Cannot the WB govt offer TATA's land elsewhere ? I think it has become basically an ego problem of the Marxist Govt and TATA's as they dont want to be the first to blink. I also do not understand why big industrialists have to be constantly given sops so that they can lecture to others about competition , excellence, and what not about their great managerial and enterprenurial skills in facing challenges of globalisation. Can they not pay the fair and market prices for their inputs ? Or is it a conspiracy to deprive the poor of their only means of livelihood.
I think same matter you are pasting all the news related to the Nandigram. As the CBI is entering into the matter truth will comeout. It is required also. Both sides are wrong. Everybody should avoid any violence as life is precious. Please provide free hand to CBI, so that they will give the correct report.
RE:Muslims in disguise as villagers
by Anindya Dasgupta on Mar 15, 2007 12:57 PM Permalink
Where did you get all these informations my dear ? Do you know anyone from Nandigram whose land is about to be confiscated - Anyone not belonging to either of the political camp. Better still have you ever been to west bengal or just putting together as someone has mentioned "cut and paste" job from here and there ?
RE:Muslims in disguise as villagers
by pandurang jadhav on Mar 15, 2007 12:36 PM Permalink
Dear Iqbal What is real we do not know Butif it is true then really bad news. Anyway for land, police and government can not say that they had done good by killing people. Communist mentality must finish from democratic country like India. Or other way should we accept communism. Because two anti concept of freedom will never stay on same piece of land. Now I stay in Vietnam and I can see Communist country also give lot of freedom to people and never force anyone and surely they never kill people like Nandigram. If everyone get good returns of their land,I think no one will oppose the matter. Reliance SEZ planned in Maharashtra is good example. That sez is going to happen with good returns to farmer too. Hope you do not try to bring muslims and naxals in this incidence. You know naxals are childrens of CPI old age father,muslims no need to say anything as all crime and voilance is attached to muslim community as most of criminals are muslims and one and other way whole muslim community supports this fanatic way of living . Country like Pakistan is a breeder of all sorts of this jihad and I can this country is trying to sale Islam to world market for the sake of fullfillment of empty dreams of some power greedy persons like Mushraaf and some more devils staying in Pakistan. SO now is time that India need to think over and stop politicising issues. Still Naxals i do not understand what they want. Naxals and Maowadis must be caught and gun shot them all together as they are killing many people everyday in some states like UP, MP, AP, WB and Maharashtra.
RE:RE:Muslims in disguise as villagers
by Unnikrishnan Nair on Mar 15, 2007 12:59 PM Permalink
Dear Mr. Panduranj,
Gone through your message. After 25 Years of Communist rule also W.B has not developed. All infrastructure's are bad. so now most of the industrialists are not turning to W.B. To put an end to this Mr. Buddev Bhattacharya has taken initiative, against their parties policies to bring industrialisation to the State. However most part of the W.B is having farm land and more people are landless farm labours. If land owners are willing to give their land also how to compensate the land less and "to be jobless" land labourers?. Also some people are settled the place for generations and they don't want to leave the place. However for putting up industries, vast area of land is required and without aquiring farm land there cannot be any industrialisation in W.B. Hence only one thing they can do to minimise the aquisitation of farm land.
In Nandigram last few months the villager's had digged all the roads leading to the villages and not allowing any Govt. people other than journalists to enter in to the village and they are totally cut off from the main land. Any accidents or any emergency comes also no vehicles can enter int to the area. This was having the backing of some political parties.
Govt. Has decided to put an end to this and gone with massive force. People retaliated which caused lot of deaths.
Whom to blame?
If Central is imposing Article 356 then again with massive majority same Left front will come back to power and same time the left with withdraw the support to Central Govt. and they themselves will fall.
Hence CBI probe is the best option and with a vision and broder out look we have to see this subject.
RE:Muslims in disguise as villagers
by TSN Xumar on Mar 15, 2007 12:28 PM Permalink
You are cute - thats a nice cut and paste job - great for productivity - keeping pasting!
RE:Muslims in disguise as villagers
by Manu on Mar 15, 2007 12:31 PM Permalink
You can not defend killings of innocents by any logic. It is sad that for accomodating MNCs, we brutally kill our own people. Worse than Jalianwala Bhag.
