Shri RAMAN, Pranams. As usual astute article. Our country is currently in the grip of two extremes - NDA under the stewardship of Sonia and Mr Singh - who are vying to make love to the US; on the other hand, the communists like Sitaram Yechury who are making love with the chinese. The real enemy is none but the Indian polictican lot who are designing a game plan for sabotaging India per se. Seeing this I feel like shouting the same "WORD" You said you shouted when you retired from yoru eon service from R&AW as mentioned in the KAO BOYS OF R&AW,
Salutes for being the unflickering consciousness and thought provoking articles
The Leftists are really dirty ppl .. deshdrohi ..now the BJP and congress should come together on this crucial issue and bail out India Inc... The leftist should be boycotted ...
This article may have some facts and some truths. We have to protest Left front's ideological US-hatred. There is no place for ideologies in 21st century.
But some frustrated people here are saying foul about begalis. Let me be very clear communists and bengalis are different kind of things, Every state have a communist party and they have some members. The number of members are huge in West Bengal, Ya I know it. But, not every bengali is a comunist. The people who are spreading hatred against Bengalis are just frustrated and jealous. Stick to the topic.
RE:Bengalis and communists
by vijayaraj d.t. on Aug 19, 2007 09:57 PM Permalink
Not all Bengalis are communists, I agree, the bengalis are intelectuals, when this intelectuality and the ideology of communism mixes it has attracted more bengalis towards the idea of communism, am i right Mr. Roy?
RE:Bengalis and communists
by Vinay Gupta on Aug 19, 2007 10:07 PM Permalink
No govt in democracy can survive 6-7 terms. It is possiblem only if the elections are rigged or voters are fool. There is something wrong in WB
It is human tendency not to remain stisfied . Thre is always a urge for a change after some time. Why only communits govts survive for 40-50 years ( russia, china, uguslaivia, Cuba etc. I feel elections are held there)
The view of the author is harsh on the left. When we lean too much towards the West, the left act as counterbalance. India need to be strong to be friends with China. So we need allies like Russia, US, Japan, Australia etc. The author's expression of fear of Muslim backlash is unwarranted. It is economy that dictates the tide of human sentiments. It is the petrodollar that attracts the attention of the world. Once the petrol dries up, the gulf will be past memory. Marxists get inspiration from China. To blame them as unpatriotic is injustice. May be they want to drive with one leg pressed on the brake.
RE:Left act as Counterbalance
by jesus dn on Aug 19, 2007 10:08 PM Permalink
Is capitalism Indian concept? Isnt anti marxists are propogating western values, agendas. Philosopies cant be a product one country alone. Then supporting capitalism is as good as supporting the British, the race that expolited us for 200 years. If we blame communist we should blame others as well. The point is that no one philosophy is perfect. Communists, Hindutavabadi BJP or nondemocratic,family ruled party like Cong all are same. The point is the treaty, we should discuss it threadbare not commies, bjps, congs etc. Nt which political party is good or bad. The author of course is nt w/o his personal bias and quite evident whom he is supporting.
RE:Left act as Counterbalance
by manish jain on Aug 19, 2007 09:56 PM Permalink
What do you have to say about silence of these traitor leftists on 1962 war? Why they were silent when visa to two IAS officers from Arunachal Pradesh were denied on the premise of their being chinese citizens? Take a note that as 1/3rd of Jammu and kashmir and as Tibet was occupied by China to pursue its monopolistic attitude, one day they would eye for other disputed areas also, which they claim as their own. Don't you people see to that.
RE:Left act as Counterbalance
by vijayaraj d.t. on Aug 19, 2007 09:52 PM Permalink
"Marxists get inspiration from China", what inspiration they get from China? Is it Anti-Indian? or not willing the development of India a powerfull nation as China wishes? I suppose you mean it.
I am also not much enthused with the contents of the deal but it is also a fact that we need to have more and more of nuclear energy which besides the non-conventional sources, is going to be the only source of energy in future. These leftists are real traitors and Govt, should not bow to their pressure. Since they are pursuing China favoured approach despite so many setbacks from China, its really hard to digest that how can an Indian still trust China. China has its own set of goals to dominate the region and thats why supporting Pakistan to engage India at all fronts. If US is favouring us then don't these traitors have a bit of common sense that we are moving forward with a more strategic alliance with US. Although US too doesn't have credible record but still enemy's enemy is friend and undoubtedly, as George Fernadiz has said that "China is our Enemy no. 1". These people should be exposed and suitable action taken against them.
RE:Really a shame
by Dharmendra Sharma on Aug 19, 2007 10:02 PM Permalink
Very well said... just to add, it is no longer a doubt in our minds that CPI-M's HQ is not in Kolkatta but in Beijing! They should be thrown out of the country, leave aside West Bengal.
They are simply dancing to the tune of China and making the Indian Govt dance simply because they have some sits in Loksabha to blackmail the govt. It is time for Indian people to realise what is good for the country and who are the traitors.
RE:Really a shame
by Vinay Gupta on Aug 19, 2007 10:10 PM Permalink
No, they are not making this Govt. to dance. They are using the lust for power of Congressis. Congress shud immidiately throw these communists in dust bin. How can 60 odd MP put the whole country for ransom?
leftists r traitors. they didnt say a word when 62 took place. the nation knows there involvement. the left has audacity to to weild authority with NO responsibiliyy.
Think the horning of the CPI & CPIM in India is the handiwork of the Chinese, what these Cs where doing when China claimed Arunachal as its part, they get plenty of money from the chinese, so that the WB government runs a parallel red force to the police and kills people in singur and nandigram, and doctoring all the polls that are held in WB. Now, the Cs will be happy as China is signing a nuclear pact with Pak, China has forgotten that it's citizens were caught in Pak for prostitution and the consequential happens of Red Mosque. If they are going to join hands with Pak and try to arm twist India where these so called Cs (traitors) will go? Will they support India?
RE:Sino-Pak tie up in Nuclear cooperation
by Arnab Chowdhury on Aug 19, 2007 09:47 PM Permalink
SHUT UP...."so that the WB government runs a parallel red force to the police and kills people in singur and nandigram, and doctoring all the polls that are held in WB" DONT INSULT THE PEOPLE OF BENGAL-THEY ARE NO FOOLS!! say what you want to say against CPM or CPI but DO NOT INSULT US.....the left are in power due to their work and not any rigginf as touted by these lady mamata!!
RE:Sino-Pak tie up in Nuclear cooperation
by Vinay Gupta on Aug 19, 2007 09:57 PM Permalink
Arnab, is not a fact your CPM supported Tinnaman. No govt in democracy can survive 6-7 terms. It is possiblem only if the elections are rigged or voters are fool.
It is human tendency not to remin stisfy . Thre is always a urge for a change after some time. Why only communits govts survive for 40-50 years ( russia, china, uguslaivia, Cuba etc. I feel elections are held there)
RE:RE:Sino-Pak tie up in Nuclear cooperation
by vijayaraj d.t. on Aug 19, 2007 09:50 PM Permalink
Hahaha!!! I think you are a staunch supporter of the Cs, it surprises me who come you have not known about the fact in WB?
RE:Sino-Pak tie up in Nuclear cooperation
by Vinay Gupta on Aug 19, 2007 09:46 PM Permalink
One fact which we forget is that these CMP wala supported killing of innocent student by red army of Chinese Communist part at TINAMAN Chock.
Communists are anti people, goons and anti nationals
