It is shameful to the country, what happened in Nandigram. I have not seen any person, like the Minister of State for Home,Mr.Jaiswal, Mr.Lalu Prasad Yadav, Mr.Mulayam Singh, Mr.Karunanidhi, Mr.Prakash Karat, Mr.Sitaram Yachuri, Mr.Bharathan, Mr.Ram Vilas Paswan as well as Mr.Mahesh Bhatt, etc. as they used to come to Gujarat to criticise Narendra Modi and BJP whenever any small thing happened in Gujarat. (I don't mean riots). Why these people are not criticising Budhadev Bhattacharya. Where is the human right commission, where is the Women attrocity cell, Where is the Supreme Court for enquiry.
RE:condemn any act against peaceful society
by Another Indian on Nov 15, 2007 06:16 PM Permalink
Why is that nobody is condemning farookh abdullah for ethnic cleansing of Hindus from Kashmir? Whereas we see every dog in India condemning Modi. So a Hindu's life is cheaper that a muzzie life? As long as we have politican-media-underworld nexus against Hindus there won't be peace.
RE:condemn any act against peaceful society
by parvinder on Nov 15, 2007 02:16 PM Permalink
Fight between different relgions, castes is understandable but CPM is killing their own BOng people just for votes only ? That is worst then any thing .. so no Bong is safe under CPM .. they can kill anybody for votes.
RE:CM
by parvinder on Nov 15, 2007 02:17 PM Permalink
Not possible .. an insane person has to be admitted to a Mental Asylum for treatment - dont leave him in the open, he might kill others.
Do you KNow BJP is Proud of Gujarat Riots? BJP wants to make Modi as next PM for Murdering Muslims.. Try to think with a Neutral mind please.. Is it Right What BJP is doin?
RE:Is it Right??
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:03 PM Permalink
Dude do not relate Kashmir issue with every muslim in India the army has killed more muslims in Kashmir than the terrorists killing hindus but the media will not project all this they will only project what muslims do.
RE:Is it Right??
by parvinder on Nov 15, 2007 02:20 PM Permalink
Ismail is always after Modi only .. he does not criticise the start of the riots .. who burned the train ?
Ismail .. people call you a Paki are right .. you are struck on onw ord .. Modi .. liek Pakis on Kashmir.
If you an indian and have got a brain .. criticise all but include Modi in the last.
RE:Is it Right??
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:57 PM Permalink
these people always saying these dirty things . thay know whou gujrat riots started by burning the train & who nandigram strted -by the selfishness of cpm leaders. do you n\know more hindus were died in gurat riots than muslims & in nandigram who are dying are mostly muslims by saleem groop of indonatia . when tahalka & cnnibn was doing story on gujrat comunist were shoutin after 5 years of gujrat and they were trying to desteblise the gujrat state now when they are doing masecare in nandigram they are saying please dont make this isuue a big issue as per my report there were 1267 people were killed by cpm cadders
RE:Is it Right??
by Haatim on Nov 15, 2007 02:38 PM Permalink
Ismail Bhaiya Riots started in Gujarat after Godhra.The Mumbai Riots started after Radhabai Chawl killings. You guys have always started the killings.The way you kill innocent animals in BAKRI IDD, if you had your way you would kill humans.Look at Saddam he killed 18000 Muslims look at Musharraf to be in power he is killing innocent Pakistanis.Look at Bangladesh
RE:RE:Is it Right??
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:35 PM Permalink
when your own house is on fire you are worried about the fire in the neighbours house. By 2020 Islam would be the most followed religion in the world. Every third person would be a muslim. Your children will be in touch with the muslims more than ever before...So to protect your ideology you have to work in your ranks. The more you get involved in hate mongering the more you leave your own house unprotected
BJP has no right to talk about Nandigram........ first he should answer why his own party massaccred innocent people in Gujrat.......why Babri Masjid was demolished .....What BJP did in Gujrat in a large scale, CPI(M) did in Nandigram......there is basically no difference between BJP and CPM.....they do not hesitate to kill innocent people for their own benefit........
RE:No Right!!
by parvinder on Nov 15, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
Fight between different relgions, castes is understandable but CPM is killing their own BOng people just for votes only ? That is worst then any thing .. so no Bong is safe under CPM .. they can kill anybody for votes.
RE:RE:No Right!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:09 PM Permalink
Please for heavens sake, some one tell the time when this so called "killing" of hindus took place in Kashmir. at what year that happened? who was the PM at that time? who was the CM at that time? is there any commnission set up? what are its findings? what BJP did for the 10 years when it ruled the country? please tell me? for humanity sake dont kill Hindus just for news sake.. Give an report of any news channel (dont refer to sicko VHP site ) The only thing I am hearing from kashmir, is the killing of muslims both by terrorists as well as by the army. Nothing else
RE:RE:RE:No Right!!
by Harsh Vardhan on Nov 15, 2007 02:12 PM Permalink
You can educate an illiterate who wants to learn but you cant educate someone who loves to be an illiterate.
RE:RE:RE:RE:No Right!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:33 PM Permalink
if u want to target the whole muslim community for acts of a few then ur intelligence is questionable. Yes I agree some muslims did bomb blasts and I condemn such acts bcoz in such blasts only innocents are killed. Any normal human being should not support killing of innocents but u have shown that u are an animals when u were very happy to see muslims getting killed in nandigram.How can u support killing of people just bcoz they are hindus or muslims I cant understand. They must have been the common people who go abt their daily life working hard to make ends meet. What if the bread winner of their family has died in the riots what is the future of their children. My only request you is to not blindly hate muslims, from independence till date can u tell how many hindus got killed due to bomb blasts. Werent we all living peacefully till Babri Masjid got demolished. Hindus are very peace loving people but a few communal parties are playing games to divide people and rule which will not augur well for India. High time people realize that peaceful co-existence is the only way ahead
RE:No Right!!
by PethuruRaj Chelliah on Nov 15, 2007 01:53 PM Permalink
brother, muslim terrorism is condemnable and even moderate muslims have to stand unitedly to tell pakistan and other rogue states to shut up. Within the context of our nation, who originated this curse of terrorism?. BJP demolished mosque, another religion's worship place, and celebrated that victory in bombay by killing several hundreds of muslims. Today muslim fundamentalists are showing their ugly faces. For killing 58 hindu pilgrims, Gujarat hindu terrorists terrorized the whole Gujarat muslims and butchered them as never before in the history. How come these hindu animals could take the laws into their hands and play havoc. My question is whether there is any difference between these hindu extremists and muslim terrorists? Whom do u try to cover up?
RE:No Right!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:05 PM Permalink
Dude after Gujarat riots u dont have any right to blame only muslims for violence. Hindus have shown they are also the same if not much better at carrying out organised genocide.
RE:No Right!!
by Harsh Vardhan on Nov 15, 2007 02:11 PM Permalink
you kill us once.. we will tolerate.. you kill us again.. we will tolerate.. You will kill us and portray yourself to be a good gentle breed.. we will not tolerate.. for its not just Muslims know how to kill.. Godhra and Mumbai are just the samples.. learn from them and teach your brothers the values of peace first then cry on Rediff.
RE:No Right!!
by bhimsen on Nov 15, 2007 02:06 PM Permalink
I have been reaing your rantings about BJP. But nowhere you have talked about muslim jihadis. Why do you always bring Gujarat? What happened in kashmir where your own brothers are killing themselves. Don't forget Godhra was started by your brothers.
You people will never learn. US has taken over all the Islamic world barring Iran (includes your country of choice Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Malaysia, UAE, Egypt, Turkey et al. But like ostriches you are fighting about Gujarat ad nauseum.
Brains and Islam seldom go together. Grow-up mister and look beyond your beard.
RE:RE:No Right!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:06 PM Permalink
Clean the dirt below your bottom, before cticising and trying to find mistakes, and shouting at the maximum voice that somebody else bottom is smelling.
Stop smelling others bottom. and stop criticising any religion or region.
Dont discuss the matter which you dont know about.
To just to reply you in the language even i might had said some bad words against Ram or Krishna. But I belive my religion is made to develop a good culture among us and by doing the above, i will defame my religion and the god i believe
RE:No Right!!
by bhimsen on Nov 15, 2007 02:19 PM Permalink
You still don't get the message. Can't you see that your poster card islamic countries are under western rule. yet you are fighting for Gujarat. Mr. Brainless wonder go eat some vegetarian food that clear your bowels and your brain.
RE:RE:No Right!!
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:56 PM Permalink
these people always saying these dirty things . thay know whou gujrat riots started by burning the train & who nandigram strted -by the selfishness of cpm leaders. do you n\know more hindus were died in gurat riots than muslims & in nandigram who are dying are mostly muslims by saleem groop of indonatia . when tahalka & cnnibn was doing story on gujrat comunist were shoutin after 5 years of gujrat and they were trying to desteblise the gujrat state now when they are doing masecare in nandigram they are saying please dont make this isuue a big issue as per my report there were 1267 people were killed by cpm cadders
RE:RE:RE:No Right!!
by Ismail Sayyed on Nov 15, 2007 02:06 PM Permalink
See the Topic is about Politics in India not about Hindu & Muslim. Learn to think anything above the Religious Divides. Am i not allowed to Express my view without anyone Questioning my Faith... I m not talking here as a representative of any communities. These is my personal Opinions.. Pls dont justify violence. Modi was an elected CM and was responsible for protection of everyone but he himself supported rioters to kill people. I agree that the Godhra incident was tragic but that was done by a group of mad people. You cant relate these 2 incidents and say Gujarat riots were fine bcoz muslims burnt kar sevaks.
The difference between Gujarat under Narendra Modi and Nandigram under CPM rule is that the reign of terror in both was revealed in Gujarat and hidden from any scrutiny in Bengal, be it press, oppositon, even CRPF was forced to follow CPM cadres after being initially prevented entry in Nandigram. The red flags are everywhere just as the swastika was everywhere under Hitler and the roars of mtorcycle borne CPM cadres remind me of the blaring loudspeakers that threatened to keep Kashmiri Pandit women in Kashmir Valley(without the Kashmiri men). Mufti Sayeed and his henchmen consoled the Kashmiri Pandit womenfolk by day and sent marauding hordes by night as early in Kashmir as 1986. No reaction came forth from civil society then thinking that it was somebody else's problem not theirs. Next time....... ASK NOT FOR WHOM THE BELL TOLLS, IT TOLLS FOR THEE. WAKE UP INDIA
RE:Narendra Vs Buddhadeb vs Mufti Sayeed
by PethuruRaj Chelliah on Nov 15, 2007 01:55 PM Permalink
please do not compare. Gujarat is a hill and Nandigram is a mole.
RE:Narendra Vs Buddhadeb vs Mufti Sayeed
by bhimsen on Nov 15, 2007 02:16 PM Permalink
No way, Ever heard of a commie fighting another commie and winning. Hence they look other way, rake up Gujarat, produce frivolous statistics, indulge in meaningless debates, shed crocodile tears for muslims but care two hoots for the dead.
RE:Narendra Vs Buddhadeb vs Mufti Sayeed
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:58 PM Permalink
these people always saying these dirty things . thay know whou gujrat riots started by burning the train & who nandigram strted -by the selfishness of cpm leaders. do you n\know more hindus were died in gurat riots than muslims & in nandigram who are dying are mostly muslims by saleem groop of indonatia . when tahalka & cnnibn was doing story on gujrat comunist were shoutin after 5 years of gujrat and they were trying to desteblise the gujrat state now when they are doing masecare in nandigram they are saying please dont make this isuue a big issue as per my report there were 1267 people were killed by cpm cadders
Absolute power has corrupted CPM absolutely in W.B. They always raised huge cry over Gujarat but now they r confident if Union Govt.takes any action, they'll cause Ministry to fall. This is blatant blackmail.
I request all concerned to show patient and go to the root cause of violence and study the whole proceedings with the help of all media before making a comment on it. Otherwise, it will fuel again. People have lost many things during last one year. They now want peace, relief, faith and honest efforts from all concerned to restore their minimum requirement. Do politics after they start normal life pl. Cooperate with all administrative functionaries.
RE:Nandigram wants peace not adjournment.
by kalyan chaubey on Nov 15, 2007 01:30 PM Permalink
You missed one simple thing. There is a distinction between "we" and "you" in Nandigram. Peace for one party means loss for the other. No life is "normal" under CPM. Administrative functionaries would not able to work unless the root cause is taken care of. The message of peace and harmony which you and some part of the Buddha regime are trying to preach is sounding like Bush's call for peace in Iraq after he had invaded Iraq.
RE:Nandigram wants peace not adjournment.
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:29 PM Permalink
I think Mr. tuhin is a comunist follower because when tahalka & cnnibn was doing story on gujrat comunist were shoutin after 5 years of gujrat and they were trying to desteblise the gujrat state now when they are doing masecare in nandigram they are saying please dont make this isuue a big issue as per my report there were 1267 people were killed by cpm cadders
RE:no comments
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:25 PM Permalink
because they are such a pakistani who dont know about w. bangal they know only one thing that always opp. hinusim & BJP
RE:RE:no comments
by MANISH MITTAL on Nov 15, 2007 01:50 PM Permalink
mr. or miss banerjee i think you have not gone through those narrow minded people . thats why you are saying this. my the way i am a regular readar of rediff & i have batter idia thet who is who
