhadeb is a greater monster than Narendra Modi because, after all, Modi never claimed moral sanctity for the anti-human carnage. It is the greatest shame that even after being thoroughly exposed the comrades are never tired of hoodwink the people with their old stale rhetoric in terrible idioms.
Dr. Jyotirmoy Prodhani North Eastern Hill University Meghalaya
RE:India's Fascist Face
by abhisek chatterjee on Nov 21, 2007 03:36 AM Permalink
Hey ranjan, Definitely u r a supporter of CPI(M). The blunt brutalty of your personal attack is an automatic proof of how communists react when they find objection
one must understand that when Jyoti Basu was the CM he was virtually boss of the CPM( & LEFT)also. however, Buddha is a glorified Cadre man becoming CM working under pulls and pressures from the party cadres. last week , the TV were full of talk shows on Nandigram but no answers were forthcoming as to why the CM could not visit Nandigram even once during the last eleven months to talk to or comfort the villagers. at least Mamata, a woman had the courage to venture deep and risk her life, even pillion riding a bike. besides, almost all the CPM MPs were talking in WE & THEY language. it is certain people of Nandigram cannot get justice under such a partisan dispensation.
It is a clear fact that only that region develops at best pace in which people live with peace and a feeling of security in themselves but in gujarat both this things are not available because one man in gujarat is not allowing it to happen. People here in the state have no faith in each other as Goverement is spreading feeling of hatred amongst them as they are not allowing all the religions to come togather. It is fact and we also believe that only NARENDRA MODI SHOULD WIN BECAUSE IF HE DOES NOT WINS THEN HE WILL REPEAT 2002 AND MANY MORE PEOPLE WILL DIE IN THIS STATE. I request you to vote for MODI or else he will again kill hundreds of our minority brothers and sister and many young bloods of the majority will been put behind bars if we didn't support modi..
RE:Support Devil for Yourself!!
by Sincere Citizen on Nov 20, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
Instead of blaming Modi why dont you prove his guilt and accept the criminal guilt of others too. Till now we have only been hearing and seeing people like Lalu, Congress pointing fingers at Modi. These people themselves are corrupt and have a very bad track record. Your appeal sounds like generating hatred by making an appearance of a weak person afraid of evil. If minorities were really so much afraid of Modi they wouldnt have lived in Gujarat or India at all. Fact is people like you are just highlighting BJP and Modis wrong doings while masking Congress and others. If you have the guts why not expose Congress or Lalu corruption too.
RE:Support Devil for Yourself!!
by arundhati singh on Nov 20, 2007 07:13 PM Permalink
the way you speak it seems you hate minorities, well india is secular state and everyone can live here. but obviously people like you have given birth to borders and partition. instead of asking minorities to leave any state or india why don't you get your fundas clear about things happening around you and accept wrong as wrong instead of giving up in front of a dictator. as far as lalu and congress are concerned, open your eyes and go back to that phase of india you'll find cases filed against them too, films reorded as evidence about their acts. but as it always happens they were in power, they were bailed and are still free same will be the case with your dearest pal Mr modi. after all its about people like you who can be that easily convinced by the rulers to go and kill the minorities and give birth to riots and other celebrating events in your list.
i think you need to do lot of research to know if there are any eveidence for the wrongs like your dearest pal Mr modi, Lalu, congress, BJP, and other parties too.....just give a bit of effort, i assure you will get the details but thing is they all have blind supporters like you, unfortunately some stupids in category of majorities . And instead of having half knowledge, oops sorry NO KNOWLEDGE about something stop giving your comments.half knowledge is dangerous but NO KNOWLEDGE is life taking disease.
RE:Support Devil for Yourself!!
by Vaibhav Pradhan on Nov 20, 2007 08:25 PM Permalink
Arundhati, no one is saying or justifying the killings of anyone here. Everyone has EQUAL right to live in India. But, EQUAL, not MORE not LESS. Right????? So, how do you justify appesement in the name of human rights???? How can muslims have more or first right over national resources? This unabetted appeasement has brought us where we are today and trust me, it is going to get worst!
RE:Support Devil for Yourself!!
by arundhati singh on Nov 20, 2007 08:45 PM Permalink
vaibhav i am not talking about more right for hindus or muslims, but does that mean we need to chose someone as our leader on the grounds of fear? how far is it right to ask the minorities to leave their state or country just because being in the category of majorities we are more secure than they are? people talk about different political parties as wrong, agreed, no one is taht innocent here but does that mean we should ignore what is on face?be it gujarat riots, nandigram violence, ayodhya rally....whatever, there are clear evidence for all of them but till date no action has been taken against any of the leaders becasue they are the powerful ones....and its going to be same even later. but if asking the minorities to leave their land is a way of saying india in secular state then i am sorry i wasn't aware of that. may be i am wrong, i am not ashamed of apologising if i am really wrong....but first decide how right are we being the majorities in India?
RE:Support Devil for Yourself!!
by Nilesh Wagde on Nov 20, 2007 12:25 PM Permalink
is that an advice or threat??? is that the way to handle things in life??? do you give up or surrender everytime you face a problem in life? if the minorities are in trouble can't the majorities give them security instead of letting a killer rule them??? i mean how can you ask for a support or vote for a man on the ground of fear??? government is supposed to look after its people and not keep them under threat. so if this government is not the right one will it be wise enough to appoint it at that power level??? the man who can commit such an act when not in power, what is the surity that he'll not do anything worse when he has powers?????? please thinks 100 times before you give such an advice.....don't try to impose your fear on others. look for the right support around you if you cant find one within urself.
