The left is opposing this deal only on ideological grounds - the left is anti US. They are opposing not because the deal could harm India's long term interest.Their decision is not based on what is good or bad for India but based on what is good for their party's survival. So in short comies are selfish towards their ideology even at the cost of India's benefit. The lalus and Pawars and others in the coalition are not with Manmohansingh because they do not have the guts to face an early election now ( in case commies pull the govt down). These coalition partners are selfish too like commies- selfish and greedy for power. Certainly India's interests are not included in their decision making process ( I am neither saying nuclear deal is beneficial for India nor I am against it for the reason that I do not know exact implication of this deal - some of which would become clear only after it is and if it is implemented). I am more concerned about the decision making process of the coalition partners in UPA. None of them have India's interest in mind - though they are taking great pains to make it seem as if they have only India's interest on mind. As for BJP - it does not influence over the outcome of this deal and its opinion or stand on this issue does not really matter.... so they are doing what any 'opposition' would do - oppose it for the heck of it..then bring out arguements supporting the stand...India Shining ? Samajwadi is a bunch of loosers who are lost as far as takin
Solar and Wind energy, if promoted by the GOVERNMENT properly can fulfil every requirement. The money which we are investing in Nuclear reactors and Hydroelectricity etc. should be diverted in form of SUBSIDIES to the LARGE SCALE promotion of renewable sources of energy. Otherwise all our slogans on environmenmtal conservation will be slogans only. And I request readers to do some more research before writing anything against any idea. Why do we see everything so negatively? To quote a report by Rob Edwards published in "The New Scientist" , 10th June 2006 (Magazine issue 2555),"In the mountain village of Kara Agach in Kyrgyzstan, people are unwittingly eating radioactive waste. Radium left behind by more than two decades of uranium mining during the Soviet era has contaminated their chickens,milk, potatoes and pears." THIS IS JUST ONE EXAMPLE.... Till what time will we live in stone age? Everything must be decided on the merits and demerits & on purely scientific grounds. If the nuclear energy was so good for india, it should also have been for US. But under intense public pressure, US has not made a single nuclear reactor after 1979...What is the point in ignoring the freely available energy and kissing the death? If we could start to see the things in more correct light, we can save our nature from more extinction. With warm regards, Chetan Upadhyaya, Satya Foundation
RE:Why are the parties silent on Subsidies to green energy sector?
by Attatar Yena on Dec 07, 2007 05:09 AM Permalink
Could you please let us know if Wind Energy is enough to meet the mega mega Watts requirement of India..? Is it available 24 hours a day ?? You are presenting an arguement only on basis of emotions and not on the basis of facts.. can you cite one scientific study ( not an NGO observation) that can validate your claim that wind energy is sufficient to meet all our requirement ??
I wonder when will the smaller parties rise to the level of thinking/ doing good to the country. Amar Singh has all the time for his celeb friends and leisure trips with them. Im sure all these parties think of the N desl as another opportunity to sneer at the govt. Hopeless politicians!!
It is funny to see the smaller parties react to the nuclear deal. Most of them dont have a clue. Please conduct a quick test in the Lok Sabha about the nuclear deal, lets see how much our MPs actually understand it.
I would like to see the Mulayam and Laloo understanding of the issue.
RE:Does Samajwadi Party understand the nuclear deal
by Rohit Panicker on Dec 04, 2007 09:40 AM Permalink
actually vinod dua of ndtv in his programm KHBARDAR had shown mp's indeed had no clue; even of bigger parties like INC and BJP. HE asked them what was their opinion about "CHROMIUM REACTORS"; most of them didnt know that chromium was not radioactive element, and as usual they had their opinion regarding it. IT was really funny to see such idiots being elected by even greater idots.
RE:RE:Does Samajwadi Party understand the nuclear deal
by Sincere Citizen on Dec 04, 2007 01:47 PM Permalink
What do you know about Chromium reactors ? nowadays anyone acts smart and throws up terms. What does Vinod Dua know about Chromium reactors ?
Its good to bring out the ignorance of politicians but we should know better first.
RE:Does Samajwadi Party understand the nuclear deal
by vinay kapur on Dec 04, 2007 11:12 AM Permalink
Who understands the deal? We do not even know whether it is a business deal, a political deal,a scientific deal or a matter concerning our foreign policy.Why pass comments about others as if we are copnducting a general knowledge quiz?
RE:Does Samajwadi Party understand the nuclear deal
by Rohit Panicker on Dec 04, 2007 12:30 PM Permalink
atleast I (or can i sa 'we') that ther can be no chromium reactors. This means that most do not have any knowledge, maybe have not been to school.
it not for nothing that they call mulayam as Mulla Yum. He is a traitor and runs a party of traitors who cannot see beyond immediate gains at the cost of rational and realistic approach to India's development. Loosers who wont matter anyways
