Simi should be banned and all top leaders of simi should be put in jail. They are ruining our culture and causing national insecurity. Also we should ban christian missionaries. They are spreading false christ religion to Indians who are good.
RE:RE:RE:Ban on Simi is right
by vijay parasar on Feb 16, 2007 12:27 AM Permalink
shiv sena,rss is the outcome of the Hindu frustration,operssion . if u wipe out congress and commies i guarntee that the above org. will have no role to paly and they will die down the next dat otherwise these hooligans(con.&commies) and making them more strong and in turn they find supporters in large nos. cveryday. u understand??
RE:RE:RE:RE:Ban on Simi is right
by syed nazar on Feb 15, 2007 09:12 PM Permalink
simi may be anti nation and so is Shivsena, bajrang dal and Narendra modi of gujrat. What is thousands of innocent muslims killed during gujrat riots and babri masjid demolition. I know its not good to open old wounds but facts r facts.
Fareeda u need to ask them who lost their near and dear during the riots (for shivsena, bajrang dal)and also bomb blasts (for SIMI).
It must b realised that u cannot ban one organisation and hope for peace. Peace can only b achieved by mutual trust, fair oppurtunities, fair trial, equal rights & education etc. Its only then these so call protectors of religion will have no followers and they get banned/vanished themselves.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Ban on Simi is right
by Mayank Kumar on Feb 15, 2007 09:07 PM Permalink
We donot know whether SIMI has put BOMBS or not. But, this is for sure that time has come to think "what ISLAM preaches". DOes it preach violence? Taliban is raising heads again. Can any civilised person on this earth support the barbarian culture of Talibanism. Buddhist statues were destroyed. Public hanging was resorted to. Muslims must go modern just as our SHABANA says. Go hitech. Show talents. Indian industrialisation and IT has thrown a great opportunity. There is no discrimination. INDIA is full of opportunities. Even then, Kashmir is burning. It has destroyed our great heritage.
RE:India
by fareeda on Feb 15, 2007 08:47 PM Permalink
It is not every where but it is where ever you are week or supported by dirty vote bank politicians.
This organisation is fit for nothing.
They have done nothing for real development of muslims and the dirty politicians mentioned above are also fit for nothing for muslims as the real good done for muslims by them is nill.
Well as hailing from North Kerala i know much about Simi. When we go to school they call us (Hindus) Kafirs. During the 90s there were the incidents of burning of cinema theaters because it is against Islam. They were posters ."Hindustan Kabristan, Pakistan Gulistan' these were posted by SIMI and ISS. In my opinion fault is in our part because WE (HINDUS) ARE DIVIDED AND WE ARE PREACHERS OF SO CALLED (F***) SECULARISM. wE NEED LEADERS LIKE Tiger pRABHAKARAN but we have only paper tigers like .....you know better
RE:RE:Ban On simi
by rajesh on Feb 15, 2007 08:53 PM Permalink
hey you are indirectly mentioning the Gujrat problem. Whatever happend in gujrat is because of Godhra. It is a COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT. I think you got the point. We are not COWS we can too make to ........got the point
RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by Renuka Sharma on Feb 15, 2007 10:06 PM Permalink
And what will you say when SIMI or others justify their acts in similar manner by calling their acts Collective Punishment!!! Think Again... Dont forget that its we Hindus who started it all way back in 1990 by pulling down the mosque.. which benefitted us in no ways... But yes lakhs of people were homeless and thousands killed - both Hindus and Muslims.... Dont you think that We Hindus have been responsible for the killing of not muslims buit atleast the Hindus... And Godhra is not separate - its part of the Ayodhya Scandal.. Why do we people bring back the bygones, in the name of Shila daan, trishul daan etc... The godhra contained Kar sevaks.... The same Kar Sevaks who collected from all over the country during the Ayodhya episode.. they were over a lakh kar sevaks, on road, on dec 6, who pulled down the mosque and killed thousand of muslims on their way....... If you justify this, where do you justify the raping of women - No one spared not even old women, neither childred......... You justify that tooooo!! If Islam is what they preach, then set an example........ we are also not what Hinduism preached........
RE:RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by chaitanya kumar on Feb 15, 2007 11:25 PM Permalink
The thing about "Secularism" in Malyasia, Indonesia and Turkey is that, they are becoming fundamentalist now. In Malaysia people are asked to wear full Burqas by some sections. It was a peaceful nation before. Vociferous support is gaining ground there for Mr. Alqaeda and the King Laden. Turkey is rearing it's head too. About smaller states like UAE, Bahrain etc, they are very small in size and filled with non-arabs and non-muslims of all hues and colours. Get them out of there and you will the "secularism" of those lands.
RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by Nadeem Khan on Feb 15, 2007 09:55 PM Permalink
so by calling it collective punishment you just justified killing of innocent people. I don't justify killing of people in kashmir or in 9/11. All human life is sacred. But according to you, COLLECTIVE punishment is justified. You are no different than any extremist out there who has no value for life.
RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by chaitanya kumar on Feb 15, 2007 08:50 PM Permalink
well, NO Muslim nation follows "secularism" and you guys love those nations. How do you explain it? India is much better.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by syed nazar on Feb 15, 2007 09:18 PM Permalink
Chaitanya 2 need 2 get ur facts right....UAE, Maylasia etc r muslim countries who r prime example of secularism. For ur info there has never been riots in these countries on basis of religion despite significant population being non muslims. Make a judgment for ur self regarding our home country.
There is a reason for whatz happening now and can b reasolved only by us n not by comparing other countries
RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by ravi sinha on Feb 15, 2007 10:19 PM Permalink
Renuka, Oil rich countries have enuf wealth, but did u ever thought from where oil came..its not produced by them..its natural something they got as gift...and all those company listed they r not natural..they r created by Hindu leaders...what was the state of Baharin before 1940...a penny less state...before they found oil to be rich...so its no hardwork..take pakistan for ex...how many company in pakistan u can name of the status of likes of tata,birla?
RE:Ban On simi
by on Feb 15, 2007 08:33 PM Permalink
The person who told u kafir is not a muslim, because the holy prophet prohibited anyone telling others a kafir. and a kafir means a muslim not practising religion. And I a am deeply pained as to what has hurt u. ALI
RE:RE:Ban On simi
by chaitanya kumar on Feb 15, 2007 08:35 PM Permalink
holy prophets tell many things. But the question is, what is the state of Islam today? why are people blowing themselves in the name of Jehad? why aren't others doing it? did their holy prophets say something different?
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Ban On simi
by Renuka Sharma on Feb 15, 2007 09:49 PM Permalink
Dont tell me that there are no no hindus in these companies.... Think again.. America and Europe are fairing well as a country not as individuals and they are Christians... Malaysia is of Muslims... and the oil rich nations are all islamic countries... Dont be biased by saying that only Hindus can perform and no one else can... Thats not proper... Out of the 100 crore in India... How many Hindus are atleast above the poverty line..... Think again....
RE:Rediff
by chaitanya kumar on Feb 15, 2007 08:38 PM Permalink
media of "mainstream" kind is propagating misinformation. It's a concerted campaign to denigrate Hinduism in India. Sarcasm and hypocrisy is not the main issue here. It's not a joke. Some serious things are happening and Hindus like you need to wake up.
These Mulayan elements are actually anti-elements whom speak for anti-nationalist orgs leaving the troublesome kashimiri pandits behind. So these Cruel anti-elements of India had supported SIMI and now what for them? Should they be hanged or throwed out of India. Annnd to the most terror these guys wants to handle defence ministry and again want to sit in PMs chair. No more!!! Enough with this corrupters.
RE:So what is for Mualaym and SP
by syed rahman on Feb 15, 2007 08:41 PM Permalink
HA HA PUMA, In NDA regime, what happend in defence ministry is not hidden from any one. Now, you called mulayam as corrupt, though he is more than just a leader, and though law-and-order problem is their in UP as in other states, but he is an elected CM and will continue to be in next assembly election.
RE:RE:So what is for Mualaym and SP
by Mayank Kumar on Feb 15, 2007 08:57 PM Permalink
Even after NITHARI... There exists no chance for Mulayam to win. DO you know that no senior minister from UP GOVT visited the site? A comment came-" Aisi chhoti chhoti ghatanaaen hoti rahti hain" from a senior SP leader.
RE:Muslim lawyers for hindus cause
by Shahenil Ashraf on Feb 15, 2007 08:18 PM Permalink
The VHP/Shiv Sena and BJP have just appointed a muslim lawyer.. get a life !!
RE:Muslim lawyers for hindus cause
by mahesh kamath on Feb 15, 2007 08:21 PM Permalink
100% agree, we have bad people in our community. But the people are still blind even after 9/11 and 7/7 in the history.
no compromise on the security of the country. the rest are sideshows. if at times, we have to do things a little too harshly, so be it. india is too important to be treated in a cavalier way.
RE:RE:simi
by vipin pm on Feb 15, 2007 08:23 PM Permalink
can you quote few examples regarding this. if you are pointing to RSS shakhas ,let me tell you ,in shakhas training is not given on 'how to use AK 47' .the trainings are conducted on open grounds not in the forest's of kashmir and pakistan.where as most of the muslim outfits like simi undergo training in handling explosives and fatal weapons .
RE:RE:RE:RE:simi
by Pakki Rao on Feb 15, 2007 08:43 PM Permalink
We are innocent people and wo don't with whose bullet we are going to die. Any body who targets innocent people should be banned and please don't identify with their religion ,cast or creed but to their Intention. Dear! what is your intention!!!
