Please dont sy things that cannot be backed up with evidence.. Like you Karat and Bardhan are Indians... And good ones... Had they been interested in financial gains I am sure they could have done so better by aligning with the americans than with the chinese,,, So please catch up on some facts...Read AMERICAINVADES INDIA... www.americainvadesindia.com and you will know what actually is the truth behind this deal...
RE:AMERICA INVADES INDIA
by anil shetty on Aug 21, 2007 08:55 PM Permalink
Karat and Bardhan..Good Indians ?? Karat and Bardhan Indians?? Amol..Amol you must be confused..Karat and Bardhan are Chinese, Very good Chinese in fact...Their Masters in Beijing must be be very pleased with them, They must be wanting to pin little Mao medals and pins on Comrade Karat and Comrade Bardhan's chest..After all Comrade Karat and co with their imported Red China Sickle and Hammer are sabotaging the energy sources of China's greatest rival..Oh just imagine the ceremony Amol..It could be held in Tinammen Square where Chinese Tanks rolled over and slaughtered innocent Chinese students, Comrade Karat and Bardhan's chest would swell with pride to be awarded medals in the birthplace of their inspiration for Nandigram..Maybe, just maybe Amol they would even buy you a ticket to join in the festivities..
RE:AMERICA INVADES INDIA
by amol on Aug 22, 2007 09:19 PM Permalink
Anil Shetty,,,, I can see what you are saying. But sadly I have taken the trouble of meeting Karat... And I think he is a good man with India's interest at heart... When you say he is Chinese what exactly do you mean... Can you give me a categoric evidence? If he has Chinese masters what exactly has he done in your view that has been instructed fro China? Can you give me any evidence? Something more tangible just abuse. Please back up accusations with real evidence.
RE:AMERICA INVADES INDIA
by kohinoor das on Aug 22, 2007 10:21 AM Permalink
The Communists are good-for-nothing rabble rousers who will oppose anything and everything just for the heck of it. They try to project themselves as out-of-the-box thinkers who claim to analyze and see things in a way others cannot. Of course, they see and analyze everything in a different way, but more often, that way defies common sense. It may be because they do not think out-of-th-box, but maybe because their brain is out-of-the-box.
In fact if u check Prakash Karat and A B Bardhan's mobile phones record, you will find so many calls have been received from Bejing China to ensure this. It may also possible that Karat and Bardhan have been paid by Chinese Communist Part to stall the deal
RE:Karat, Bardhan acting in Chinese interest
by amol on Aug 22, 2007 09:21 PM Permalink
You are playing with words...You say that 'it may be possible that Karat could be paid by Communist' But for what? And how? Can you back it up for this is a national issue and I would like to know more. But facts ..
RE:Karat, Bardhan acting in Chinese interest
by anoop alexander on Aug 22, 2007 05:32 PM Permalink
kajolika pls never make statements for which u might be sued. be fair in ur judgement and sane in your talk.
Friends, who are these left that are opposing the Nuke deal - lets get to some history about them.. 1. These left are the same people who had got several Indian freedom fighter arrested during World War 2, 1945-46, at Soviet Russia's instance.
2. these Left are the very same people who has taken China's side when 1967 Indo-Chinese war broke out.
3. Today they want to stop the Nuke deal the the instance of China's Communist party.
Can we Indians trust these very same Left with India's national interest ? Think yourself after carefully going thru history.
I am a true and real SLAVE of yours. I cleaned your shit and now ready to eat. But the bloody illeterate communists and nationalists BJP parties are giving me trouble to sign the paper prepared by you and your house. I am pretty sure some-day I will make these bloody communists bent down and whole Indians will clean yours' shit. You keep faith on me, I have done everything whatever you and your companies told me to do before coming to PM position.
Bush: I have full confidence and trust you, my baby. I will NOT find better SLAVE than you.
RE:Manmahan and Bush conversation
by Vishwanathan vishu on Aug 21, 2007 03:44 AM Permalink
u people are agents of chinese. without even reading the papers how can u guys comment like this.
RE:Manmahan and Bush conversation
by us on Aug 21, 2007 09:56 AM Permalink
Probably you must be idiot. Was there full release of the report? Why SLAVE MMSingh and congressis not clear to the people about the deal. Let every people read it and decide which is good or bad and then vote for MMSingh if he is going to do such a great deal. Why Govt is not doing that?
While setting up priorities between two almost identical issues of importance to the Nation, well, any simple wisdom will give a priority to National Security over an energy issue! If Nation is lost, what do we do with enormous energy? Further, the quantum of energy that is likely to be obtained, if at all we succeed amidst several risks in addition to the one of National security, is very meager and that too without any assurance of sustained supply of energy for ever! Under the circumstances, it does not warrant much thoughts to decide in favour of National security above all! How national security is in peril can be inferred from the sustained arrogant and dominant behaviours of US to annexe any nation for its own benefits at any cost by using its might as the world history reflects! Its illegitimate, unauthorized and illegal interference in internal affairs of Afghanisthan, Iraq, India-Pakistan and Israel-Palestinian and also the threatened interference in the matters of North and South Korea and Iran etc., are concrete evidences of its wickedness without any valued high moralistic principles! The entire world inclusive of a majority of population of U.S. itself opposed to its such activities of vandalism!
Result is sufferings, miseries and gruesome deaths of millions of innocent and along with rapid growth of terrorist network every where now all over the world! The people all over, suffer due to such terrorist activities! Neither the world benefited, nor our nation! U.S. is certainly benefited by oil and other expansion of business in rehabilitations in the affected countries, taking all necessary precautions against terrorism in their own country! Thus U.S. is most untrustworthy nation and we have to stand losing all as a silent spectator, when they turn against our interests to fetch all the fruits of such Nuke agreement, either by playing cunning tactics by the unknown catches in the agreement or by arrogantly and boldly violating the terms and conditions of the agreement, as I said earlier, U.S. is a cunning wolf, as is evident from the world history! Its part in the world is blood stained! There is no necessity to be a communist to see this simple fact of danger to our nation! Perhaps, our top brains are under threats of brain drains as seen in other vital issues too!
RE:Is there a threat of brain drain to our top brass?
by anoop alexander on Aug 22, 2007 05:38 PM Permalink
exactly gautam . this is what i have been trying to convince my friends. US is not trustworthy. just like Chinese. even more untrustworthy. why dont rediff look into if N-energy is the energy source of Japan. Can we find some alternate sources of energy. why dont we deal with our natural allies which would be better and safer.
RE:Is there a threat of brain drain to our top brass?
by us on Aug 21, 2007 02:53 AM Permalink
Bush and Manmohan Singh COnversation:
Dear Sir (Bush),
I am a true and real SLAVE of yours. I cleaned your shit and now ready to eat. But the bloody illeterate communists and nationalists BJP parties are giving me trouble to sign the paper prepared by you and your house. I am pretty sure some-day I will make these bloody communists bent down and whole Indians will clean yours' shit. You keep faith on me, I have done everything whatever you and your companies told me to do before coming to PM position.
Bush: I have full confidence and trust you, my baby. I will NOT find better SLAVE than you.
the nris in usa must press pres bush to invite narendra modi to his texas ranch for one week. modi will definitely arm-twist the pres to override his state dept spokesman's pronouncement, making it possible for the bjp parliamentarians to support the deal, rendering in the process the commies as useless as they only could be.
India's foreign policy and energy security should not be compromised. We should not live in luxury at the mercy or goodwill of others. Why cant India itself produce nuclear techonoly and y cant we buy the technology from the old Russian friends.
If the Left Parties are so concerned about the negative impact of the Deal. Let them bring this for a vote in the parliament. After all the Speaker can very well help them in it.
There is no point in putting undue pressure on the Government outside the Parliament, when they are talking about Democracy. They only know dictating terms, nothing sort of Blackmailing.
RE:RE:Democracy and Left.
by Lalatendu Deo on Aug 21, 2007 12:14 AM Permalink
I think it is the Left who are the most concerned about bringing it for a Vote in Parliament. Of course Congress does not have a choice here.
