His grand father Gandhji was hero to Midnapore people who announced independence during 1942 Quit India Movement (the only place in India to do so other than Balia).
Its a good jesture by his (and Rajaji's) grand-son.
Police force is full of CPM cadres by appointment. With help of these cadres (legally), the illegal anti-social cadres also joined in the team to take control of farmers and farming land. See how brutal these communists and their cadres are. They even did not leave Women, School going Children. Oh my God, when will you save us from this brutal barbaric government.
the law is clear for taking land of farmers by any govt and none is above a law.in some cases farmers first sell their land-get money and then all of a sudden they want their land back or want more money-this all happens due to dirty play of political outfits landmafias and second part is govt takes land forcefully by many means to fill their coffins with money.the sufferer is actually our NATION.in present case all played a dirty game-mamta cong batteling for minorty votes and a diagonally division in left allies due to same reason has led to present situation.persons battling with police r not farmers but antisocial elements of area and BUDHDEB da has to suffer due to bad acts of leftists as there r elements of left who want this to happen so that BUDHADEB da leaves CM. any relief by SOMDA sitting in parliament-no as leftists has already played into dirty hands of their own, mamta, congress and hence why blame our HC to order CBI to enquire--oh put a review petition jointly--lalit
RE:it is a war of votes irrespective of growth of state and nation
by shambhu agarwal on Mar 15, 2007 01:18 PM Permalink
U r right sir, The latest example is from ASANSOL(BURNPUR IISCO, WEST BENGAL)Where the landowner`s are now demanding for employments in the company in spite of earler agreements for full payments in cash against the land acquistion by the co. for it`s modernisation.
After NANOOR , now NANDIGRAM . The result will be like this : 1. Some Police will loose there job & their seniors get a transfer . 2. News agency get busy for 2 weeks . 3. President , VP , PM , CM & other leaders shows their teared face in front of ELECTRONIC MEDIA . 4. LEFT FRONT supporters bark more . 5. MAMTA for another round of hunger strike . 6. State Congress show their impotency . 7. Low profile , self proclaimed leaders often visit to NANDIGRAM . 8. Some fake arrest ( with covered face ) 9. Bring back the GODHORA issue . 10. Sympathy from all NGOs. 11. Protests from self proclaimed EDUCATIONISTS, ARTISTS , senior SIDELINED COMMUNIST Leaders . 12. Fake announcement for COMPENSATION from all . 13. NO JUDGEMENT , CLUELESS END , finally LEFT IN LURCH..... waiting for another MASSACARE.
At least Hon'ble High Court is the real sane voice in the mileau all pointing towards confusion. But CBI probe is what irks me as this Premier Investigating Agency has become a tool at the hands of Politicians. A Retired Justice with impeccable record would have been a better choice.
Calcutta HC scores over Mamata Bannerjee, Priyaranjan Das Munshi and others by asking for a CBI probe before they could. This is not fair. The judges can ask for and get more than Mamata Didi and co because they have more power without any responsibilities.
The CPM takes WB as their inheritance and now days they rule the state like that. We outsiders don't know the exact picture of Naindigram but sure there is something rotten. May this be the beginning of the end of CPM's fiefdom in W.B. May God help the W.B. people.
RE:End of Marxist Era in W.B.
by Mr. Ujjal Bhanu Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 12:55 PM Permalink
I don't know why people are shouting against the ruler, without knowing the truth. For last 2 and half month, the Nandigram Thana area was under the control of villegers, they were not allowing any government officials to enter inside the villages. When a village in J&K behaves like this, we can send troops to destroy the village and the villagers, but its getting terrible and horror when it happens in Bengal?
RE:RE:End of Marxist Era in W.B.
by PAL on Mar 15, 2007 01:17 PM Permalink
Mr Ujjal Bhanu Ghosh is a real sheep and unhuman. My suggestion to you is visit vilalge and take decision rather sitting in front of monitor and AC room.
RE:RE:RE:End of Marxist Era in W.B.
by Mr. Ujjal Bhanu Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 01:28 PM Permalink
I spent half of my 30 years life in a remote village in Keshpur. Perhaps you know the name.
Mamata Banerjee is to blame for all these, her destructive and disruptive politics, always instigating militancy among the poor and innocent people to fight aganist the State, and having political game with their sufferings.
Mamata has done this in the yesteryers and gained much momentum, but lost all as people came to understand her dirty politics.
Many people suffered under the influence of her instigation, and is still suffering, as Nandigram does.
She is misleads people, lies, makes up gimmicky stories, and goes on gimmicking.
She is aganist development as if West Bengal Govt succeds in its industrilization drive and development, she will lose even the 30 seats she managed in the last elections.
And will only be left to cry like kids with allegations of political rigging, scientific rigging, mechanised rigging, blah blah ....
She could be a good story writer....but as a politician.......she should he HANGED
RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 12:53 PM Permalink
Dibyendu, u r welcome to hang me, but u have to put up a solid cause for it. Ha Ha.
RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 12:52 PM Permalink
Mind your language. DId u learn it from your mother?
And what did you say? "Bangalis r traitors" Which community do you belong? Probably any inferior/backward one.
I think you are uneducated. Poke in history books in the Freedom struggle chapters, and you will find a majority of them Bengalis, who you call traitors, and do not give that 1962 China War issue. Everybody knows that was a gimmick used by the central govt to crush communist movement in India, which did not succeed.
RE:Mamata is to blame
by pandurang jadhav on Mar 15, 2007 12:45 PM Permalink
Keep silent and do not talk any thing nonsense If mamtha is wrong then your Buddhadev is right . What is this dirty politics you are talking. So it means you support killing so those 11 people. Shame on you. Bangalis educated by degrees but surely not by mind. Come on now world is changing .
RE:RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 12:58 PM Permalink
Bhaskar, I read ur previous messages on Nandigram. If I am a classic CPIM cadre then you are a classic Trinamool activist, bred on nothing, as your party does not have that culture or ability to educate its own people.
RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 01:02 PM Permalink
Mr. Jadhav, your message is okay. As I can, u can also express your own likings or dislikings. But what is this, why do you use the word "Bangalis"? Firstly, u should know it would be "Bengali". Ok. Now, all bengalis do not agree with me. May be I am wrong, but why are you blaming them also?
This shows your own inferiority about your own community, to which you belong.
RE:Mamata is to blame
by Jas Sand on Mar 15, 2007 01:12 PM Permalink
Mr. Bhattacharya,
The CPIM is doing the smae thing at the National Level - Opposing the Development everywhere. Isnt this a calssic case of the pot calling hte kettle black?
RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 01:26 PM Permalink
You may be right. Double standrand happens in politics. But we, common people of West Bengal want to see the maximum gain we can harvest. There is no 100% good thing, so we have to consider that have at least 70-80% good in it. Ist that?
RE:Mamata is to blame
by nilmadhab mandal on Mar 15, 2007 01:01 PM Permalink
Mr.Bhattacharya it seems you not only share the surname with the CM also share the same facist (u understand the word more often than others..hopefully..know the meaning!!)..mentality!!
what a twist in your story!! when CPM did agitation for last 4 decades (hope u wont deny that even!!)...u call it..peoples'movement..when ppl protest...your police shoot them..you call it Mamta instigated them!! While live TV shows Mamata was not even allowed to enter...becoz 1000 of CMP caders barricaded..!! cant you see live TV? are you guys so away from ppl...i am not a TC supporter..neither i have ever vorted her..but its pplz movement..and if you close your eyes..read the world history..to see your fate!
what development are you taking of? come out of your state..to see the development...you know the whole sufering of common ppl could have been averted if you could build industry in arid districts..but you will argue as these are not developed..now who is to be responsible for the underdevelopment for this districts? definite who ruled the state for last 30 years..go to Gujrata and see how they build roads, amenities..in the arid lands and have min. 100 times more industry than your party even dream off..so thats the way to develop...dont bring industry (and to top it all...a non descript grp called Salim)..at the bloodshed..!!
RE:RE:Mamata is to blame
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Mar 15, 2007 01:20 PM Permalink
Mr Mandal World History says...Communist uprooted......Democracy restored.....Communists return to power with peoples vote.....THEN WHAT IS THE FATE?
Firing by police is the last option. Just get down clam and think why did police fire on innocent people?
And give your opinion about when those "innocent people" killed seven people who did not support their cause, earlier and even dared to kill a Police Officer.
The questions always arises, Why? Did they confront police eye-to-eye? Intelligence reports says they assembled large amount of firearms and crude bombs in self defence. So, what you expect?
Those innocent people are instigated for days and months, not yesterday itself, to fight aganist the State, for someone's political gameplan and milage, and it happened.
So, who is to blame?
In a murder case, the Judge does not merely see who murdered, but the motive, and in what situation the murder took place, it is cold-blooded or in self defence, and the question of instigation is also taken into account.
Gujarat have a lot of arid land, you learn by topography of that region, it is easier to build 100 times more industry there. In West Bengal, it is very difficult, moreover, ours is the most densely polupated state in India with a lot of agricultural land. There are little arid regions, I agree, but they are not well connected. SO, if we want industry, we have no option but to take low-yeilding regions which produced 1-2 crops a year. When such a region is selected, it is possible that a few acres among it could be 3-4 crop producing, but if that percentage is low, we must go by it. Think logically. I am not a CPIM cadre, as someone told earlier, but I want to think and want to see the future gains.
May be I am right or may be I am wrong. Please let me known your views.
Nice to read your arguments. I am happy if communist come back with vengeance...as an ideology..none can deny its humane aspect.
I am cool down enough...I will tell you why police gun down? To prove that local MP is the boss! show me one sign ..where..police was hurt by bomb or pipegun..show me one footage? this is story..and now u understand why CPM ddint allow jurnos..inside..for the whole day..Hear Binay konar and the party line'..i quote"ppl cann't stay out of home for long"..yes that is the fact..for sudden urge to enforce rule of law..remember Mr. Bush...and you will find exact similarity...in the excuse..given by him and CPM..both are concoted story..see your argument "intelligence report..large gathering of bombs..etc..sounds like WMD of Iraq...sorry..not convincing?? even if you have the privy of the spl. report,..then..how come that enetr Nandigram? whose failure?
If i take of your wallet..do u require somebody to instigate? what are u talking off man? hear even Mr. Sumity sarkar..part of the fact finding team..you will belive the fact finding team..in Gujrat riot,,biut not here..that moulding the truth ...and Mr. sumit sarkar is not famous for supporting capitailist!! Yes, I am talking of kotive only..if u feel motive was to enforce rule of law...i am sorry...u are sleeping awake...none can awake you!!
Yes, Comrade state incident should be investigate by central agency only otherwise they never accept their mistake. Every issue when any government uses police forces immediately CPM (I) first reaction is excessive of police force but when it was happened their own state than Comrade Sitaram Yechuri says public has thrown the stones over police force and outside people joined with agitated people. Sorry comrade, speak in on voice do not change your tone time to time depend on situation
