I'm surprised that the leaders of the past were so shortsighted to even think of reservations as a way to achieve social justice.
People at all levels should be empowered with education and the basic necessities (60 years on, this is still a joke, with farmers committing suicides). Grants and other facilities should be given to poor people at the basic level.
Instead they opened the Pandora's box of reservations. I can't digest they believed this would last only for 10 odd years. They should have known the likes of today's Congress leaders would like reservations to stay forever!
Reservations, Kashmir....our leaders did prove to be a handful. Blah!
ARJUN SINGH KO SARE FIELDS MAI LIKE INDIAN CRICKET TEAM, INDIAN OLYMPIC TEAM & PARLIAMENT MAIN BHI RESERVATION LAGOO KARNA CHAAYAHIYA, SO THAT ALL RULES FOR PLAYERS OF SC/ST & OBC SHOULD BE ABOLISHED, SO THAT INDIAN TEAMS CAN'T BE ABLE TO ENTER IN ANY INTERNATIONAL WORLD CUP/OLYPIC CHAMPIONSHIP LIKE THIS WIORLD CUP, 2007.
RE:RE:BAD DECISION
by Anil Kumar on Apr 23, 2007 04:23 PM Permalink
YOU BLOODY UPPERCAST ENJOYED 5000 YEARS EDUCATION AND EVERTHING, STILL THERE IS NO CHANGES ON THE FUEDAL ATTIDUDE OF THE UPPERCAST IDIOTS
RE:[object]
by serial on Apr 23, 2007 04:26 PM Permalink
you are a dirty lowewr caste fellow to jakar naha kyon lete bhai ganga nahin poochti hai aapki caste kya hai
RE:BAD DECISION
by neeraj jain on Apr 23, 2007 04:25 PM Permalink
no dear, actually there is small mistake. govt went back in past 1931 and tried reservation on the basis of census done in 1931.
but unfortunately SC went backin 1600 and found that there isno OBC term and people are happy.
so they declare if you want to go backwards please do not stop at 1931, go to 300-400 BC where india was "sone ki chidiya" without reservation.
else face the truth that last 60 years of reservation has provided nothing and change the policy
RE:BAD DECISION
by SUPRATIK BHATTACHARYA on Apr 23, 2007 04:36 PM Permalink
WHY MY FRIEND CALL IT AS A BAD DECISION ? U DON'T WANT THAT INDIA SHOULD BE FREE FROM ALL THIS CASTE POLITICS AND WE SHOULD NOT BE VICTIM.MERIT SHOULD BE THE ONLY CRITERIA NOT CASTE IN ANY SPHERE OR IF ANY CRITERIA IS THAT ONLY ECONOMY CRITERIA BECAUSE INDIA IS A POOR COUNTRY ONLY THEN IT WILL BE [RESERVATION] EFFECTIVE U CANT DENY THAT. WE SHOULD REALLY PROSPER AND MADE OUR COUNTRY SUPER POWER ONLY BY MERIT OR OTHER ALL INTELLECTUAL GOOD PEOPLE WILL WORK FOR OTHER COUNTRY AFTER DISILLUSIONED AND FRUSTRATED BY THE CASTE SYSTEM. WE ALL UPPER CASTE PEOPLE AGREE THAT YES THERE WERE HUGE INEQUALITIES AT OUR EARLIER TIME BUT THAT DOESNOT MEANS WE SHOULD GO ON DOING WRONG THINGS IN THE NAME OF EQUALITY. RATHER IN MY VIEW, WE ALL SHOULD WORK FOR UNITY OF THE COUNTRY IRRESPECTIVE OF OUR CASTE & CREED. A PLACE EVERY PEOPLE WILL COME AND STUDY & LIVE. THINK I AM GIVING U AN EXAMPLE IF YOU R ILL & HAVE GONE FOR A TREATEMENT AND U FIND A LOWER CASTE PEOPLE WHO GOT ADMISSION FOR HIS CASTE WILL U PREFER TO DO THE TREATMENT FROM HIM. & ON THE OTHER HAND ANOTHER DOC. WHO SECURED GOOD MARKS AND DID NOT GOT ANY ADMISSION ON MBBS DON'T U THINK U R MAKING SAME MISTAKE WHAT OUR ELDERS DID AND DENYING HIS RIGHT AND INFRINGING HIS INTELLECTUALISM AND FORCE HIM RATHER TO FLEE FROM THIS COUNTRY AND SERVE OTHER PEOPLE NOT OURS. ANOTHER EXAMPLE IF ANY BODY WHO HAVE NOT BUT GOOD IN HIS EDUCATION AND SECURES GOOD PERCENTAGE BUT A HIGHER CASTE OR A LOWER CASTE DON'T U THINK WE WILL HAVE THE RESPONSIBILITY TO HELP HIM AND MAKE HIS FUTURE. SO I HUMBLY APPEAL TO U ALL LOWER CASTE INDIAN PEOPLE COME FORWARD AND FORCE ALL THIS POLITICAL PARTIES NOT TO PLAY CASTE OR RELIGION POLITICS BOTH R VERY DANGEROUS CONSEQUENCES FOR THE FUTURE OF THE COUNTRY. supratik
RE:BAD DECISION
by Nishant Upadhyay on Apr 23, 2007 04:25 PM Permalink
You are obviously a beneficiary if OBC quota is provided. Please tell, what argument do you have in support quota (except blind arguments of vested interest?)
RE:BAD DECISION
by Mani Shekhar Jha on Apr 23, 2007 04:26 PM Permalink
Who is upper cast ? You have created the concept of upper cast , can not you rise without reservation.?
RE:BAD DECISION
by on Apr 23, 2007 04:52 PM Permalink
ok.dont show ur cheap mentality and unhuman nature by addressing daliths as dogs...just think wat english men behaved with indians they literally kicked asses of indians irrespective or any religion. the most CORE of this cast systems r BHRAMINS.if they had not created any such differences between castes our country would have beed in no:1 position in this world. socially ,economically and financially.but this dint happend coz they CREATED this bloody SHIT of caste system ...so something has to be done to raise the social life of those daliths ...coz those upper caste fellows done this ,so they have to struggle for few years ....HEY..excuse me who told u that all dhaliths have less intelligence than those uppercaste fellows we all r humans and we have same amount of knowledge dont forget that AMBEDHKAR is from a dhalith community and hez the one who wrote our constitution .....not nehru or gandhi......i stongle believe that this regervations has to be put for few more years coz there r many ...i mean many obc students deserve for quality education.ok am giving few examples..... (1) a boy from uppercaste like reddys and chowdharies in south,gets economically good life then a boy from low caste community. (2)the boy from upper caste gets quality education coz he gets in international school admission by paying thousands (or even lakhs) but a boy from low castes gets his primary education from GOVERNMENT school ...which doest even have a basic requirements. (3) a boy from a upper caste buys his seat in ( 1 and 2) levels by paying good amount and gets trainned by professionals ...and he will be fit for quality education in top most colleges in india...BUT BUT a the latter gets his education from any govt college and he tries hard for entrance examinations like GATE ,IIT ,AIIMS....he deserves a seat coz he is economically back wen compare to others., (4) coz he is unaware of any good educational systems.so...guys common be matured and broad minded they deserve the reservations....atleast for 10 more years ....now dont prank by saying that indian team also need reservation...be mature enough to respect ur fellow humans...u bloody creeps.
RE:BAD DECISION
by nishu on Apr 23, 2007 04:20 PM Permalink
This is correct judgement.. We dont want our kids to be operated by reserved category "doctors"!!
RE:RE:thanx...
by kirti chauhan on Apr 23, 2007 04:22 PM Permalink
TERA BAAP BHIKHARI,TERI MA BHIKHARI.ITS RIGHT OF OBC THAT GIVEN BHAI BABA SAHEB IN CONSTITION.
RE:thanx...
by nishu on Apr 23, 2007 04:26 PM Permalink
who is this bhai baba saheb the son of pig. Please mind you language and dont use abusive lang against him..
RE:[object]
by Satyendra Dubey on Apr 23, 2007 04:23 PM Permalink
Tum SC ST log General category walo ka Haq kab tak marte rehna chahte ho...khud apni ROTI pakana kab sikhoge..
RE:Amending constitution
by G on Apr 23, 2007 04:21 PM Permalink
And Congress is doing only for lower-caste for last 50 years. So, we should get compensation now.
RE:Amending constitution
by vidya chivukula on Apr 23, 2007 04:28 PM Permalink
Ravi by asking for reservations, you are asking for a shit. India cannot improve as long as we have Shit eaters like you.
RE:Amending constitution
by Ravi on Apr 23, 2007 04:37 PM Permalink
Dear Vidya,
You should never abuse a person. You should talk about the point.
FYI : I am a Brahmin.
But the point is how do we provide the required help to our fellow citizens.
1. We don't let them inside temples 2. We don't let them inside our houses 3. They cannot get expert guidance 4. They cannot focus on studies as their generations would not have touched book
5. My son who is 2 years old would have spoiled 50 pens.
Do you think that this kind of support can be given to their kids by illiterates.
If sons of such poor dalits can pass graduations and score decently in CAT why can't we give helping hand
Hurray atleast the SC has people with brains otherwise the politicians are already there to ruin the country for their petty concerns....I hope Arjun Singh wud take notice of the judgement and start acting wisely atleast he should do one good thing before he leaves for his grave...I hope we can see an India where no caste bias would be there whre intellectuals can thirive and where healthy competition would thrive and merit would be the only way to judge a person and not his caste.
Done right. Why will the SC go by irrelevantly incomplete data? And most important why will the SC accept the proposal for quota when the GOVT failed to do everything by 1990?
The Political Leaders have ill will behind this quota system. Every year they are raising this issue and stalling the whole process. There should be concrete policy atleast for 5 years.
In fact, it should strictly on MERITS only. However if at all there is any reservation, some minimum per centage of marks should also be a criateria. Further after getting a seat under reservation if the person could not complete 1st year say in 3 years, that seat should be dereserved and should go to a person having merits.
But in any case, reservation should be out of hands of the Political Leaders.
Hon'ble Justice Pasayat and Hon'ble Justice Panta have ultimately upheld the fundamental 'Right to Equality'. They have given precedence to merit over dirty vote-garnering politics. Jug, jug jiyo, ye hamari hai arzoo...
