Are LEFTISTS interested to do developement by suppressing people voice. It seems that they have declared emergency in Singur for helping TATA Group against locals wishes. They are doing autocracy and giving true colors of Communists who are not interested to heed public opinion and democracy. Communists are literally declaring that they do not heed or want democracy to function in this country. We are afraid, if they gets power in Centre, they will demolish Indian Democracy as well and supress opinion of differences under brutal force.
force big industrial housed to establish Big Industrial Plants on Waste land
by Anoop Chopra on Feb 05, 2007 12:53 PM Permalink | Hide replies
India has huge barren land, it is nor justified to acquire fertile land for industrial purpose. We are just wasting our already scarce fertile land for industrial purpose, on the other hand we are importing food from abroad. People are justified to oppose such move, while sitting in cities one can not understand value of fertile land. In the name of industrial development this is Farcical surrender to rich and resourceful.
If we force big industrial housed to establish Big Industrial Plants on barren land, we will be able to develop ourselves industrially without disturbing other sectors. Agriculture is equally more important than industrial development.
By acquiring Fertile land for Industrial and residential purpose, in future we will end-up no-where.
Singur land acquisition done by West Bengal Communist Government indicates the bankruptcy of the political ideology of the communist and leftists leaders and supporters. These people were declaring that they are the savior of KISANS and LABORS but the power sandwich they got during the last general election and continuous rule of leftists in West Bengal, their eyes are blind and they are living in fool%u2019s paradise at present. They are supporting Central Govt. in the name of keeping away a recognized political party to come into power which they afraid that if they will come in power, India will be more and more integrated and this integrated India, they and their parties have no role because of their bankrupt policies they are adopting in the name of communism.
We strongly object acquisition of fertile lands for any type of industrial purpose and if it is TATA or BIRLA, they should themselves keep away to ask or acquire land from fertile lands. If they are adamant to remove the entire cultivation and they wanted to import food grains from out of India for the 100 crores people of India, then they are not making any progress for their own country, but they are ruining India and giving India to become another salve rule from the Western Countries, particularly from USA.
Communism and its ideologies are good if the leaders or the parties who are adopting these ideologies are their basis to form party. We understand that since more than 25 years, West Bengal is under Communist Rule and there was enough time to make this state as a true communist land, but they failed to make their ideology because of their leaders and ministers are power hungry and not interested to give the prosperity to their own people who supported continuously during these long rule of any party in a State in India. Left Front is the only party who got an opportunity to rule a state continuously for more than 25 years, except that of the Indian National Congress who ruled the entire country for more than 30 years after independence.
However, both the parties miserably failed to achieve the real progress they wanted to make and in that place rampant corruption and misrule increased which is making turbulence in the entire Indian Territories. The voices coming from the States are being suppressed with the help of their muscle / money power. Administrative and other authorities are simply doing their jobs on superiors / political masters verbal instructions even though most of the instructions are illegal and unconstitutional.
Unrest in Eastern States of India and the problems we are facing in J & K, growing terrorism etc. are the indication of bad administration and policies adopting by the political leaders, particularly the ruling combination, whether it is in states or centre.
Our political masters%u2019 policies are corrupt and they are leading this country for disintegration by creating imbalances on inequality of properties / finance, unemployment, seeding hatred among Indian Public by dividing caste/religion/region basis. Our great India has the resources within India, but the political masters are still asking for investments from foreign countries for developmental or industrial projects.
These political masters opened Indian Territory for foreign individuals / countries for investing their money with the help of World Bank and World Bank is giving money for the developmental activities to India under their own terms and conditions. We failed to understand why these political leaders agreed to opening the doors on the dictated terms of World Bank and European countries when we have our sources in this country itself.
In India, Government bodies are not doing their jobs very systematically under the rules and laws of the land. If these three wings of the Govt., i.e. Income Tax, Excise and Customs and Police Departments did their jobs obediently, earnestly and patriotically, after 1947, then by this time, India would have been a PARADISE on this world!!!
Rampant corruptions everywhere we can see from the top level of the Indian Public Life to the lowest people who are doing their daily jobs for getting bread and butter to live in a peaceful manner! Due to the wrong doings of Income Tax Department and the wrong tax structures adopting/declaring for every annual budget by the Central and State Government, ordinary people lives are getting very very difficult. Black money is huge in India and without this, not a single man can live in India. If we cannot take back the black money/unaccounted money of the individuals/factories/establishments, who ever it may be, our Indian Democracy cannot go in a long way. There will be growing inequalities among the people and the low / no income groups will get more and more violent or even mass suicides we will have to see in the near future.
So, we are asking Indian Political system to be transparent on every deal, rule and be proactive for the overall progress and upliftment for the entire country. Our people should also understand the mistakes Indian Political Parties are doing and we should ask them to rectify it. After all, we have got a good constitution. The constitution is good, but unfortunately 90% of our political leadership became corrupted and remaining 10% are still immature or unable to keep their promises they gave to the voters when they elected from their particular constituencies.
Singur Land Deal is not a single incident and it had happened all over India and it is still happening in other states a well. Indian Public should come forward to protect our fertile lands and forests and the authorities should also stop forthwith to acquire any land from either forest or the land which are using for agricultural crops. We have to safe guard the interests of our KISANS first and without them not a single creature can live in this world. Industrial king pins should declare in public that they will not ask or acquire any land from these sections so that it will ensure no Singur or Nandigram will ever happen in India. We hope that TATA which signed the agreement with West Bengal Govt. should re-consider the decision and ask them to acquire non-agricultural as per their choice to put their car factory. It is the time to prove TATA%u2019s social obligation and not consider this as a sentiment issue. If TATA makes it public this declaration, then it will be the history of Indian Democracy and by doing so, a new chapter can begin for cleansing the Indian Political System as well.
RE:OPEN LETTER TO MR. RATAN TATA, CHAIRMAN OF TATA GROUP
by pradeep agarwal on Feb 05, 2007 01:06 PM Permalink
TATA's have been provide the land by Govt of W.Bengal & hence it is not their responsibility to clarify the deal.The most vocal party that obstructs every possible effort of govt at centre for reforms & largely responsible for scuttling the reform agenda of NDA(UPA never had one) should come out with white paper on land deal in Singur if at all required.
RE:RE:OPEN LETTER TO MR. RATAN TATA, CHAIRMAN OF TATA GROUP
by ramachandran pillai on Feb 05, 2007 03:06 PM Permalink
Singur issue is not a single one as I already stated. We are not asking TATA to clarify the deal they signed between WB Government and TATA. As we respect TATA GROUP and their patriotism very much, they should also see the real problem and whenever they need land for industry they should also declare that they will not take any agricultural land or forest land for developing industrialsation. We knows that here in Singur, WB Govt. is the main culprit, but we want that RATA TATA should make a model to other corporate / business houses and come out clean and declare that they will not acquire land which are using on agricultural purposes. It shows maturity and gives more respect to this Industrial House. But after fully knows that Singur land is using for Agricultural purpose, TATA cannot wash away their hands. The present rulers have declared an emergency in the territory of Singur and its neigbouring country and it shows the ugly color of Govt. the State Govt. and TATA by ignoring public protests and the reason behind the violence, creating a suspicion in the minds that they are fully aware of the status of the land acquired in Singur.
RE:RE:RE:OPEN LETTER TO MR. RATAN TATA, CHAIRMAN OF TATA GROUP
by pradeep agarwal on Feb 05, 2007 05:17 PM Permalink
Your views are appreciated but how on earth can an Industrial house say no to land already acquired by Govt? How do we know that protests by mamta are not creation of her party workers as there were 3500 farmers other day gathered by CPI(M) in support of industrialization. Let Communists pay for all the sins that they have committed against nation in 60 yrs of independence & many more before that & people who vote for such party also has to suffer.
IF WE TRACE HISTORY OF TATAS,ONE THING IS VERY CLEAR THAT THEY HAVE ALWAYS BEEN WORKING,ALWAYS KEEPING IN MIND THE SAFETY, HONOUR & WELFARE OF THE COUNTRY FIRST , SECOND BEING THE EMPLOYEES/SOCIETY & LASTLY THEIR OWN.
BY AGITATING AGAINST PATRIOTIC & PEOPLE ORIENTED COMPANY OF INDIA,THEY ARE SHOWING THEIR ANTI-NATIONAL ATTITUDE JUST FOR A POLITICAL GAIN.
ALL THE PEOPLE AGITATING ARE REQUESTED TO LET TATAA GO AHEAD WITH THE PROJECT & PUT THEIR DEMANDS IN A CIVILISED MANNER.AFTER ALL TATAS ARE ONE AMONGST OURSELVES,ANY HARM TO THEM MEANS HARM TO OURSELVES.
RE:OPEN APPEAL TO THE AGITATORS OF SINGUR.
by ramachandran pillai on Feb 05, 2007 12:57 PM Permalink
We are fully aware about the patriotism of TATA group and I saw the interview he had given to IBN-18 television which was telecasted yesterday. But sometimes, even most patriotic citizen are getting trapped into the hands of selfish people. We expect that as a patriotic Indian Citizen, Mr. Ratan Tata will give suitable steps against acquiring agricultural land for industrial development.
You feel sorry for Tata's as they have been dragged in war that will have no winners.The leftists however deserve no symathy for what they are doing to the nation by blocking entire reform drive initiated by NDA & surrendered by spineless Manmohan singh
This curse Mamata Banerjee is hell bent on destroying the bright future of WB and Kolkata. It is sheet misfortune that she doesn't realize how painful it is to leave home go ut to work elsewhere in the country just because Kolkata doesn't offer enough opportunity and just when things were about to change the curse returned. It is really now or never for Kolkata and the entire West Bengal and if she doesn't realise this, the next gen will never pardon her
RE:Its really now or never
by Big John on Feb 05, 2007 12:23 PM Permalink
Yeah i agree with u, no one wants to be outside home for long. If we have everything available in our native place, we would be glad to return and stay with our families and work. Its all gimmick to be in the limelight. She s a real spoiler.
RE:Its really now or never
by Shibaji Mukherjee on Feb 05, 2007 12:36 PM Permalink
I congratulate you for voicing the larger concern. Mamata is identified with anything that obstructs growth in WB. Her heart is not crying for farmers or anyone, her main agenda 1. Show to BJP/NDA that she is important 2. Try to get a foothold in the WB Countryside, hoping to get a part of the vote bank
She needs to be further congratulated for two things
1. Reviving the naxalite group in WB and giving scope to naxalites from other states to come and prosper in WB, this naxalite are one of the main contributor to the destruction of WB in 70's
2. She succesfully included Jamat and gave communal color to the event and also allowed them to grow on communal line, don't know how many illegal bangladeshi's she is also helping to move in through Jamat and plant RDX etc all across India.
A note to Anuradha, Medha and similar people who have no business to be in WB and supports vested interest. They cannot stand the idea that some industrial development can happen in WB. Why this people don't demand a more equal distribution of industry and investments among all states.. they want the poor states to be poor forever.. all investments should go to TN,AP,MH,Gujarat.. they are happy then.. whenever there is some investment in WB,Orissa,Jharkhand they are up in arms.
RE:RE:Its really now or never
by thana pillay on Feb 05, 2007 12:50 PM Permalink
Common guy, apply some sense, why tata really hell bent on singur, If they sympathetic about WB development, they can start a factory anywere in WB, its all about land, guess 5 years down the line, What would be worth those cheap lands occupied by means of some coersion, unholy nexus, mucsle power, may be Some billions.
But i dont support Mamtha Either. Here tatas reputation, sincerity is questionable, there is brain behindd Tatats plan, paid crores to multiple their family wealth, i am neither againt tata, think the kind of name they have brought for country recently Corus.
Man its about money multiplying, Real Estates and game plan, Mamath just exploiting god(tata) given opportunity.
RE:TATA is right
by ONKAR MUKHERJEE on Feb 05, 2007 12:32 PM Permalink
TATA is not doing anything in this game. It is the ruling party of Bengal who suddenly cannot find enough to do to please the industry. Ironically it was the same party which at one time drove out the industry from Bengal by clamoring for union protection for (non)workers to gain popularity among the masses and secure their vote bank. Now that they have been exposed and are openly criticised for driving out the industry and held responsible for the widespread unemployment of the educated in Bengal, they are trying to woo back the industry at any cost....ironically this time victimising part of the same vote bank they sought to please earlier. Lol Bengal and its ruling party! That doesnt mean to say the other parties want to miss the train this time. Suddenly everyone is up and fighting for the common good. Lol Bengal! I just wonder once this hue and cry dies out and everyone once again settle back to their comfort zones (including the press), who will inquire into the well-being of the poor peasants who are losing their land and being promised of a job with MUCH HIGHER INCOMES? Thats exactly what is going through the minds of the peasants I guess. After all a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. Going by the record and credibility of the existing political parties of the country as a whole, thats worth a thought.....watsay others???????
If u have money political influence one can uproot innocent prople out of their native, in the name of development, jobs , weaslth and all these phoneys.
TATAs should be shamed of doing such a silly thing after too much of resistence. THink about the common man , not the weell settled middle class.
If u want to start a industry go to Barren land,, think about Isralies, they groom roses on hot desert>.. dont u know that???.
Oh my God save my innocent, uneducated downtrodden people....
