Guys, think about the reliality...we haven't seen this type of long debate any where else apart from Rediff..and just go through the below information posted by one of our citizen...
An observation on Cauvery Tribuna's Verdict.
Total volume of Water available in Cauvery basin area, including all 4 states TN, Karnataka, Pondicherry & Kerala is 740 TMC
Please note that verdict does not say that Karnataka should release 419 TMC to TN. It only says that TN should get 419 TMC out of total of 740 TMC available in Cauvery. For TN to get 419 TMC, Karnataka needs to release only 192 TMC. TN gets rest of water from Cauvery water capturing area in TN itself. This is 13 TMC less than tribunals' interim award of 205 TMC.
Out of 192 TMC that TN gets from Karnataka, it has to release 30 TMC to Kerala and 7 TMC to Pondicherry.
So, unlike the media projects, verdict is not against Karnataka. It is more or less in line with interim verdict only.
Infact karnataka get more share than TN. Understand the reality..
If, Karnataka does not have enough water, what we should do. Let us talk about reality. You can manufucture water by yourself, but first you should drink that.... THINK ABOUT THE REALITY AND THEN POST
RE:RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by Lokesh BS on Feb 05, 2007 04:44 PM Permalink
Arjun we also can understand what might have happened to the peoples if there is no water.. Bu twhy can't you just think in the same line.. if theere is no water how we can servive.. if there is only 5 glass of water we can shre 3:2 or 2.5:2.5 but if you are arsking for 4 glass .. how we can give our water to you by keeping starve our peoples.. is this is the justice you are speaking out..
RE:RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by arjun on Feb 05, 2007 04:45 PM Permalink
What if the veridct has favore you then you will start celebrating great justice ???Look if you wnat to appeal go to court but dont attack tamils or create violence.We as indians should think more broadly and cannot further create division amonmg themselves.Hoe can you tolerate someone who says that he is realeasing only drainage water to Tamil Nadu.
RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by sreenivas murthy on Feb 05, 2007 04:48 PM Permalink
iSNT IT A shame that we are quarreling amongst ourselves over something, which in reality doesnt affect our day to day lives, too much of politicising an issue will lead to lot of tension between states which have basically known to be peaceful. The credit of growth of bangalore, madras, hyderabad, pune etc, do not go to any one individual, community, language. These are happening cities because of the attitude of people living in these cities. Today we are showing economic success because of a unity by default. Lets hope this award doesnt create disunity amongst us and lead to tensions among different language speaking persons. I am a kannadiga living in chennai. I am proud of my tamil neighbours who have been great. I am sure many a tamilian settled in blore will vouch for the same. Lets be united. Hope the respective governments start thinking of saving rain water, recycling it somehow or create artificial lakes etc, let them give us solutions which will take us into the future than blame each other and cause infight.
RE:RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by arjun on Feb 05, 2007 04:55 PM Permalink
Great to hear the same Murthy.Nut how could you tolerate someone when he syas that you are using our drainage water.Is this how we behave to you.Answer me.
RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by Raghu SM on Feb 05, 2007 04:35 PM Permalink
Arjun if you and your goveronment has the capability to take IT out of bangalore we are most welcome...MNC people know where to set up and where not!! Hope you got which is the best place and who are good!!Think my friend
RE:RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by on Feb 05, 2007 04:41 PM Permalink
Thats Y new companies are being set up in Chennai... go per stats my dear. No more blore is IT hub.
RE:I am from Tanjore!!!
by amit dhamane on Feb 05, 2007 04:48 PM Permalink
We are indians first..it is very sad that we keep fighting..no one is going 2 remove tamils from bangalore nor IT companies will go 2 chennai right now (in few years u will also have them)..but the point is we should think like indians and not like idiots and fight on natural resources..we should discuss and negotiate where in all parties are happy :) and then look at other issues we are facing today..like building new dams..we have 2 grow..we have 2 show the world that we are not third world country...so lots of work has to be done by us..god bless india..
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by b vinay on Feb 05, 2007 06:01 PM Permalink
If 'Report abuse' disabled by moderator for this posting, dear frinds please wake up we are on a wrong platform where the leader/co-ordinator/moderator is misleading us...... Yavattu srigandada jote guddadu but sagani jote sarasa beda
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Dhanunjaya Gotur on Feb 05, 2007 05:05 PM Permalink
It is not Kannadiga's doesn't know...It's stupid Tamilians doesn't know.
1. Art of Sharing : Even though lot of verdict we r releasing lot of water to Tamilnadu from Cauvery, but you people don't know how to utilize it. 2. Patriotism : Just go to Madikeri and Kodagu you will come to know the meaning of Patriotism.
3. Hardwork : I don't know Tamil's Hard work , It's because Sir M. Visweshwaraiah 's Hard work KRS is there and that's why u r asking some tmc of water. And there is lot of Hardwork befind Infosys Narayan Murthy where you tamil guys working.
(they eat and sleep and get electicity & Food from others) : You can see in the Tamil capital Chennai Railway station and Bus stop.
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Yamanappa Ogennavar on Feb 05, 2007 04:47 PM Permalink
Can you share, what you shared with Karnataka. Kannadiga's are so liberal that is the reason more than 40 lac Tamils live in Bangalore. Kannadiga,s speak all languages in Bangalore. Just show me any Tamilian speaking Kannada in chennai.
RE:RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by suresh n on Feb 05, 2007 11:50 PM Permalink
Come on Man... why the hell shuld i speak Kannada in chennai.
RE:RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Ashok on Feb 07, 2007 03:40 PM Permalink
Please excuse me for saying this. It seems to me that Kannadigas outside Karnataka are not sufficiently attached to their language to speak it openly outside Karnataka. Therefore the question is NOT show me one Tamil speaking Kannada in Chennai but show me one KANNADIGA openly speaking Kannada in Chennai or Mumbai or Delhi or Calcutta.
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Kumbar kn on Feb 05, 2007 04:35 PM Permalink
is it? u r sharing everythng? hw cme? u ppl here to live be carefull!!
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Santosh Chadichal on Feb 05, 2007 04:47 PM Permalink
I think it is idiots like you who are spreading more disharmony than the politicians. If we never were to share Cauvery water, Tamilnadu would have been a desert by now. As for patriotism whats your locus standii to make a make a comment on Karnataka/Kannadigas? As for electricity and food, get ur fundas correct and talk.
RE:RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by jayaramaiah MV on Feb 05, 2007 05:38 PM Permalink
Kannadigas are all along have been liberal, open minded, sharing etc with all excellent qualities. This has been endorsed by one and all. People before blaming others should search their hearts and talk.
RE:RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by vivek jauhari on Feb 05, 2007 05:25 PM Permalink
why u feel bad. he is currect only.. kannadigas not require to learn all these they need a open mind too. no body can stop any natural resource for use to others. it is not any single state property.
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by rayker rayker on Feb 05, 2007 04:37 PM Permalink
i guess the statesareallequally bised, there's nopatriotic fervour left. thats because everypolitician divides instead of uniting. we are just fighting within ourselves, neither has TN been proved a righteous state, nor has the KTK government been punished. its stupidity to fight amongst states.
RE:Kannadigas - Please learnt he art of sharing and patriotism.
by Shri Padmanabhan on Feb 05, 2007 04:33 PM Permalink
Don't say like this they know but little bit adament that is all. It will be o.k
I ask other states take opportunity of this verdict. Soon bangalore will become Uncomfortable city due to violence on this and all IT companies will force to run out of here.
RE:RE:Take opportunity
by Santosh Chadichal on Feb 05, 2007 05:00 PM Permalink
U forget the fact that there were and still are umpteen number of public sectors in bangalore long before IT industry started in Bangalore. Uninformed bigots like you are a black spot on the society.
RE:Take opportunity
by vivek jauhari on Feb 05, 2007 05:29 PM Permalink
It will happend SAN very soon.. u r right.. IT companies r here currect but is they will remain here.. no ways.. they have to give security and peace to there employees. but now kannadies are showing there nature.. finally they r son of.......
1. I feel verdict is impartial. But it had to take into account the rainfal and inflow and fixed percentage based on this data. We are all Indians, we live and let live.
RE:cauvery water tribunal verdict
by vivek jauhari on Feb 05, 2007 05:31 PM Permalink
who want more they should get more it is not like one state of owner of that...
RE:cauvery
by murthy gowda on Feb 05, 2007 04:33 PM Permalink
What basis do you welcome this justice. karnataka is having al lteh rights to have more shares on Cauvery water.
RE:RE:cauvery
by amit dhamane on Feb 05, 2007 04:42 PM Permalink
No one in india can say that he owns more natural resources or others can have more...we are democracy and i think we should have election like one in US on different issues along with the normal elections. (not twice)..we should vote for various issues...and that should settle the issue...
This is not a right judgememnt. All resident of karnatak must fight against our rights on Cauvery. Dear Bagalorean please co-operate 7 support for this fight ( No voilance please)
RE:Cauvery tribunal gives TN 419 tmcft, 270 to Karnataka
by Shri Padmanabhan on Feb 05, 2007 04:39 PM Permalink
Thanks friend for saying no violence but what is your right with understanding the facts then we would go for fight. Present is just 192 tmc previous..... go and refer if u know the way.
RE:Cauvery tribunal gives TN 419 tmcft, 270 to Karnataka
by mylarappa m on Feb 05, 2007 04:39 PM Permalink
Absolute injustice to karnataka. Save india from central govt(congress govt).
Rediff wanted more page views may be and therefore did not gave full information on Cauvery verdict. Please guys know full information before abusing each other. First know the verdict then debate...
