What can we expect from a nominated PM coming from Rajya Sabha? He has been talking thru his turban. UPA itself is a bunch of jokers.Former West Bengal CM Jyoti Basu, a foxy CM - described NDA government as a bunch of cattle!! It is unfortunate that we have become a hand rag of USA.Develped nations sanctions against india during NDA government was a blessing in disguise. We have been own our own.Now every nation wants to do business with india.Why this UPA government is lying thru its teeth?
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by samir banerjee on Dec 04, 2007 08:24 PM Permalink
It is unfortunate that someone had put your name in wrong basket.You have no ANAND nor any TEERTHA.Only insene can describe one of the most internatioally respected,non corrupt honest highly educated person like Dr Manmohan Singh in the term you have used.In a democratic system critical analysis is usual but with a dignity.If we compare Dr Manmohan Singh with Mr Jaswant Sinha it will be disrespect to Dr Singh Jaswant Sinha's has come and gone through the corridoor of South and North Block but there is one in a billion where you find an astute cool head with so much knowledge as Dr Manmohan Singh People like you and Jaswant Sinha were critical and abusive as you are doing now when Dr Manmohan Singh initiated economic reform in 1991 as Finance Minister, that he is going to barter Indias national asset,destroy Indian business hand by advocating open market and creating level playing field.Unless you are blind or not in control on your knowledge then it will be clear to you where Indian economy stand to day an envey to even USA.BJP initiated N-deal but unfortunately could not conclude as they did not come in power.We at least give credit to Dr Manmohan Singh for his placing the document of the deal in the floor of the Parliament.Even to day no one knows what went on between USA (Mr Talbott) and BJP (Mr Jaswant Singh).Mr Jaswant Singh must be credited to have the guts to say that there could not have been a better deal under the present context.China and Pakist
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by Abhay T on Dec 04, 2007 08:45 PM Permalink
Dear Samir, I don't think Anand has said anything to disrespct MR. Singh. It is just the fact that he comes from Rajyasabha and is powerless without Sonia's support. A person who is not considered as a leader by is leading the country. With all respect to Mr. Singh and the post of PM, it is sad to say that he is handling Prime Ministership just like any other job. There is no doubt about his honesty and dignity. As far as the debate on nuclear deal is concerned, it is Dr. Singh and Laluprasad Yadav who got personal and not Mr. Sinha. Please comment based on context rather than just supporting someone you like.
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by samir banerjee on Dec 04, 2007 10:49 PM Permalink
Dear Abhay, Power dosent come from any house you represent.Mr Pranab Mukherjee till this term was never a member in the lower house but was as powerful as any in the political arena for years becouse he with his bengali english was absolutely clear in his mind about the subject he is speaking.It is not the house that gives you strength but the strength comes from your conviction of knowledge,mental balance and hard core honesty.There are number of elected members in the ower house(Muscleman,Criminals,corrupts and with questionable record while in civil service) and if you want to say thay are more powerful than Dr Manmohan Singh, I am afraid I am not line with you.You are speaking from one sided mind set-the BJP line.Will you believe that BJP was almost signing NPT and Mr Jaswant Sinha was a party to it.Howmany times NDA Govt. discusses proposed Neuclear deal while the talk was going on between Mr Brijesh Misra and Mr Talbott.None.Mr Brijesh Misra along with Mr aswant Singh not Sinha complimented Dr Manmohan Singh when he went to apraise Mr Vajpaye about the deal.The subject matter is N-deal so I am dealing with it.The subject matter is ding good for the country with honesty.
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by Taklu Gandhi on Dec 04, 2007 10:06 PM Permalink
Manmohan Singh and honesty, what a joke? In 1999 LokSabha Elections, Manmohan Singh was congress candidate from one of the Delhi constituency. This constituency had a huge Sikh voters. In one of the elections rally, he was asked be Sikhs why he did not protest against Congress's sikh riots. His answer was that these Sikh Riots were handiwork of RSS. On the election day, there was huge turnout of Sikh voters. All the surveys predicted easy win for Manmohan Singh. Result-Manmohan Singh lost heavily. Sikhs showed him that he was a dishonest congressi chamcha who can sacrifice his morality for the sake of winning one lok sabha election. Can this guy be trusted. shame on him not even protesting when people from his community were being massacred by Congress Gundas.
I have heard about a Malayalam saying from a friend of mine, which says, If you are stuck for a proper reply, make faces at your opponent. This is the sort of debate being conducted by our POLLUTICIANS in parliament and outside.
MM Singh is responsible for this horrible mess. Unfortunately he is still not learning a lesson. Because of his ego, the country is suffering. He should take all parties into confidence and take them along with him. If this treaty fails it will be equally due to him and we can not just blame the left or right.
Mounting a scathing attack on the UPA government on the Indo-US nuclear agreement, main opposition BJP on Tuesday said it will re-negotiate the deal if it comes to power. "I declare that if we come to power, which we will, we will re-negotiate the deal," senior party leader and former External Affairs Minister Yashwant Sinha said in the Rajya Sabha participating in the short duration discussion. Sinha said the UPA government was "misleading" the nation on all key issues including the right to reprocess fuel, energy security and ending country's nuclear apartheid. "All the scientists whom I have spoken to have told me that the nuclear isolation has proved to be a boon for India," he said advising the government to stop this "cry over ending the apartheid". He said when the entire world wanted to do business with India, "what apartheid you are talking about". The debate saw heated personal exchanges between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Sinha over BJP's allegation that India could not sign a deal with Russia for additional reactors under pressure from the US. Sinha's charge was stoutly denied by the Prime Minister who said the agreement with Russia could not have been initialed without India finalizing the country-specific agreement with the IAEA and the NSG. Sinha said the Prime Minister in his July 2005 press conference in Washington had stated that the deal would have the support from "all thinking" segment of the population in the country. He wondered whether all those
RE:RE:here is the right scene
by tun tun on Dec 04, 2007 07:18 PM Permalink
continued
opposing the agreement including himself, Sitaram Yechury (CPI-M), Amar Singh (SP) and the AIADMK did not belong to the "thinking segment". Reading from the Hyde Act and the draft 123 agreement, the BJP leader said there was no assurance of fuel supply for life time for Indian reactors in these documents. "I challenge and ask where is the assurance of fuel supply in the 123 agreement," he said. Sinha said while the government makes claim about achieving energy security, neither the Prime Minister nor External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee seemed to be bothered about the cost. The BJP leader said the Manmohan Singh government was coming under the US pressure as was evident from the recent setback to the Iranian LNG project and the State Bank of India not being able to transact business with Iran. Observing that Indo-Russia ties also saw a nosedive in the recent past, Sinha said this was borne out by the fact that the External Affairs Minister could not meet his counterpart when he visited Moscow. "What is happening to India-Russia relations," he asked.
RE:Yaswant Sinha, a man of doubtful professional integrity.
by Frankly Speaking on Dec 04, 2007 07:23 PM Permalink
As finance minister, Yaswant Sinha, sold the gold on the pretext of raising the funds, even the interest rates on retired people savings were sliding rapidly, Indian rupee was devaluing vis-a-vis dollar and other major currencies alarmingly.
RE:Yaswant Sinha, a man of doubtful professional integrity.
by ralph nader on Dec 04, 2007 07:27 PM Permalink
dont give wrong info--it was chandrashekar's cash and carry govt which did that
RE:RE:Yaswant Sinha, a man of doubtful professional integrity.
by comman man on Dec 04, 2007 07:32 PM Permalink
You also seem to be a victim of rumours of Yaswant Sinha
RE:RE:Yaswant Sinha, a man of doubtful professional integrity.
by comman man on Dec 04, 2007 07:28 PM Permalink
Yes, I agree that country was heading for horrible time, a complete mess because of incompetence of Yaswant Sinha
This issue has dragged on for too long. it is time the Honourable Prime Minister give a spirited reply in defence of this nuclear deal in both the house of parliament and follow it up immediately with a Televised address to the nation, explaining in his very simple way the whole issue of nuclear deal. He should however take care to answer all the critical aspect without getting in to any accusation of the personalities or parties. The nuclear deal is good for the country and we all know it, but petty and arrogant politicians are trying to scuttle it for god knows what reasons. It is indeed surprising that BJP is also acting childish, which could be because they are not getting credit for that deal. Maybe the Prime Minister can take Vajpayee or Advani the next time he goes to finalize the said deal.
Why is PM getting irked by remarks from opposition. Why dont PM give propoer explaination to house. Does he needs speech writer from Congress preseident or does he needs his speech reviewed by congress president. Why does Indian "Dr." PM does not want to act as professional responsible statesman. This all proves that "deal" is done without keeping nation interest in mind.
RE:RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by ralph nader on Dec 04, 2007 06:59 PM Permalink
dont blame MS--he has to keep looking over his shoulder at Madam gandhi for approval and now junior gandhi too--he is becoming like that idiot deva gowda--never heard PM's speak like this or trade charges
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by Balakumaran on Dec 04, 2007 06:51 PM Permalink
italyian interest is more important than indian dear
RE:PM, Yashwant Sinha trade charges during N-deal debate
by Bhatji on Dec 04, 2007 06:55 PM Permalink
salakumaran u must do a crash course in english i hope u wont go a crash somewhere
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by prashant kumar on Dec 04, 2007 07:17 PM Permalink
Look here u idiot BONG this fellow, Yashwant, was an IAS and u know any idiot can become politician but not Intellectual all can become IAS, SO bear this in MIND when u say HEAD AND SHOULDER ABOVE
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by ralph nader on Dec 04, 2007 07:02 PM Permalink
another bong commie with chinese/bangladesh leanings--cant even read properly before jumping into the fray--FYI yashwant Sinha was an IAS officer before joining politics.
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by tun tun on Dec 04, 2007 06:45 PM Permalink
mr banerjea.. u look very child in comparing mr sing and mr banerjea.. Both of them are well proved in their field. Dr. singh of course has so many degress with good percentage on the other hand Mr. sinha wwas distrctict magistrate (DM) one of the toughfest competetion of world. he resigned the post when he was forced by politician to work in wrong ways.
About their vovality.. Mrs Sonia Gandhi also speeks very less -- (less vocal) do u compare sonia, Singh and sinha...?????? About the N-Deal, BJP has initiated this deal and they are not fuly against this but they are against the Hyde act clause which has been opposed by so many imminent nuclear scientist. I think this would be enough for u to be satisfied.. if not come on and we will have long debate...
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by Balakumaran on Dec 04, 2007 06:36 PM Permalink
its not jaswant its yashwant sinha, read the article before commenting
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by Carti Rengasamy on Dec 04, 2007 06:40 PM Permalink
You first pronounce correctly the BJP leader name. He is Shri. Yashwant Sinha and not Shri. Jaswant Sinha and the criticize him.
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by Bhatji on Dec 04, 2007 06:47 PM Permalink
is ur name written correctly it should be kutti rangaswamy
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by Chandra SK on Dec 04, 2007 06:42 PM Permalink
and we keep wondering why foreigners ruled us for 1000 years....with people like samir....
RE:Mr Jaswant Sinha and Primr Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
by Sreedhar Pothukuchi on Dec 04, 2007 06:47 PM Permalink
And why Bengal continues to have commies ruling it. And the best bet being clue less Mamata and Pranad. With mindless bozos like S... Ban....
