I would like to ask all my Friends after Independence of India. How many of the National Leaders have been killed by bullets or injured. For example let us take the Babri Mosque demolition, Sardar Sarovar agitation, Reservation issue etc. etc. did any Politician get killed. It is only the common man bears the brunt of Police fury.
I have seen many Agitation in my state. These politician alongwith his Cadre and Common Man gives big fiery speeches and incite the public. When some cadre starts creating problem, the Police safely take the Politician in their Van to a safe place and after that they use lathi charge, tear gas and fire on the public. The cadre sensing this cunningly leave the place and the AAM AADMI is caught in the Cross Fire.
These Politician are then put in House Arrest which is fully air-conditioned, with Doctors, TV, News Paper etc. They enjoy their life. They make us look like FOOL
RE:Why Not Politician get Killed why is it only the AAM AADMI always
by saket verma on Mar 15, 2007 05:40 PM Permalink
I agree to the fact that very few politicians have been killed by bullets!! I wish those 11 people killed yesterday were politicians like Mamta Banerjee etc.Tomorrow if her party was in power she would support the same industries.
RE:Why Not Politician get Killed why is it only the AAM AADMI always
by Varghese Philip on Mar 15, 2007 05:27 PM Permalink
I STRONGLY ENDORSE YOUR STATEMENT.
RE:West Bangal
by YOGENDRA gupta on Mar 15, 2007 05:24 PM Permalink
I think police should have fire you for not understanding the pain of the people... people like you will never become a freedom fighter you .... a suggestion for you just relax and trust that somebody is helping the poors... and prey to god or allah that you never see such a situation ......
RE:RE:West Bangal
by morpheus thyrux on Mar 15, 2007 05:44 PM Permalink
abbas i fully agree with you and u yogendra or nutcase as your friends used to call u in your colony....u r still useless! oh man...i cannot believe it!!!!
RE:West Bangal
by suman das on Mar 15, 2007 05:16 PM Permalink
Yes, you are the actual Communist who does not believe in democracy and try to kill the opposition.
RE:HI
by pinaki on Mar 15, 2007 05:43 PM Permalink
then what about our CM budha(deb?), Krishak leader Binoy Kongar, Left front chairman Biman Bose, and the so called king of Haldia(???) Lakhman Seth??? They are real culprits and violence creator.
RE:HI
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 05:38 PM Permalink
no she missed the bus.. medha, anuradha and the maoist were better than her.. she is trying desperately to make last minute amendments, so that she can get the credit for doing that
RE:RE:HI
by YOGENDRA gupta on Mar 15, 2007 05:17 PM Permalink
she is doing the right thing but not in right way.... the way govt.is kiling people is wrong.. and mamta is doing the right thing by opposing it but not the way by calling a bandh
RE:RE:HI
by YOGENDRA gupta on Mar 15, 2007 05:19 PM Permalink
you want her to get arrested .... why because she is helping the poor to get their right... if anybody takes your home... what you will do
RE:RE:RE:HI
by Narinder Singh on Mar 15, 2007 05:29 PM Permalink
No she is not helping any poor. That is the part of her election campaign. Look at her face. Does she look innocent?
RE:RE:RE:RE:HI
by pinaki on Mar 15, 2007 05:48 PM Permalink
there is no election in near future. after 4 years Assembly etc. This is a mass movement from the poor farmers against the forcible land acquisition from the CPM led govt.. This is the real fact friend.
RE:RE:RE:HI
by sabyasachi gangopadhyay on Mar 15, 2007 05:29 PM Permalink
she should be under house arrest since her intention is not remain by the side of poor farmer but rather to instigate violence in Nandigram and thereby to empower her political hold in the area..she has done the same in keshpur and will continue to do so but in vain...
do you know the Mayor of Washington resigned after a lady have been killed due to an accident and he cried in the time of resignation ?? this is a example of humanity
RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 15, 2007 05:10 PM Permalink
Mr.Das...then there would be no Chief Minister in any state....UP...Nithari....AP Farmer's suicide.......etc etc...
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 05:14 PM Permalink
No Mr. Nandy there are so many leader in left front to be a good CM. Buddha Babu was good but not now
RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by rohit on Mar 15, 2007 05:12 PM Permalink
nothing will happen to this lady....1st she will ruin whole of bengal..its still sime time for that..dont talk of humanity..these are all bookish things..for development u need industries..how much our farmers our growing foodgrains we all know..for years we have importing wheat, potatoes and onions.
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by Arya Gupta on Mar 15, 2007 05:23 PM Permalink
Rohit bhai...tell me...if theere is a fully automated ar factory in Singur and a Chemical hub in Nandigram, how many and which section of the population is going to get an uplift?
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by rohit on Mar 15, 2007 05:35 PM Permalink
lets say a minimum number of 15 people will get benefit if i be the most conservative but if its not built who will benefit and how mahy will benefit...whats the plight of farmers there..are they real land owners or farm labourers? or are they poor peasants...or are they the richest farmers in India
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by VSS on Mar 15, 2007 05:19 PM Permalink
Atleast therez one who can stand against the Communists. Communists r ruling bengal for 20 yrs and what did they achieved. They opened up for privatisation a bit late, 15 yrs after pv narsimha had actually implemented it
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by pinaki on Mar 15, 2007 05:53 PM Permalink
well said. CPM committed historical blunders many times. Forcible acquisition of most fertile land in WB - i think CPM can realize after 10 years and they will say " That was a mistake and a historical blunder".
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by JA on Mar 15, 2007 05:16 PM Permalink
good... so we should create SEZ on all farming land and should import food grains and other stuff...as our farmers are useless as per yr suggestion
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by rohit on Mar 15, 2007 05:33 PM Permalink
Of course SEZ has to be created...there is no alternative...as per the plans..all proposed SEZ will consume only 1% of all the agricultural land in the nation...and somewhere this land has to come from...
RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by suprotim burman on Mar 15, 2007 05:16 PM Permalink
you can do one think if any persons from ur company resigned then u try to relolve it and solve her/his problem. this is the example of humanity and also try to do some thing to stop the violence. Don't only write big words. please do something
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 05:24 PM Permalink
But suprotim you have to understand all things. we want industry (pl note i am not supporter of Mamta) but it may be other way, by killing any one? - so what is the different between Buddha Babu and Pol Pot, Edi Amin, Stallin.........
RE:RE:Chief minister %u2013 please resign with apologize
by Avik Konar on Mar 15, 2007 05:31 PM Permalink
resignning is his or her decission. forcible acquisition is not. If you give your land with your own consent its ok but forcibly acquiring is not right. So you pls give your house to the government if you are so generous
Bengalis have seen very little job Oppurtunities since independence. Thanks to CPM and its tactics. Now Mamta has got her PHD from CPM University. She is out to use its own baton to placate the CPM.
The lose is ultimately Bengals. The place was once the Capital of the Country and had prolific thinkers like Ishwar Chandra, Raja Ram, Swami Vivekananda and Netaji does not have any now.
Bengalis suffered from partition and later Nehru ruthlessly used the North Indian agenda to suppress the people of Bengal.
I heart goes out for the Bengalis. All you can do now is wait for TIME to heal your wounds.
Budha might have good intentions but he is now found himself in the wrong party which cannot portray his goals.
RE:Bengalis will end up working in Mumbai or any other state
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 15, 2007 05:08 PM Permalink
CPM University???? where is it in this world???
RE:Bengalis will end up working in Mumbai or any other state
by biz Narayan on Mar 15, 2007 05:18 PM Permalink
How do bengali explain the thinkers considering their achievments since 1940s. One thinker is a nobel laurate, he can't stay in his ancestral home but he is fine. he would wonder about that when english language papers point out that.
The thinkers invited Marxists, the greatest bengali of the century ( in my opinion) had gone away from Bengal, I am yet read an introspection by the thinkers.
RE:Bengalis will end up working in Mumbai or any other state
by suman das on Mar 15, 2007 05:13 PM Permalink
Lots of barren land are here in WB. What are they for?
RE:RE:Bengalis will end up working in Mumbai or any other state
by Arya Gupta on Mar 15, 2007 05:24 PM Permalink
It is better to go and work in any other states than to see these poor farmers suffering in the name of industrialization
I dont why people are making it a bong issue. Here both the parties are bong. Party which is proposing is bong and at the same time the party which opposing is also bong. Why are people going mad here???
Even such a protest was made in Ghaziabad (Uttar Pradesh), by Raj Babbar and V.P. Singh. Were they bong too??????????
RE:Industrialisation of West Bengal.
by ram deshpande on Mar 15, 2007 05:09 PM Permalink
why cant they have industry in the land which is unused for cultivation..... why they want farm land only....we can live without industry but we cannot live without food... try to get it in your mind
RE:Industrialisation of West Bengal.
by arup roy on Mar 15, 2007 05:15 PM Permalink
have you ever visited Bengal to make such comments. you should first the lock out factories of west bengal because of the agitation of CPIM before making comments like thsi
Politics is the dirty game of this great Nation. Violance of Nandigram has put our nation on alret.Such things should happen any where.Innocent people are dieing."Politics is the dirty game of this Great Nation". Immorality and corruption will disintegreat nation
RE:mamta hurt
by Arun selvan on Mar 15, 2007 05:11 PM Permalink
Jyothi - You are absolutely right. I would like to ask all my Friends after Independence of India. How many of the National Leaders have been killed by bullets or injured. For example let us take the Babri Mosque demolition, Sardar Sarovar agitation, Reservation issue etc. etc. did any Politician get killed. It is only the common man bears the brunt of Police fury.
I have seen many Agitation in my state. These politician alongwith his Cadre and Common Man gives big fiery speeches and incite the public. When some cadre starts creating problem, the Police safely take the Politician in their Van to a safe place and after that they use lathi charge, tear gas and fire on the public. The cadre sensing this cunningly leave the place and the AAM AADMI is caught in the Cross Fire.
These Politician are then put in House Arrest which is fully air-conditioned, with Doctors, TV, News Paper etc. They enjoy their life. They make us look like FOOL
