By refusing to allow discussion under rule 184 the Lok Sabha Speaker played into the hands of the govrnment. It is the opposition's inalienable right to dislodg a government that has come into a standstill because it survives on the support of parties that have a diametrically opposite ideology. The opposition should seriously ponde whether it should move a vote of no confidence against the Speaker.
Those are supporting the deal shd say to cong first to put the clauses/conditions of the deal then only it wld be discussed and finalysed.
One more thing,-we need the same status of China only from USA in the world and nothing else.If China,US,Russia,France,England even Pakistan,Iran,N.Korea then why we shd not? If all of them leave nuclear test then we are also ready to leave it,otherwise not.
Those are supporting the deal blindly they are actually the blind supporters of Congress,nothing else.
Pls say if I am wrong(if rediff allows u to read my msg)
RE:Why do u support the deal?
by Jerry Kurian on Aug 19, 2007 10:58 PM Permalink
Mr Chinmoy, first of all, what will you gain with a test. It is only to prove we are nuclear capable and the whole world already knows that. Second, none of the coutries mentioned by you like Pak, Iran.. are allowed to carry out test without consequense. US will impose sanctions even if India tests without 123 agreement, so this is nothing new. The best option would be for the world to recognize us as a nuclear state, but that will not happen, so 123 is the closest to that...
RE:Why do u support the deal?
by chinmoy chatterjee on Aug 19, 2007 11:15 PM Permalink
Dear Jerry, Either we shd live in the world with courage , otherwise we shd die , pls dont be afraid of death even. Death of courageous person/nation is not only death(hv u heared the sloka VIRBHOGYA VASUNDHARA) but idol forever.
RE:Why do u support the deal?
by bhumiputra on Aug 19, 2007 10:41 PM Permalink
Your are correct. Those supporting the deal 123 are Cong sonia Supporters. May be the India Loot network. Left is giving infact all options for CONG for a amicable solution. But the intention of cong is to sell the country like YSR in AP is doing.
It is pity that communist sees problem with all developement activities. They are the people with regressive approach. Appeal to Kerala & West Bengal to throw them out in the election.
They have no ideology in practise for the welfare of the people. They are not bothered if 80% of WB remains backwards with no new industrial or agricultural develpoement.
Can any one tell me where does Kerala ( minus NRI Fund flow) & WB stand today in terms of revenue generated & emplyement opprtunity in their respective states after 60 years of ruling by CPM?.
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by India Fan on Aug 19, 2007 10:35 PM Permalink
Good show them the door, this govt will collapse. If the present coalition has to survive they have no option, else try licking the boots of Mayawati, Jayalalith, Chandrababu, Akalis, and just about everyone to survive.
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by cool guy on Aug 19, 2007 11:06 PM Permalink
They are the jokers of a drama company.no body takes them seriously. thank god .. this time they are not protesting in the streets and roads..
RE:RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by bhumiputra on Aug 19, 2007 10:37 PM Permalink
123 act is not a development activity. Puppets of WESt can not though WB or Kerala govt. You are kid in telling facts. WB & Kerala Left are not in power for 60 years. Cong ruled those states for sevaral years. Cong sonia is looting the coutry. Now they want to sell the country through 123 pact. If we do not know facts better shut up.
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by Manoj Mehta on Aug 19, 2007 10:44 PM Permalink
I never said 123 is a developement activity. Show me one good project with employement opprtunity for the people ( Be it a refinery, fertiliser, Hydro power, steel , agriculture, Pharma ) coming up in either of the state where LEFT is ruling now
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by bhumiputra on Aug 19, 2007 11:24 PM Permalink
Industrialization which nehru has taken was a total failure. Indian economy is different. Today you want to work for a company for a salary. You get the salary, and company gets benifit. As long as you do not see the housing, drinking water, health, education for the poor which will not come by establishing industries, through automation the capacity employ more people has already decreased. Only thease polocies will help TATA at the cost of Vizag steel, Airtel at the cost of BSNL, Reddy labs at the cost of IDPL. we have humpty number of examples. 123 pact is near death to poor indians. The Indian rich will sure get benifited, because they are the tools of KFC, McDonald and wallmart economy.
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by India Fan on Aug 19, 2007 10:51 PM Permalink
The left are now doing well, they have bagged Tata car project, They have IT software complex, they are planning a chemical complex. The kerala Tourism has beaten every other state and is now number one.
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by Manoj Mehta on Aug 19, 2007 11:14 PM Permalink
You can't make the state run on one car project or one IT complex. Even a small state like Haryana & Chattisgarh has generated atleast 10 times more jobs than Kerala & WB.
RE:RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by bhumiputra on Aug 19, 2007 11:26 PM Permalink
did that jobs inturn give any housing, health, education to poor? question yourself?
RE:CPM / Ieft must be shown the door!!
by chinmoy chatterjee on Aug 19, 2007 10:49 PM Permalink
Those are supporting the deal shd say to cong first to put the clauses/conditions of the deal then only it wld be discussed and finalysed.
One more thing,-we need the same status of China only from USA in the world and nothing else.If China,US,Russia,France,England even Pakistan,Iran,N.Korea then why we shd not? If all of them leave nuclear test then we are also ready to leave it,otherwise not.
Those are supporting the deal blindly they are actually the blind supporters of Congress,nothing else.
Pls say if I am wrong(if rediff allows u to read my msg)
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by chinmoy chatterjee on Aug 19, 2007 10:56 PM Permalink
Those are supporting the deal shd say to cong first to put the clauses/conditions of the deal then only it wld be discussed and finalysed.
One more thing,-we need the same status of China only from USA in the world and nothing else.If China,US,Russia,France,England even Pakistan,Iran,N.Korea then why we shd not? If all of them leave nuclear test then we are also ready to leave it,otherwise not.
Those are supporting the deal blindly they are actually the blind supporters of Congress,nothing else.
Pls say if I am wrong(if rediff allows u to read my msg)
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by Sumanasa Global Services on Aug 19, 2007 10:26 PM Permalink
This could have been expressed by them before saying no negotiation on N DEAL.Now they are ready for Negotiations i think CPI is more stable then the left which barks more without any analyzing or reasoning.
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by Padamprakash Bhatnagar on Aug 19, 2007 10:28 PM Permalink
Yes, India badly needs a change of guard.The LEFT have shown what they are capable of,i.e.trade uninionism. After holding the centrestage and grabbing the headlines,they are waiting for the last straw to wriggle out. To hell with the nation.Who cares,it is the likes of you and me only,who dont count.
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by VENKATARAMAN IYER on Aug 19, 2007 10:24 PM Permalink
Both Communists and BJP are Hypocrites. The polices when implemented by them are good and when the same is being implemented by other parties in power becomes anti people. Example being promotion of SEZ and World Bank loan being availed by West Bengal Govt. and the Neculear deal which were negotiated by them when they were in power by BJP.
They should specifically mention the clause which will be anti people in the neclear deal being signed by Manmohan singh else they should keep quite. venkataraman
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by Shankar Panday on Aug 19, 2007 10:29 PM Permalink
hopefully WBengal is watching and vote them out of power soon...or else these idealistic idiots will take them back to the stone ages .
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by India Fan on Aug 19, 2007 10:36 PM Permalink
They will never vote them out, bcoz they know that Trinamool and Congress are worse shitbags.
RE:Toothless Bulldogs bark!
by chinmoy chatterjee on Aug 19, 2007 10:55 PM Permalink
Those are supporting the deal shd say to cong first to put the clauses/conditions of the deal then only it wld be discussed and finalysed.
One more thing,-we need the same status of China only from USA in the world and nothing else.If China,US,Russia,France,England even Pakistan,Iran,N.Korea then why we shd not? If all of them leave nuclear test then we are also ready to leave it,otherwise not.
Those are supporting the deal blindly they are actually the blind supporters of Congress,nothing else.
Pls say if I am wrong(if rediff allows u to read my msg)
