The whole point of argument about muslims proving their patriotism is ridiculus....and should be totally unacceptable to not only muslims but fellow Indians as well. Muslims dont need to prove anything to anybody they are as much Indian as anyone else living in India while being a muslim. Most muslims as of today are suffering psychologically as a community for they are prejudged as terminators and terrorists..by rest of the world .I wonder who owes an apology here !!! Torturing a whole community with preconcieved notions is it going to create in solutions for a society or problems for it ?
People who preach equality amongst all owes an explanation to this muslim beating phenomenon all over...
Its ridiculous for any Indian community that others Indian communities will judge them for their faith in patriotism unless we declare India to be a Hindu nation only....
Do these judges realize the Muslim living in India have already proven with partition of subcontinent that they have valued nationalist identity more then any other community living in present day India..
Though all this has come at a huge cost to muslims living in the subcontinent.(Almost 50% of people lived in the geographical boundaries of subcontinent have been Muslim for more than 400 years!!!)
What america is trying to prove today that being the powerful nation it can dominate and act like a boss.There is a need for a person who can punch america in the face and to clearly state that he is not the boss.
RE:America is not the boss!!!
by niki surabi on Jun 17, 2007 09:40 PM Permalink
Osama & the others had the guts to just do that, puch America on the nose with 9/11. Not only that it bled & bled real bad. Now the Americans feel that Bush is a greater evil than Osama.
RE:RE:America is not the boss!!!
by Piyush Bhargava on Jun 17, 2007 09:49 PM Permalink
And now America is punching back and now your nose is not only bleeding ,it is heammoraging.
RE:America is not the boss!!!
by S Narain on Jun 17, 2007 09:40 PM Permalink
Indian muslims are not fanatics like Osama and should maintain their identity as better disciplined & followers of peace as preached in Quaran,and should present a good example to the world.Indians muslims or hindus are peace loving,This has to be shown by each one of us,ireespective of religion,region and class.
RE:America is not the boss!!!
by S Narain on Jun 17, 2007 10:48 PM Permalink
You are kidding! Indian Muslims are not fanatic like you.You are not Indian,I am sure!!
RE:America is not the boss!!!
by unni on Jun 17, 2007 09:33 PM Permalink
OH yeah? After America,whom will that person punch?India or Israel?Good thinking!
RE:America is not the boss!!!
by Piyush Bhargava on Jun 17, 2007 09:36 PM Permalink
You punched America in the face.Now they are punching you.Don't crib.
Arrest of these 12 men is done only on the basis of one mans complaint, I am not saying that thorough investigation should not be done and all possibilities should be explored, but it is not possible that these men could be of different sect and Zahiruddin thought of an easy way to get rid of them.
RE:RE:Something fishy here ?
by Piyush Bhargava on Jun 17, 2007 09:40 PM Permalink
Well,well.Do you mean to say that if 12 men are arrested then 12 men should have filed complaints.Let the security forces do their duty. We have full faith in them.
Arrest of these 12 men is done only on the basis of one mans complaint, I am not saying that thorough investigation should not be done and all possibilities should be explored, but it is not possible that these men could be of different sect and Zahiruddin thought of an easy way to get rid of them.
RE:Something fishy here ?
by durgpal chauhan on Jun 17, 2007 09:41 PM Permalink
u buggers will never ever condemn any wrong doing of ur fellow brothers...no matter how much educated u r ...for parliament attck is fishy..godhara is fishy....laden is innocent...
RE:hey guys you gotta check this out
by niki surabi on Jun 17, 2007 09:35 PM Permalink
Bush is proving to be a greater terrorist than Osama. So whats this big deal about glorifying Osama.
This is the first instance I have found of Indian muslims complaining about the bad elements in thier society.
Kudos..........well done.........hope more such complaints help reign in the terror in India........and truly proves the patriotism of majority of Indian Muslims.
RE:Good Work Indian Muslims
by epsilon on Jun 17, 2007 06:51 PM Permalink
This is only the first instance that has come to your notice. But if you go to the police and ask them they will tell you that most informers are muslims.
RE:Good Work Indian Muslims
by dys on Jun 17, 2007 08:43 PM Permalink
true Abhinav
This is the 1st instance i can remember. i hv been crying for this, that good muslims should condemn and act against the islamic terrorists and all, instead of simply saying 'that is not true islam'
Really kudos to the muslims who came out in this case today
RE:Good Work Indian Muslims
by dys on Jun 17, 2007 08:44 PM Permalink
true Abhinav
This is the 1st instance i can remember. i hv been crying for this, that good muslims should condemn and act against the islamic terrorists and all, instead of simply saying 'that is not true islam'
Really kudos to the muslims who came out in this case today
RE:Good Work Indian Muslims
by dys on Jun 17, 2007 08:44 PM Permalink
true Abhinav
This is the 1st instance i can remember. i hv been crying for this, that good muslims should condemn and act against the islamic terrorists and all, instead of simply saying 'that is not true islam'
Really kudos to the muslims who came out in this case today
RE:Old news
by epsilon on Jun 17, 2007 06:13 PM Permalink
Have you read this news brother ? If you have read the news then I am sure that you missed the this part of the news so I am pasting it for you.
A delegation of Muslims also submitted a memorandum to District Collector Sandeep Yadav seeking strict action against the accused as 'they were spreading rumours about Islam'.
RE:Old news
by imam on Jun 17, 2007 06:19 PM Permalink
Yes they shold have an arm and leg cut off on alternate sides and then sent to Afghanistan, i hope that was the strict action this delegation was seeking,otoh kudos to the chap who complained agaist them, you are a true Indian, the country comes first
RE:RE:Old news
by Augustine Alemcherry on Jun 17, 2007 06:32 PM Permalink
For some it is a question of country comes forst or second. What they dont understand is this barbaric ideology is against the humanity and should be destroyed. Any religion that spreads hatread and preach killing all those dont follow them is agiinst humanity.
Our problem is that we are looking for religion based terrerism where as religion itself teaches terrorism. You can not stop this unless you start addressing the root cause.
RE:RE:RE:Old news
by epsilon on Jun 17, 2007 06:44 PM Permalink
So how to you plan to convert the 2 billion muslims around the world ?By abusing their religion ? If Islam is a religion of hate then how do you plan to counter it by hate? If you start hating then you also become one of those who hate.
