Is Buddha the CPI (M)'s Narendra Modi? if Modi used the 'action-reaction' theory to justify the post Godhra massacrea, how different is Buddhadeb Bhattacharya when he says, "Those who resorted to violence in Nadigram were paid back in their own coin"? This wasn't expected from the CPI-M.
RE:Isn't he talking like Narendra Modi?
by Bappa Maiti on Nov 14, 2007 06:28 PM Permalink
1) Godhra Carnage was not started by Modi, but Nandigram carnage initiated by Buddhadeb and CPM.
(2) Gujrat Riot was also not initiated by Modi, Nandigram mass murder initiated by Buddhadeb and CPM.
(3) Modi might have been sitting iddle instead of taking stern action to control riot, but Buddhdeb and CPM actively initiated the mass murder misusing state law (police force).
(4) So, Buddhadeb ordered for the killing of farmers (Hindus and Muslims), whereas Modi did not order killing.
(5) Modi came to power not by muslim votes. But Buddhadeb and CPM came to power by common people and farmers' vote whom they are killing now.
7) During Gujrat Riot, Media persons had full access to move around (although it was risky), but in Nandigram massacre no media person was allowed, no minimum help could reach, all the junctions around 100 Km cirle were blocked by the armed CPM cadres.
(8) Rioter were not used police dress in Gujrat, to spread riot wehreas CPM cadres used police dress for the genocide (mass murder of farmers).
RE:Isn't he talking like Narendra Modi?
by soumali chakrabarty on Nov 14, 2007 06:27 PM Permalink
we atleast expected that he says the truth.Not lies what he has been saying all these days.
Why so called intelectuals & secular mouth pieces not talking. this shows their double standard, is only muslims who got killed deserve attention, is only Modi is Bad man? Whole political system needs a re-boot.
RE:Why so called intelectuals & secular mouth pieces not talking.
by Biswajit Gupta on Nov 14, 2007 06:30 PM Permalink
(all political leaders and so called intellectuals)
RE:Why so called intelectuals & secular mouth pieces not talking.
by Utkal Mohanty on Nov 14, 2007 06:33 PM Permalink
You must be blind. Otherwise how can you not see the protests by intellectual of KOlkata, many of whom have even courted arrest?
RE:Why so called intelectuals & secular mouth pieces not talking.
by Biswajit Gupta on Nov 14, 2007 06:39 PM Permalink
then whom u will see tomorrow marching who are they?
RE:RE:Why so called intelectuals & secular mouth pieces not talking.
by Biswajit Gupta on Nov 14, 2007 06:40 PM Permalink
is not sunil ganguly or soumitra chatterjee intellectual?
Buddhadeb is following the footsteps of his mentors Stalin, Beria and Mao Tse Tung. It is one of the most atrocious statements made by any Chief Minister in living memory. Dr. Manmohan Singh at one time called him the most able CM in India. What a shame!!
RE:1000 Rs
by Pooja on Nov 14, 2007 06:26 PM Permalink
May be all the houses made out of grass and clay ! Even Rs. 1000 will be more than enough. A socialist state !
THE COMMUNISTS ARE CERTAINLY A CRIMINAL LOT;THEY'VE PROVED IT IN NANDIGRAM. ALL THE FILTHY 'NATAK' THEY DO POSING AS WELLWISHERS OF THE PEOPLE IS TO BE CONDEMNED & SHOULD NEVER BE ELECTED TO POWER ANYWHERE IN INDIA!. LET COMMUNISM BE GONE TO HELL! IF THE ATROCITIES IN NANDIGRAM IS PAYING BACK,THEN SO IS THE RIOT IN GUJARATH!!.
