I guess Honbl High Court has made a mistake- it should have asked to form a enquirey commisssion with B. Bhattacharya as its head & other CPI-M memebers as its members- afterall the results will be same as CBI enquiery- infact we can expect a conclusion with this commission- where as with CBI time= sky is the limit (remember Q case?)
i dont think buddha babu would order killing innocent people. I doubt mamta is also misusing this tragedy,as we know politics and politicians. i condemn this killing of villagers and and doubly condemn the CPI (m) party for considering ego and righteousness of stand bigger than peoples' life. I was supporting buddha babu all along but was aware of cpi (m)'s 'Total control' ....i feel like losing a game i was playing against mamta.
Hello Friends Are you aware of the thing we have a Prime Minister??? Hello Hello?. Its pathetic to have such prime minister sits quiet and nothing to say on this incident. I am pity to see Mr. Shivraj Patil, (dont ask me who is he? He is our Home Minister)defending firing in the Lok Sabha in a (english) language that majority of this country doesnt undrestand. Come on Prime Minister pl get up from the sleep and say something about the Nandigram incident. Any I am pity about Indians, we are treated like animals no body care for our lives, but recent killing of one MP from Jharkand, Govt finds time to send home minister to the state, but for this Govt is mum and said nothing. My condolenses for all those my fellow Indian citizens killed at Nandigram. And also with a request to big business men like Mr.Mukesh Ambani, Mr. Ratan Tata, please reconsider your proposals, dont take it as prestige issue, please reconsider and say business is not more than the fellow Indians killings.
RE:CBI Probe into Nandigram Firing
by allen on Mar 15, 2007 05:39 PM Permalink
Is Nandigram a seperate nation ????...whr police cannot patrol !!!!.... For kind information to all ..the police were not able to enter Nandigram from last 30 days... Whatz dis ?? U cannot hv ur own Independent nation status dere ...!!! I am sure the marginal farmers in India meet the same fate... malnourishment...disease ... under heavy debt and finally suicide.... look at Maharastra , Andhra . The industrial development is the only panacea to all ills. MAMATA and some irresposible rascals are pushing Bengal to become another Bihar...with no employment oppurtunity and plenty of cheap .. exploitable labour for other states , if not already there. I feel sad for West Bengal... such a self destruction is seldom seen. INNOCENT FARMERS IN NANDIGRAM GROWS BOMBS , GUNS , BULLETS ...FERTILE LAND ..AHA... SADDAM MISSED THEM
RE:RE:CBI Probe into Nandigram Firing
by Koushik Rudra on Mar 16, 2007 02:32 AM Permalink
Please check your facts before writing. The lands that were acquired were very fertile and was 3 crops a year land. What industrialization we would get by sacrificing agricultural land like this? and cant the farmers have right not to sell their lands. When your fertile land is taken away from you at a low compensation and you are promised a job of worker in the factory, what growth we are bringing? Its not Mamta who is taking bengal backwards but the leftists started by jyoti babu already promised to ruin bengal.
RE:RE:CBI Probe into Nandigram Firing
by ONKAR MUKHERJEE on Mar 15, 2007 06:51 PM Permalink
you seem to be another of the cpm's dogs....dont try to justify the firing of civilans by saying all that crap...its easy to type out a few words sitting on your couch..but when your livlihood and birthrights are threatened by the very people supposed to guard them then people have every right to try to protect themselves...forget about all that employment crap...the cpm's failure is quite obvious....allen go to hell
RE:RE:CBI Probe into Nandigram Firing
by Bon on Mar 15, 2007 07:30 PM Permalink
My dear CPM cadre, if you think those policemen are doing a noble job of washing off terrorists, then why do you think the CPM cadres out there have been taking pains to keep all media personel out of that area. They are not letting even a single reporter to go there. What are they scared of? Don't you think they are scared that their misdeeds don't come in front of the whole world? They have actually gained so much power only because of foolish people like you who are supporting them. I would like to see what you would say if it was your land they had seized or your family they had killed!!
RE:waste of time
by Ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 05:04 PM Permalink
Very true. All the accused only need not be sacked, but there should be a strict punishment also. Its good that CBI has been asked to find out the truth, but the question is what will happen after that..... Like NITHARI CASE (in Noida, U.P)..... After having all the evidences and proofs, still we are waiting for the judgment. When this delayed judgement will be stopped. After this lot of other cases will be raised, and slowly people will start forgetting the previous one's. All this problems are due to corrupt Ministers of our country. A CBI team should be there to stop the Ministers from doing corruptions. Whenever anybody (actually everybody) proven guilty, all his property should be seized by the court. Everything is happening in front of our eyes, but one can't do anything. How pathetic. We really need a radical change to sort out all this kind of problems.
RE:RE:waste of time
by Koushik Rudra on Mar 16, 2007 02:35 AM Permalink
Have some humanity to call the landless farmers peasants. This was the same govt of have nots (sarbohara in their terminology). You mean to say those villagers are terrorists? have some shame and dont talk like the paid agents of those communists (the way they put facts in their mouthpiece ganashakti)
RE:RE:waste of time
by Manoj Mathew on Mar 15, 2007 04:54 PM Permalink
who are the terrorists you mention ? the poor villagers who are trying to protect their land? The massacre is brutality to the entire humanity.
RE:RE:waste of time
by Ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 05:10 PM Permalink
r U crazy? How can u say this? U know the meaning of terrorist? Peoples who r not even getting proper food two times a day, but because of whom we r getting our food everyday. Before giving any comments, atleast feel the pathetic life they r leading everyday. If U can't do anything for them, its OK, but please don't utter this kind of inhuman words for them.
RE:waste of time
by Paramesh Waran on Mar 15, 2007 05:54 PM Permalink
I would not be surprised if this incident works as a catalyst for the spread of the maoist network into Bengal. Remember that they are already well entrenched in Jharkand and Chattisgarh both abutting Bengal. As Naxalism originated in Bengal there must still be very many sympathisers for the cause and CPM may have unwittingly given them all platform to come together, this time with the underground support of the ordinary folks who have genuine grievances. Sweep the commies off the face of Bengal and Kerala, I say, they are a blot on the proud escutcheon of these two otherwise cultured adn educated states.
And the great leader of CPI-M, Jyoti Basu once called BJP a barbaric party. It is time for CPI goons to sit back and reflect on who is actually barbaric. People of India already have the answer now.
RE:Calcutta High Court asks CBI to probe Nandigram firing
by Achintya Karmakar on Mar 15, 2007 04:28 PM Permalink
by Achi on Mar-15-2007 4:30 pm This is not the first time that CPI-M has proved that they are barberian. You must be remembering the firing at Marichjhapi and Jyoti Basu's comments on that.
RE:RE:Calcutta High Court asks CBI to probe Nandigram firing
by Koushik Rudra on Mar 16, 2007 02:37 AM Permalink
And how can you forget the great comment of Jyoti basu on the brutal rape of one lady govt official in broad daylight. The ex King of Bengal said, "Erom koto to hoeyi thake". He said, these things happen so much, that does not imply that there is any law and order problem in Bengal.
Cases remain pending in the court for years. Court is now having ample time to rule the country and give instructions which the central government should do, in every matter political or apollitaical. shame on us.
it is very bad, that people had to shed blood for sake of industtrialisation. my sympathies with the families. I am not from bengal but I am opposed to the project, because I want all growth and industrial, IT etc; to happen only in my neighbourhood--south and west. this incident will roll back bengal to 1990s.. bengal people dont deserve growth.
RE:good and bad
by pramit palit on Mar 15, 2007 03:42 PM Permalink
How stupid and selfish of you.You want all the growth to happen around you ! India still lags because of selfish morons like you. As for Nandigram , first arrest the people who instigated the uprising. They are the same people who played dirty politics in Singur.These people with very few seats in the assembly are trying to gain political mileage through others blood. Though killing innocent villagers is highly condemnable- civic administration should be allowed to function.
RE:RE:good and bad
by Paramesh Waran on Mar 15, 2007 05:59 PM Permalink
Nonsense, Pramit, even you should know that there are barren land masses in large quantities where these industries? can be located. However, the interests of both the corrupt politicos and industricos is to have access to the most desirable locations from different states so that their profiteering can continue. An environment can always be created to suit any prospective venture and does not have to be over so many dead bodies.
RE:RE:good and bad
by Tarun Bhardwaj on Mar 15, 2007 04:17 PM Permalink
Hey bro can't u see this mihir thing is a mischief monger...don't waste ur time on him. Just see all his replies. Man !!! India does really have people so idle and foolish...wow
RE:RE:good and bad
by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:44 PM Permalink
yeah focus on grass-root development, voting out government, mass uprising, people movements etc;; when u have time, please work and think about economy
RE:good and bad
by Ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 05:43 PM Permalink
Yes, we all deserve growth and those villagers deserve poverty, diseases, hunger & dealth. One day they will demolish your house (if there in Kolkata or anywhere) to make a big road or overbridge, then U'll realise what industrialization means. At that time, we all have sympathies with you. Great thought. keep it up.....
I doubt whether CBI would be able find out anything at Nandigram. The area has been taken over by Police and CPM-cadres. By yesterday night they must have cleared off all the proofs like shells, killed children and ladies, the rape-victims' clothes etc.
The CBI team must check the TV recordings from all the channells like Tara-Bangla, Zee etc. However, footages of Star-Ananda (which is patronized by CPM) would hardly yield anything - but that too should be checked. The CBI team would have an uphill task ahead of it.
RE:CBI Probe in Nandigram
by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink
it is very bad, that people had to shed blood for sake of industtrialisation. my sympathies with the families. I am not from bengal but I am opposed to the project, because I want all growth and industrial, IT etc; to happen only in my neighbourhood--south and west. this incident will roll back bengal to 1990s.. bengal people dont deserve growth.
RE:RE:CBI Probe in Nandigram
by K Roy on Mar 15, 2007 04:17 PM Permalink
Star Ananda is of the ABP group. It was that ABP that took part in the Trinamool meeting and its editor Abheek sarkar was there when the list of TMC candidates for the last Assembly election was decided. Know the facts correct whether Star Ananda patronizes CPM or the TMC
RE:RE:CBI Probe in Nandigram
by ONKAR MUKHERJEE on Mar 15, 2007 06:59 PM Permalink
RE:CBI Probe in Nandigram by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:19 PM it is very bad, that people had to shed blood for sake of industtrialisation. my sympathies with the families. I am not from bengal but I am opposed to the project, because I want all growth and industrial, IT etc; to happen only in my neighbourhood--south and west. this incident will roll back bengal to 1990s.. bengal people dont deserve growth.
lol...mihir i think bengal can only grow when it rolls back 26-27 years...when cpm came to power...then it was perhaps one of the most industrialised states? the downfall started with the cpm assuming power....now after so many years of evicting the industry for the cause of workers union the cpm suddenly want to appease the industry to come back to bengal...to champion the cause for employment for the youth of bengal....wow! good idea! hehe... as for south...well yeah...u may want something..but ure obc first policy will soon drive away the "growth and industrial, IT etc" beyond your reach...so...sweet dreams!
This is a nice ploy. The CBI will be used to suppress the case as has happened in numerous occasions before. With leftists as allies at the centre, can we rely on CBI? On the other hand, there is no other option. Lets pray for the souls of the departed and pray that the injured get well soon. Lets also pray that the ordinary human beings rise up in protest by all available means.
RE:Eyewash by CBI
by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:17 PM Permalink
it is very bad, that people had to shed blood for sake of industtrialisation. my sympathies with the families. I am not from bengal but I am opposed to the project, because I want all growth and industrial, IT etc; to happen only in my neighbourhood--south and west. this incident will roll back bengal to 1990s.. bengal people dont deserve growth.
RE:RE:Eyewash by CBI
by Ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 05:40 PM Permalink
Yes, we all deserve growth and those villagers deserve poverty, diseases, hunger & dealth. Grow up, Mihir. One day they will demolish your house (if there in Kolkata or anywhere) to make a big road or overbridge, then U'll realise what industrialization means. Great thought. keep it up.....
immediately arrest those people who forced to villegers to protest against police men, because those people just want this situation to prove their political existence.
RE:nandigram violence
by nilmadhab mandal on Mar 15, 2007 02:56 PM Permalink
and Mr. chakraborty as per you immediately give promotion to police officers..who killed women and children..immeditely..make the CMP caders as central committee member..promote Lakshamn Seth from MP to PM..
great man!! you guys make me remember the saying in Hindi..which says..the Ulta chor kotyal ko date!! (meaning the theif is blaming the chowkidar).. your brain is so full of patry office fodder..that you fail to realize..that you dont require a party to react..if your livelihood is taken off..and how come other instigated ppl..when the CPM cordoned off..the whole Nandigram.. Hear the eminent historian (also know for his leftist interpretation of history)Sumit Sarkar..on live TV..he said..no party is beyond this..its a ppl movement..only if you could see it...pity on you and your brainwashed comrades!!
RE:RE:nandigram violence
by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:27 PM Permalink
I support all communists in bengal. they are the ones who ensure that growth gets concentrated ONLY in south and west.. else we would have to think about working in bengal.. with this incident.. no chance.. also i hope jyoti basu comes back to power and establishes a socialist regime in bengal.. i am loving it
