you promised unnototoro (better) CPIM...if this is better..then plz dont promise the best at the next poll... you promised 'Rule of laws' for the 4 villages near nandigram..if that means loss of 20 lives..plz allow us to live in anarchy!! you told industrialisation.....if that means giving fertile lands instead of arid areas of Purulia and Bankura...then plz ..dont bring development... and what are you taling about? you feel we all are fool? can you justify one reason why TATA has to built factory in hoogly..and not in Purulia and Bankura...?? I have 5 to say otherwise...want an open debate? you fool us that TATA will generate empolyment? simple logic: to build a 1 lakhs rupee car you have to automate the whole industry in such a way..that was never done in India...even Maruti tried ..but failed..!! if it is automated how many ppl will be employed? 500..that too educated engineers!! and what will the rest of 20 K pppl will do after loosing land? ist foolish to say..there was no economy...in Singur..or Nadigram..before industrialisation...any way you wont understand this logic...your brain is full of stuff that is fed by your party ..you are the face..a suitable mask...if you have courage just step out of your chair..and for humanity's sake dont say 'it was our fault'...this gimmick of yours has worked earlier..but now its overused..
I reside outside Bengal..and wanted to go back...but sorry...!! I dont think I will be safe in your state..not that i dont want industry..but you personally lost the last bus..
last words: I am not anti-CPM..nor anti-BJP..but i stayed in Gujrat..just send a few caders see...how to develop....see..how to build industry...send mr. Biman bose..to salute mr. Modi...I know..it's difficult to digest..but but get angry..at the first site of defeat...as you are in Nandigram..sadly..but truly..you have been defeated by Mr. Modi..hands down..as far as industry and administration goes..lets accept the truth!!
RE:what a shame !!!
by Papu Biswas on Mar 15, 2007 10:58 AM Permalink
ask leaders bhumi uchched pratirodh committe members why they were hiding behind minors and women.
RE:RE:what a shame !!!
by nilmadhab mandal on Mar 15, 2007 11:09 AM Permalink
so what? if your police dont spare the women and children...(and lebel them as hooligan with pipeguns...)..surely you wond have spare their men..!!
what is your problem if they let the women and children to put forward..this is a simple tactic..asuuimng the police wont be that brutal..at least to women and children...but they have been proved wrong ny your leaders (CM and Lakshman seth)....!!!
next time..you send police (butchers)..they will not assume them..human beings..!!
The Left and other so called communist parties never believe in Democracy. Either in Russia or in China or where ever they are they wont respect human beings and always aiming to loot public money and will join hands with industralists and make money by cheating the workers by making them to believe them that as if they are fighting for workers.
These followers of forign born parties are always work against the interest of India and they never respect human rights. These barbarian parties should be eradicated from India because they are more dangerous than AIDS.
Hey why don't the political parties stop this bandh business........times have changes but the senerio in West Bengal is the same. Some incident takes place and a bandh is called. Now it is time that we stop encouraging these.
RE:Why softcorner for salim corporation
by Shamik Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 10:52 AM Permalink
even if it was Ram, Shyam , Jadu or MAdhu instead of the Salim group people like you will always raise questions ... you are third person ... people have lost lives ... concentrate on that man ... don't speak against industrialisation of the state ...
WELL DONE PEOPLE. GIVE THE FRUITS OF THE TREE WHICH WAS NOURISHED WITH FLESH AND BLOOD BY THE COMMUNISTS. LET THEY KNOW THE TASTE OF THEIR OWN ACTIONS . KEEP IT UP AND THROW THEM TO BAY OF BENGAL.
RE:NANDHIGRAM,
by Shamik Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 11:12 AM Permalink
hope u have a hands down experience of bengal before you start commenting ... So called innocent People dug up roads so that adminsitration people cannot access the area ... they burnt down CPIM supporter's houses, killed 6 of CPIM men , killed 1 police officer ... have left the entire area out of bounds for the administration ... when poilce goes there to restore peace , they are bombed and showered with bullets from pipe guns ... do you think any govt will take it lying down ? Police did not go there to take the lands away from the villagers .. they wanted to enter Nandigram so that adminsitration can be restored in the area ,,, these things have been incited by CPI(ML) and 1 mad woman called Mamta Banerjee and 1 media newspaper called Bartamaan whose editor writes like a astrolger ... he can foresee everything that will happen in the future and writes in future tense ... so if you from outside bengal please stay away from this politics ... I sincerely beleive that this trouble is becos of CPI(ML) ( naxals) forces who sympathise falsely with the farmers, spreads rumours and incite the administration and the govt to take extreme action against them so that the issue gets highlighted ... this is their very old modus operandi ... u should know all the facts before you join the band wagon of these so called sane people calling for bandhs after bandhs in bengal ... do u know Higher Secondary exam was scheduled to start on Friday when TMC has called the bandh ? Approx 4.5L students are suffering now ... do u know what this means ? this means delayed exams , delayed results , delayed admissions, delayed sessions in colleges ... ultimately the entire education system gets delayed .. do u think other states will wait for only bengal students ? No ... but its the whims of a single mad woman .. mamta Banerjee ... who 1st will call you a thief and then when you retaliate will cry hoarse that you are doing unfair things ... this is her nature ... its not new ... that is why TMC has 1 MP and only 30 MLA s in West Bengal ... hope u understand ... U must have made up ur mind that this guy ( that is me ... shamik ghosh) is the agent of the communists ... FYI , I am not ... I am in Seoul , working in a pvt company here witha good fat pay package but with only 1 aim ... to return to my native state and work there , this Bengal govt is tring to do some industrialisation in the state and this mad woman is chasing the industrialists away with her histrionics ... Feeling sorry to see only my hope fade away ... only yesterday I was speaking to my friend from bangalore ... he was supposed to take some interviews in Kolkata ... after this violence and bandh call ... he has refused to come and take the interviews of guys in Kolkata ... he will take the guys from some where else ... who is the loser ? Everybody knows what CPIM did for the farmers ... now they want to industries ... for that they require land ... so certain lands are being taken from farmers ... adequate infact the highest compensation in the country is being paid to the farmers ( 12L for a bigha ) ... in Maharstra a farmer gets rs 24 thousand per bigha ... yet this oppostion is not letting the govt do what it wants to ... of the 294 seats in WB, oppostion has only 50 setas ... does it not say enough ? Govt came to power by promising industrialisation ... so CM is very right in aggressively following the policy ... opposition like BJP does it in Gujarat and RAjasthan and MP ... Congress does it in AP , UP ... everywhere ... CPIM had been protesting against these , and now that CPIM is now doing what they were doing these opposition parties are barking aloud ...
RE:RE:NANDHIGRAM,
by rajes ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 11:43 AM Permalink
I got u man(?) u r a TABETAR of CIPM..are u realy not felling bad for this Killing..If not then I have doubt that U r a man or not.
RE:RE:RE:NANDHIGRAM,
by Sharan Patil on Mar 15, 2007 02:36 PM Permalink
Shamik, since you wan2 come back to your state you want industralization, it seems u r happy with snatching the farmers land, few days back one farmer suicide, coz his 1 acres was snatched by govt, n he .. you selfish, when you have fat salary how can u think about farmers family, woman, children, who will take care of their future, and wat happens,if student waited another day for exams, how can u think when the whole farmer communtity is dying all over country.. cant student wait for 1 day.. selfish bas**d
Reader, excuse me if I am wrong..is it not the same situation as of the time in "British Raj". How men in uniform can do like this? I am really speechless. I think it is possible only in India...rather in West Bengal..God..do some thing.. Raj
RE:This is India..rather..This is my West Bengal
by aditya sharma on Mar 15, 2007 10:30 AM Permalink
it is much much worst than what you have narrated. In British Raj atleast people have right to protest but the CPM rule state only what they like they allow. where is now Sitaram Yachuri and Binda Karat who speake too much for democratic rights ctc.????
