RE:NONE OTHER THAN IMPOSING PRESIDENT'S RULE AND PROSECUTE WB CHIEF MINISTER WILL SATISFY THE PEOPLE OF INDIA AGAINST HIS STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM
by SUBHABRATA DATTA on Mar 15, 2007 11:58 AM Permalink
shame shame! ur lies r caught red-handed (pun intended). 1.please prove that the CM ordered "killings" 2.please prove that electoral results r forged and we win by force.(in fact unprecedented activism of the CEC in 2005 reselted in a bigger victory for the left. does not this prove that the opposition won some seats in earlier elections by rigging? ;)) 3.media showed pix all day, who blacouted whom? please prove. (u self contradict ur self by saying that its disturbing to see the video clips. who shot these clips?) 4.if every1 is afraid to protest, then what happened yesterday? r u ok? 5.please prove that the left has entered into "secret deals with foreign players and tata". (please realise that this is the cleanest govt that india has ever seen anywhere. no scams, no kickbacks, no hanky panky for 31 yrs running) 6.law & order has broken down? please go thru the national crime records beareau report. 7. fit case for prez rule? please go thru the constitution regarding the procedure of the same. has the governor given any such report to the central govt? 8. please prove that the police is controlled by the cpi(,) cadres. else apologise. 9.compared with jalianawalla bagh massacre? wow! please read up history books as what happened there. do u expect the police to throw rasogollas at u when u r hulring bombs at them? & 1st time in independent india? please read up again before u comment like that.
the rest r ur ideas and political comments. u hv ur right to express. but regarding the abovementioned lies, i challenge you to either prove here in rediff, or APOLOGISE
RE:RE:NONE OTHER THAN IMPOSING PRESIDENT'S RULE AND PROSECUTE WB CHIEF MINISTER WILL SATISFY THE PEOPLE OF INDIA AGAINST HIS STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM
by Rajendra Prasad on Mar 15, 2007 01:05 PM Permalink
The question is not that CPIM is involved in any hanky panky, scam. you must be knowing the agenda of this party, CPIM is for the poorer, they are here for 30 long years due to the them, party agenda is same, they have ruined west bengal for 30 years, no developments, no industry, no IT industry suddenly why are they trying to develop so quickly and harshly. as far as law and order is concerned I think you have never ever travelled to the inner side of the villages in w.b. You are good readerer but practically your knowledge about this is zero.
RE:RE:NONE OTHER THAN IMPOSING PRESIDENT'S RULE AND PROSECUTE WB CHIEF MINISTER WILL SATISFY THE PEOPLE OF INDIA AGAINST HIS STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM
by krnkk on Mar 15, 2007 12:37 PM Permalink
it is high time the communists are thrown out of power. how would you know that national parties will not perform well if you do not give them a chance. with the current voting pattern it makes no sence in having an opposition. whatever cpi does will keep looking good to you. cpi is a very unethical party . they fight against other parties in the election and once again support them at the centre in order to gain power. they support illegal immigrants to garner votes. they must definitely be receiving kickbacks for the SEZ deal. Else they would not have gone to the extent of killing people. Economic development is good but you cannot do that at the cost of driving people from entire villages out. Just imagine your hometown being wiped out by an SEZ. it is as good as your hometown being submerged due to construction of a Dam. It may be beneficial to many people who are not affected. But what is the need of allocating thousands of hectares of land. why cant the industries that are making billions of dollars construct multi storied buildings. If this is not feasible then the govt needs to allocate only wasteland and not cultivatable land. if farmers stop cultivating from where will u get food to eat?.
wake up guys. vote these communists out next time and watch WB prosper.
RE:RE:NONE OTHER THAN IMPOSING PRESIDENT'S RULE AND PROSECUTE WB CHIEF MINISTER WILL SATISFY THE PEOPLE OF INDIA AGAINST HIS STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM
by abhijeet kenkare on Mar 15, 2007 12:43 PM Permalink
Subhrata, I apologise.
1.APOLOGISE FOR TAKING ON A LOYAL COMMUNIST CADRE. 2.APOLOGISE FOR TAKING ON YOUR SUPREME ADVOCACY SKILLS. 3.APOLOGISE FOR EVEN BEING SENSITIVE TO THE DEATHS OF WOMEN AND CHILDREN. 4. APOLOGISE BECAUSE I NEVER KNEW THAT A CM ALWAYS SIGNS FIRING ORDERS.SO THAT IT CAN BE PROVED LATER. 5.APOLOGISE FOR EVEN THINKING OF THE GOVT BEING HAND-IN-GLOVE WITH INDUSTRIALISTS.(I SHOULD HAVE ATLEAST CONSIDERED THEIR WISDOM) 6.APOLOGISE FOR THINKING THAT THE LAW AND ORDER IS NOT IN PLACE.(NEVER THOUGHT THAT STATISTICS COMING OUT OF A GOVT-SPONSORED DOCUMENT WOULD BE A BETTER REFLECTION THAN THE GROUND REALTIES. APOLOGIES AGAIN) 7.HEARTIEST AND BIGGEST APOLOGY AGAIN BECAUSE NEVER THOUGHT THAT 31 YRS OF CONTINOUS RULE IS NOT A SMALL ACHIEVEMENT.(SO WHAT IF THE ROLE OF BEING A COMMERCIAL CAPITAL HAS GONE TO MUMBAI. SO WHAT IF HORDES OF BRILLIANT BENGALIS HAVE MIGRATED TO OTHER STATES OR EVEN TO FOREIGN SOIL.AND SO WHAT IF TRAINS LEAVING HOWRAH ARE FULL OF SKILLED AND UNSKILLED LABOURERS MIGRATING TO OTHER PARTS OF THE COUNTRY.)
The matter is WB Govt. gave the chance to Nandigram and Khejuri's people to get gun and bomb to use for election situation. so that they can win the election easily by those villegers. but now govt. force them to leave their land for TATA and Salim group. This is why villergers now use their gun and bomb those was given by the caders of CPI(M) earlier to save their land. Its true Nandigram was proper out of law and order situation since last two months because of this. so WB Govt. is 100% responsible for this situation.
whoever the policeman who beated badly to ladies who were trying to take their relative or whoever who was suffered from bullet enjury..that policeman must be punished...i really feel bad by seeing the incident on telivision.....
I have shocked to watch the violent activities of the police inspired by BUDDHADEV.BUDDHA should wear red dresses and he should drink at least 1 ltr of human blood every day. Then his glamor will be more and the industrialists will like him more. We the people of west bengal are so unlucky to have such a MASS KILLER CM. He should go now.
Nandigram incident is a truly an insult to a democratic country like India.But i nowhere see the Police or the State govertment as a culprit behind this,but i will surely tell Mamata Banerjee and her all illliterate councillors and Mla's,Congress Mla's are behind this.I'll remind the His Honesty Governor of W.Bengal that this cold blooded Horror is a result and a brainchild of trinamool Chief and her loyalists.How could police fired unintentionally towards to innocent people?only if there is a provocation from the villagers,but inside the villages there were people of TMC and so called the other political parties who used their Goonda bahini and fired upon to the police,it's acold blooded plan of TMC chief and her party and all those who were associated with them.
IU strongly condemed the issue but at the same time i would praise for CM Buddhadeb Bhaterjee,who is a man who is doing for his state,not for any personal gains.He is trying to bring up the state in a international map,by bringing Industries,creating jobs and doing so many welfare things.
I would ask all the media,people of this demacratic Country to come up and support the Budhadeb Bhaterjee's campaign and raise the voices against to all those Mamata banerjee and her associates.
RE:Nandigram Massacare is an insult to the normal public...
by JOYDEB MUKHERJEE on Mar 15, 2007 01:43 PM Permalink
Subhasis, must you express your opinion in public and bring shame upon Bengali; not because of the killing that took place yesterday, but looking at your incorrect English and poor construction of sentences and what not.
RE:Nandigram Massacare is an insult to the normal public...
by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay on Mar 15, 2007 11:35 AM Permalink
Fool, look around. NOT A SINGLE VOICE SUPPORTED CPIM TODAY. NOT EVEN ITS ALLIES!
RE:SOLUTION FOR THESE KIND OF PROBLEM SEZs
by Raja on Mar 15, 2007 11:39 AM Permalink
Few states have land acquisition as a serious problem, in some other states acquiring land for industries is not as serious as in WB.
So eventually industries will turn their interest to those states..competition is heating up amoung Gujarat, Haryana, Karnataka, AP and TN.
Buddadeb is well aware of this and thats the reason is pushing hard to get industries to WB. Investment oppurtunities will not keep knocking WB's doors all the time..if they feel that doors wont open for sometime they will to other states doors which are open
RE:RE:SOLUTION FOR THESE KIND OF PROBLEM SEZs
by Krishnier Natarajan on Mar 15, 2007 12:45 PM Permalink
West Bengal does not deserve any industry. It deserves only high principles of communism. Tamil people like industries. So, I suggest: give communism to WB and industries to Tamil Nadu! by Tamil Savvy
RE:SOLUTION FOR THESE KIND OF PROBLEM SEZs
by ambresh kothanda on Mar 15, 2007 11:26 AM Permalink
I Think want your trying to suggest is right and it sounds like a practical solution to sez problem. otherwise this sort of saans and bahu fight will go on forever.
To send innnocent child and women in front of Police by coward politicians from Congress , Trinamool Congress , Jamat - e- ulema and other political parties shows their callousness and irresponsible act which led to the kiling of those innocent people by police . Police cannot stand like a spectator when they are attaked by the public . And it is those politicians (Like Mamata Banerjee , Subrata Mukherjee , Manas Bhunia etc ) are responsible for instigating those innnocent people against police . Those politicians should be arrested first for their cowardly act .
RE:Namdigram Massacre
by SUBRATA MAITY on Mar 15, 2007 11:24 AM Permalink
And these leaders now called a Bengal Bandh on Friday to bring in more haraassment to the students of CBSE , ICSE.They are now posing as heroes and great saviours of democracy.
If Buddha is to be cursed , we should also ban all these Dramabaz didis , dadas and their blessed Juntas.
RE:Namdigram Massacre
by nilmadhab mandal on Mar 15, 2007 11:27 AM Permalink
read your own comment..see the contradiction yourself..!!!
first you said..all opposition parties send the women and children in front line..and they should be condemned!! see...you are saying rightly they are innocent...as if that didnt allow your police to kill more!!
then you go on saying.."Police cannot stand like a spectator when they are attaked by the public"...so you mean the innocent ppl attacked police...
Now you decide whichh version you want to stick!! and last request...plz..if your ever see loss of life ...plz plz...cry a minute for the departed soul...w/o picking up the political patronage..
RE:RE:Namdigram Massacre
by soroshi kumar nandi on Mar 15, 2007 12:01 PM Permalink
I am sorry that my message hurt you . But this type of incitement is not expected from any political parties .My contention in this case was general public were brain washed by those opposition leaders which led to the killing of 14 people . And when this type of incident (massacre) happens , these very political persons take advantage of the situation and try to become savior of the people .
RE:Namdigram Massacre
by ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 11:19 AM Permalink
For your Kind information. In that place on that day there is no TMC,Congress and jamet Ulema There is only one category they are called "fermers". Yes opppostion are trying to united them But Police gunned down the fermers or fermers family.
RE:RE:Namdigram Massacre
by Shamik Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 11:27 AM Permalink
U r very wrong ... there are CPI(ML), TMC goons and Congress goondas there among the poor and innocent farmers ... they are the people who are spreading rumours, inciting people and supplying fire arms to the public ... they need to be cleared up ... that 5000 strong police force was assembled and they were attacked with bombs and pipe guns only point to the fact that people there have been brain washed !
RE:RE:Namdigram Massacre
by Shamik Ghosh on Mar 15, 2007 11:33 AM Permalink
how could you forget how TMC goons misbehaved and threatened a news reporter in front of MAmata BAnejee while she was fasting in Dalhousie ... mamata even tried to put the responsibility on CPIM , but it was proved later that ythe miscreants were from a rival TMC leader only ! Even how can you forget while marching towards Singur how rowdy people got and remember the rogh 4 people ? They were called CPIM goondas ... later they were proved to be TMC cadres only ... You seem to be only brain washed by others .. open your own eyes and own ears and let fresh air come in for sometime and then think ... CPIM is in a loosing platform now ... whatever it will do , it is going to loose ... if it allows industrialisation his own men oppose it and if it backtracks from industraialisation the state will disown it ... so it cannot take the drastic step of killing farmers by bullet ! These were miscreants of the opposition that is formenting trouble in these areas ... if you don't want to belive , dont believe ...
RE:RE:Namdigram Massacre
by surajit sarkar on Mar 15, 2007 11:29 AM Permalink
after that barbaric incidents we want to resign of BUDDHA DEV BHATTACHARYA.we condemns this incidents in all verticals.its a time to impose the prez rule in begal to save the peace people from red cadre.
I am shocked to hear the death news---by police firing.But why this incident was happened? we have to go through the matter. Nandigram is out of proper law and order situation for nearly three months.Is it right in a democratic set up?
How long will it be allowed to continue? where is an democratically elected Govt. persists.I do not want to enter into political controversy. Can I ask a question? 14 people died for whom? who will take the responsibility? Whose purpose was served? Will any purpose be served by the irresponsible Bandh? As a peace loving people of WB,I request both the Govt. and opposition parties to sit together to take a Vow that such incident will not repeat in future.
Poor people are not fools, when many of their livelihood depend on dauly wages.
CPIM leaders of adjacent areas, State leaders instead of paying attention, actually flexed muscles and those people were convinced their land will be taken over forcefully WITHOUT CARING FOR LAW as done in Singur.
Poor people are smart enough to understand what is needed. They cannot be fooled for 3-4 months against CPIM, specially in a area where CPIM HAD STRONG GRASSROOT PRESENCE.
CPIM SHOULD ANSWER WHY ITS 100s OF PARTY MEMBERS, CADERS JOINED HANDS IN OPPOSING CPIM's Decision?
It can happen, when those who rule from calcutta has lost touch with people, their view. Also the conduits who usually fecilitate that communication - CPIM leaders of different level- have been left out of this Buddha inspired forceful inductrialization.
RE:Nandigram
by ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 11:26 AM Permalink
Why this time (yerterday night not a single CPIM leader come in any telvision or media and spoke) but another time they opened assemble to show the media.Why they are not speaking a single word?
