This is a very good attempt by M. Gautier, and I thank him for exposing the lies perpetuated by the left-wing communist historians who have no regard for the truth.
Fact is, Aurangzeb is in a way responsible for all the communal animosity we see in the Indian sub-continent even today.
I would even blame Godhra and riots on Aurangzeb and the false historians who are fearful of truth.
I noticed one person (obviously a Muslim) has commented that 'Aurangzeb was a true Muslim." If that is how a true Muslim ought to behave, then I am glad I am not a Muslim. And, may I add, I am glad there are leaders like Modi to protect people like me.
RE:A great article, exposing Leftist historians
by on Apr 02, 2008 02:05 AM Permalink
I am a muslim. I won't say much. Islam is a very beautiful religion, where everything can be justified. Its perfectly acceptable for a man to be cruel/good no matter who that be, because man is a born sinner. Everybody is gonna get judged to there deeds. Here's my main point: If u really wanna know about a religion(any) don't look at a hindu,muslim,christian or Jew. Read the holy scriptures, then u will actually see what the religion is about. No one is a perfect human being or a perfect follower of religion. Jus cos of a particular guy don't spew hatred towards the religion. I like the motto by arms manufacturers here in the west- "Guns don't kill people;People do." This can be applied to everything.
RE:A great article, exposing Leftist historians
by Guest on Jul 01, 2008 07:56 PM Permalink
PLS DSON COMPARE MODI WIT AURANGZEB.... U KNW I HVE NEVER SEEN A CRUEL PERSON LIK MODI HE RIPENED A PREGNEN WOMAN STOMAC AURANG NEVER DID THIS HE WANTED TO SPREAD ISLAM THTS IT I DON UNDERSTAND Y U HINDUS R MAKIN IT A BIG ISSUE ONE DAY U PEOPLE LL KNW WHT S T TRUTH THEN U LL BE N HELL CRYIN,SHOUTIN I'MN SURE MODI LL GO 2 HEL COZ OF HIS BAD DEEDS....U DON BEL N ISLAM I UNDERSTAND BUT STOP INSULTIN ISLAM U COWARDS
RE:A great article, exposing Leftist historians
by fahad on Feb 26, 2008 07:12 PM Permalink
Mr. Kumar i think u r not aware of the research with enough proof against modi was presented by a hindu himself. if u observe it has always been some hindus having always a hatred feeling towards muslim and trust me, i being a muslim and many (proper) muslims i would use the term,never have hatred against any non-muslim without any geniun proof. it's not a debate,that it is necessary for anyone to win.what matters is the truth.search for the truth rather than searching for a way to prove muslims wrong or right. take care, god bless
RE:A great article, exposing Leftist historians
by mandook on Mar 07, 2008 08:27 PM Permalink
If any Muslim does not condemn Aurangazeb IF what is said by Gautier is true, then such muslim is not only a supporter of the misdeeds of Aurangazeb but a hateman of other religions
Aurangzeb was a true muslim and we are proud of him. he proved that for a muslim Allah comes first even before your brother or father. Maybe there is mid way in other religions but in Islam whether a person is true muslim or not, there is no midway. you can not say prayers and also keep drinking. you can not mold islam according to your needs which aurangzeb's forefathers did. A true muslim is one who obeys god, does not matter someone likes it or not. Thats why no-one could defeat him in his life because Allah was with him.
RE:RE:Aurangzeb a true muslim
by nitin on Mar 08, 2008 12:49 AM Permalink
Everything is true in your post. You can say the same exact thing about Osama Bin Laden too. In fact this explains why the rest of the world considers them terrorist. The muslims who don't agree with you take a deep look at their own religion and ponder why they are still Muslim?
RE:Aurangzeb a true muslim
by Himanshu Rajgor on Feb 18, 2008 11:29 PM Permalink
Islam is based on violence which makes it a religion of sick psychos. That your views are irrelevant is proved from the fact that you have not even written your name.
RE:RE:Aurangzeb a true muslim
by fahad on Feb 26, 2008 07:21 PM Permalink
i'm surprized to know that a non-muslim having so much knowledge about islam.lol.do u know majority of muslim are yet not aware of islam themselves or if they are,they don't follow it like other non-muslims. relax and for a while avoid looking at muslims at present.and try n realize why are there majority of PRACTICING muslim compared to anyother religion in the world.PRACTICING includes prayers,love and peace for anyone,whether it be a muslim or a non-muslim. try and find out by u'r self what islam is,rather than listening to anyone and considering it as truth. anger is the first step to darkness. take care god bless
Although the cruelty of Aurangzeb has been documented by historian after historian, we stll have a road, very near Parliament House, New Delhi named 'Aurangzeb Road'.Is it not an irony. It is almost the equivalent of having 'Hiler Street', near the Israeli Parliament House in Tel Aviv! Vivek Hattangadi Ahmedabad - Gujarat, India vivekhattangadi@yahoo.co.in vivekhattangadi@aol.com 13th November 2007
RE:Aurangzeb
by mandook on Mar 07, 2008 08:30 PM Permalink
Very true. This was done by Nehru, the antinational person. To please Muslims and get their votes.
i want to know if there existed a person named Dhukkaram Khan as a minister in Aurangasheeb ministry? Did Dhukkaram Khan took poison when he was ordered by Aurangasheeb to kill his own father?
RE:THE GREAT & MAGNIFICIENT MOGHUL EMPEROR ''AURANGZEB''
by tamal sarkar on Aug 30, 2007 12:58 PM Permalink
Was the Fix Tax only taken from Muslims in Rajput Ruled states .The answer is NO .But Jiziya was applicable to Only Non Muslims who holded Land or wealth.Tax in whatever form is Not abjectionable but Tax applied on basis of following a particular religion is Conservative and Fanatic Act .In Hinduism there is not Concept of taxing Non believers or Non Followers.
RE:RE:RE:THE GREAT & MAGNIFICIENT MOGHUL EMPEROR ''AURANGZEB''
by imran khan on Jan 02, 2008 03:27 PM Permalink
mr. u have to know that muslims are from 1100 to 1800 century..
and india is of only and only of muslims but when "AURANGZEB" died after that the main power of all muslims died because the most important and WALI OF ALLAH is "AURANGZEB" IS THE GREAT AND MAGNIFICIENT MOGHA; EMPEROR..
TODAY MUSLIMS ARE WANTS ONLY PEACE BUT NO ONE UNDERSTAND THA U CAN READ QURAAN SHAREEF
AND CAN UNDERSATND WHAT ACTUALLY ISLAM SAYS..
ISLAM SAY THAT IT WANT PEACE AND WALK ON ALLAH'S ORDER..
RE:RE:RE:RE:THE GREAT & MAGNIFICIENT MOGHUL EMPEROR ''AURANGZEB''
by mandook on Mar 07, 2008 08:31 PM Permalink
Then why are not presentday Muslims not condemning Aurangazeb?
RE:RE:RE:THE GREAT & MAGNIFICIENT MOGHUL EMPEROR ''AURANGZEB''
by fahad on Feb 26, 2008 07:37 PM Permalink
brother to understand the concept u have to understand the senario.if the rajput or anyone fought and lost then they have to either join the army or leave the country and if a peace traty has been sighned before the war than this jiziya u r talking about was only taken from the king or the ruler and not with people. anywayz the best way to understand would be,u might have muslim saying aurangzeb r.a was a good muslim.so try and find out,what is the best example to be a good muslim and if u cannot find then try searching for a life history of out last prophet muhammad(s.w.a.s).you will surely understand what r the rules and regulations muslims follow and surely auranzeb r.a did those. detail clarifications and proofs needed do let me know. take care god bless
