This is not justice but an illusion of justice designed to lull the naive into a false sense of security about the Indian justice system
Lets not forget this is the same week Shibu Soren got with murder because of willful and criminal neglect bu the CBI, pretty usual stuff for them, recently Pratibha Patil has been rewarded with presidentship for her part time activities, and 2 lawyers and Nanda continue to carry on with life as usual.
Let's not have silly posters make grandiose but shallow comments about the Indian justice system because of this verdict.
RE:Another example
by Jitesh Kumar Agrawal on Aug 24, 2007 01:32 PM Permalink
with the kind of politicians we have in the parliament, we were wasting an asset in Shibu Soren with him in the jail....so its good that he is out to join his friends in the parliament....whats the point in having all mahachors in the parliament and one in the jail....CBI and the Congress are very samrt people to understand that so he is out
RE:Another example
by vijai menon on Aug 24, 2007 01:39 PM Permalink
the judge can convict only based on evidence presented by the prosecution. if the judgement in Salman's case is upheld its because of the same said evidence. lets feel happy that "justice"is being done based on evidence.
RE:Another example
by sajjala reddy on Aug 24, 2007 01:31 PM Permalink
Mr Raul, Who are you to decide Sibu Soren commited murder? There is a system for everything. Rediff comments cannot convict/ acuit a person. Justice system cannot be perfect. Say you kissed a stranger in your room forcibly, who's going to prove anything about that? Evidence is important, not our opinions, that too formed by no so unbiased media.
all these so called rich and famous are shameless.salman should be put behind bars immediately. mansoor ali khan pataudi also ran away from warrants went undeground his wife sharmila tagore said she also did not know where he was. what a shame:::
I agree to sentence of Salman to some extent but not fully. Undoubtly & undeniably he has committed an offence of hunting twice which is prohibited in India. But still I think the punishment should not be so severe that it could spoil the future and career of somebody whether the culprit is a star or a common citizen. Here the question is not on the status of the culprit but how severe is the crime. The court and law is same for all the citizens.
I feel that Salman should be released with some penalty and warning. I am sure he must have realized by now that what he did was absolutely wrong. And every creature on each has equal right to live.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by CHOUDHARY NISHIKANT on Aug 24, 2007 01:29 PM Permalink
Can u tell if you would have been in his place then what could have happened to u and ur family. justice should be unbiased and he must go behind bars. for how long we- and our system should fall prey to favourism. it is similar to getting th relative of Mufti Md (CM of J&K) from the trap of terrorist by agreeing to their demand and allowing the terroist to kill the General manager of HMT on similar grounds. You should be ashamed of delivering such openion in public. It reflects ur spineless character
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by siva kumar on Aug 24, 2007 01:26 PM Permalink
Mukesh tell me the some penalty amoutn you think. If the sone penalty is affordable to be I am planning for this weekend. Idiot use your brain. If all law equals to some penatly then Salman might even hunt you for fun.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Samir Kelekar on Aug 24, 2007 01:11 PM Permalink
Both the judgements that of Sanjay Dutt and Salman have to be hailed. We should learn to respect the law of the land.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Dev on Aug 24, 2007 01:25 PM Permalink
With due respect to the court, the punishment should be severe enough to be corrective but not as much to be retaliatory. Neither the intention of the punishment should be set examples for others.
A punishment which may spoil ones future may create a hardcore criminal who may become an enemy of the society.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Keshetti Mahesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:18 PM Permalink
u probably dont know why sanjay dutt n salman khan are given sentence to imprisonment .. their cases are completely different .. sanjay's sentence is justified bcoz he possessed fire arms (which are dangerous to his fello humans) where as salman's sentence is not justified bcoz it is just shooting black bucks ..
RE:RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by vishal on Aug 24, 2007 01:21 PM Permalink
Mahesh do u know balck buck in an endangered species? And Salman has killed them just for fun. He has habit of killing animals (including humans under his car).
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Keshetti Mahesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:23 PM Permalink
i donno that fact .. but even in that case i don't think 5 years imprisonment is ustified ...
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by D P K on Aug 24, 2007 01:23 PM Permalink
Mr Mukesh,
Why do u think so ? I have heard that in some gulf contries the punishments for such crimes are very seviour like cutting the arms ,openly hanging,removing the eyes etc.Definitely this is not as seviour as those . You do not worry abt Salman . The law is different for STAR category people here in India (Ex.Sanjay Dutt).The same applies for Salman also. Mera Bharat Mahan!! Congrats in advance Mr.Mukesh!!
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by abdul shukkur mundon on Aug 24, 2007 02:06 PM Permalink
Why the heck you support the Salman? I think the punishment should have been more. I have heard lot about his attitude towards public. Do u know this man was beaten by a common man in Juhu beach due to arrogant behaviour.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Preet on Aug 24, 2007 01:29 PM Permalink
if all is true that salman killed those animals ,what is done to protect these animals .Tigers and lion are killed in dozens .sentencing salman khan is not going to help and going to send any message ,instead court should put an hefty fine on him and use that money to preserve and protect these animals .then it will of any good .this cases will go on on instead finish it once and for all and put hefty fine on him.
RE:RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by rajesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:33 PM Permalink
To add a point, think of the innocent people mowed down by Salman and he is still moving free... What happended to your sense of justice dear ? you are shedding tears for this criminal but don't you feel sad for those innocent people who were killed for no fault of theirs ?.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by sri kanth on Aug 24, 2007 01:15 PM Permalink
crap...than release terrorist also on the basis of every creature on each has equal right to live...lolz
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Dev on Aug 24, 2007 01:37 PM Permalink
Hi Sri Kant, Justice is a tricky issue. Long term confinement or capital punishment is delivered when the accused appears to a perpetual threat to the society or has done a rarest of rare crime (in case of capital punishment).
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by rajesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:22 PM Permalink
If the guy has committed the same crime twice - what does indicate ?. that he has not respect for the rule and law of the nation - So, he deserrves punichment which the hounarable court decides. Don't just judge based on the status of the person that he is a an actor. His arrogance and contempt for Indian Law has to be punished. Isn't it ?. For your info. the Black bucks he has killed are the officially declared endagred species and killing them is an offense. Be fair gentleman, let the celebrities or people at high places behave properly and be role models for youngsters - Else what do the young generation think of the justice system in our country ?.
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by on Aug 24, 2007 01:27 PM Permalink
Create a law where anybody can do anything they wish and later repent. No need for jails and the huge maintaining cost. what rubbish. He has done something which he is quite sure not right, but his sense of superiority has made him to do such a crime without blinking eye
RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by Manish Nandgaonkar on Aug 24, 2007 01:31 PM Permalink
Then every body will keep killing animals and human being and will pay fine and will say I realise my mistake, please do not spoil my career. Rather I will say Sanjay and Salamann both should be give 10 to 20 yrs prison for wasting time of court.
RE:RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by vishal on Aug 24, 2007 01:19 PM Permalink
Dear Mukesh do u know his offence. He has killed an endangered animal just for fun. Additionally he even does not care to be present in court to hear verdict. I think he should have been punished more. I am sure now all people in bollywood will start crying abt how is child at his golden heart and so on so forth.
RE:RE:RE:Salman's sentence is not fully justified
by rajesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:25 PM Permalink
Well said brother. Now the TV channels have some action for the next few days!! They seem to be tired of the leftists Natak for the past one week. So, have fun...
Rich people knows that they can do anything in the society..........this is a lesson for toplevel people.......It should applicable for political leaders also.........
RE:ATTACK PAKISTHAN INMMDTLY
by rajesh on Aug 24, 2007 01:36 PM Permalink
India has the capacity. But the spineless politicians do not have the vision to protect India's security interests.
