Left will beg Congress and manmohan singh to give a towel to cover their faces. at least some thing to show their foolish followers.
Why Left chnage their stand now. When India became established nucler state in Pokran by NDA left was protesting against it. Now is they realised their mistake as usual.
Manmohan sing put Left in a real fix now. Their double stands to be exposed this time.
Enjoying power without taking responsiblity, and shouting against the govt which they supporting.
This is the first time MMS shown he is not a puppet.
Reading all the previous messages gives me an impression that all of you are bent on proving that the left are antinationals.I would like to differ.Have anyone of you read the 123 deal document?I am not going to elaborate on it except the fact that it clearly demands India not to take any foreign polcy decision that is incongruent to US interests.I would like to know whether friendship with uncle Sam is more important than retaining our decade old tradion of nonalignment and sovereignty?After 60 years of independece this deal threatens us of a new colonial subjugation.I beieve no deal is more important than our selfrespect as an independent nation and the left is right in opposing it .Rahul, Agartala, Tripura
NONSENSE, THE REPUBLIC OF INDIA WAS NEVER NEUTRAL. THE FAKE NAM MOVEMENT WAS A SOVIET PUPPET. ALL THE NAM MEMBERS HAVE 100% MILITARY HARDWARE OF SOVIET SUPPLY.
RE:what should the left do
by Serious on Aug 13, 2007 03:25 PM Permalink
Hello Mr., I read the deal documents. Your "elaboration" is totally wrong. Even India will get more freedom than the present members of the NSG.
You communists and communist supporters are stubborn. You cannot see anything beyond 5 years.
You will not lose your virginity as you seemed to be afraid of if the bill is passed in both India and US.
Such a critical deal for the country; how it can be done without Parliament, Security heads (naval, airforce,army) and general public opinion??? Government must do this after all this agreement will have far reaching impacts! If government not doing it LEFT & all other political parties should go to any extent to STOP THIS so called DONE Deal!
Left should learn from Russia and other east european countries now to denounce communism as this harm the society at long run.See North Korea, East german, Hungary, Poland.Also their salary payer China is more market friendly than these stupid old school of thoughts.They just mouth speak of China. They want to show china that they still deserve their cheque. These are the parties supported china after the sixty's attack. What you can expect from such party, people? You see Bengal!OMG, what a mess of the state has been made!They dont practice wht they preach in nandigram and bengal. China is very smart.Just using the stupid red flag bearers with no conscience and patriotism. Let them do what they wish, but they are going to pay the price in election and will be routed. Their Mask has been opened many times during last 3 years.PM deserve lots of kudos challaging these Reds.Even strategist leaders of BJP are convinced.I apreaciate BJP leadership on this because they have patriotism.Today Pakistan and jehadi has been controlled to some extent not because of India's policy because of US pressure.When You are with US, You have many indirect advantages which can not be measured in real dollar & cents. Can left negotiate better deal than this? Mr Karat, Can you? We know your answer. You do not need the deal. because you want us, indians to suffer in misery like wht you are doing in whole states of Bengal.I pity the bangalis. See Kolkata! What a mess.I wonder how people survive there
It is a well known fact that the left parties are allergic to anything American - they hardly come out with any credible arguement to support their bias. Why cannot they engage in constructive dialogue with the Government on the matter ? The Government on their part should come out with convincing reasons on why the Nuclear deal is good for the country in the long run.
Karat should put his into Bardhan's back side who should put into Surjeet's back side who should put his into Karat's back side. They can then happily play ring-a-ring-a-roses.
Left parties the so called champions of the poor and oppressed should rather leave India than to ruin it. They are against everything that creates employment, development or education. The left wants India to be left behind in the dark ages. They want people to be extremely poor and live in poverty. They want them to remain illiterate and accept their ideology without asking questions or citing reasons. Why would they oppose FDI in insurance, retail and other sectors? are they against employment being generated. They hate the word "privatization" which brings accountability and improves services. Are they a party for govt employees and not the public? they dont agree with the nuclear deal with US. Are they proposing the Chinese to give us free power? People from Kerala and W.Bengal i have an appeal to all of you. If you want to vote for the left do it for your state assembly but not for lok sabha and indian parliment. They are a real thorn n the flesh for India. Naxalism and CPI, CPI-M are two sides of a same coin. We indians have to fight these traitors who openely supported China during the 1962 Indo-China war. Left parties should leave India and live in communist countries like Vietnam, N.Korea, Cuba and China. Everyone is adopting capitalist economies now for growth. If you raise your voice you will be shot in all these countries. Spineless old crooks, close down your party and retire. Play with your great grand children at home. Communism = rich union leaders & poor pple
RE:Left should leave India
by chantu mishra on Aug 13, 2007 03:02 PM Permalink
These so called communists have provided clubs in each locality.A TV and carrom board from the government fund. All youth of local area instead of going to school college and their job searching remain in clubs throughout the day. How the country will progress. All local gundas are from clubs and supported by CPM and CPI on the name of politics. They have got oxyzen in form of sardar Jee. They can not withdraw support. They need blackmoney by blackmailing.Thet sent bengal 30 yeard back.
RE:Left should leave India
by wani bhardwaj on Aug 13, 2007 03:06 PM Permalink
You are wrong mr. Left wants overall developments and not for the individual developments. Dont link left ideology with China and Russia. Chinese and Russian situation were different and India's situation is also different. However, ideology is same: Roti, Kapada, Makan, Employement for all.
RE:Left should leave India
by Natesh on Aug 13, 2007 03:15 PM Permalink
Silly bhardwaj how can there be one communist agenda for India and one for others. "Kapada" for all? and your party wants to shut door on outsiders. "roti" I am worried about the future of millions who want to eat bread working for retail outlets. Why do you oppose that? "Employment for all" .. bullshit. when you stop companies from existing how can you create employment. If you want to progress then think "right" not left
RE:Left should leave India
by Tesnion Baba on Aug 13, 2007 02:51 PM Permalink
Natesh baba, at least in India: Communism != rich union leaders. CPA leaders are not living lavishingly, but madam Sonia is. Samjha kya bidu.
RE:Left should leave India
by Natesh on Aug 13, 2007 02:57 PM Permalink
you visit Kerala or west bengal and you will know who is rich. CPM is very rich in Kerala owing so many land properties and media. Many union leaders live a lavish life while poor labourers suffer. Tension baba go burn your red flag and embrace capitalism or u will perish like the soviets
