It is a good verdict for the sake of India's integrity and democratic system. We are still not sure that these political outfits who are working on the basis of castists and religion politics will see the writing on the wall and instead of going for caste based reservation which is THE MOST DANGEROUS SWORD on India's integrity and democracy and instead adopt a progressive thinking for reservation ON THE BASIS OF ECONOMIC BACKWARDNESS. It is the only way to start nip in the bud of castist policies adopted by our political parties from 1947 onwards.
I can only say "Thank You SC. We can never forget you. It is only because of our century old laidback attitude that we have been consistently ruled by Mughals, English and now by these sort of Politicians. Please not given to sigle vote to aboe Politicians the favour of OBC quota.
RE:SC declines to vacate stay on OBC quota
by Manish Kesharwani on Apr 23, 2007 05:49 PM Permalink
I fully agree. We have some hope till the court is working like this, otherwise these politician will make our country with QUOTA system everywhere. THANK YOU SC.
SC once again proved that it is SUPREME. I am not against the quota system, but the base on which the quots system based, caste or religion shudn't be the base, better keep the annual income as the base to decide the reservation. even in that case all the BCs, STs, SCs and some other FCs (whose annual income is less than that of some STs and SCs) will be included and that willnot be any objection to any one, either a party or a person.
RE:SC has denied Social Justice
by Ram Sharma on Apr 23, 2007 07:12 PM Permalink
for scocial justice dr ambedkar had provided for caste based quota to sc/st for 10 years. it is now 57 years and still quota system is going on. do u think he was a fool? also why creamy layer concept is not being recognised by the government? why should a rich person get the benefit of reservation? if reservation has to be there, it should purely be on economic criteria and not on caste basis.
RE:SC has denied Social Justice
by Dave on Apr 23, 2007 05:48 PM Permalink
you moron..how do you know that these OBC are actually OBC..this is the main cause of concern..it seems that you dont know what you are talking about.
RE:SC has denied Social Justice
by pradeep agarwal on Apr 23, 2007 06:22 PM Permalink
Most of the OBC/SC or ST candidates come from those families that have availed the advantage of this act since independence.That is why UPA has filed affidavit in SC that creamy layer concept will lead to 75% of the seats will remain idle for want of candidates.This is the true face of the so called social justice provided by the leading party of UPA since independence.They now have a Jaichand as HRD minister & Yashwant Sinha coined charracter from mahabharat as PM to strike at the very foundation of the nation.
ALL PLEOPLES AROUND THE WORLD IS VERY SAD AFTER READING THE NEWS THAT SUPREME COURT BANNED THE QUOTA IN INDIA, BECAUSE (OF THIS DECISION) INDIA WILL COUNTINUE ITS FASTEST GROWING ECONOMY BOOM WITH THE SUPPORT OF CREAMY LAYER STUDENTS WHO HAVE BRAIN, EITHER STUDENTS ARE BELONGS TO UPPER CAST OR LOWER CAST. ITS SURE IF QUOTA IS IMPLEMENTED, THE INDIA'S ECONOMY WILL CRASH WITHIN NEXT 5 YEARS DUE TO GIANT FLOW OF UN-SKILLED MANPOWER GENERATION FROM SCHOOL/COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY/INSTITUTE.
ONE SHOULD START SIGNATURE CAMPAIGN TO SAY "THANK YOU" TO SUPREME COURT.
FINALLY GOD SAVED THE INDIA.........CHEERS......!!!
its great ruling from the supreme court,after 57 years of independence,we came long way with progress in all sectors,we should not go back plying in the agenda on reservations.Reservations was planned for 10 years,which is still being practiced blatently,if reservation has to be given it has to go to weaker sections ,economically extremely backward irrespective of their caste creed or religion,
RE:Defeat Congress and Throw out Italian Sonia Gaandhi out of India
by KETAN JAVIYA on Apr 23, 2007 05:48 PM Permalink | Hide message
everyone knows that what congress did in their 50yrs of rulling and what BJP did in only 5yrs. people have to use their own brain to think, dont listen to others. supreme court should kick out the.....
RE:Defeat Congress and Throw out Italian Sonia Gaandhi out of India
by chandra kant on Apr 23, 2007 05:49 PM Permalink
dO YOU FEEL IT WILL HELP IN ANY WAY, WHEN ALL THE PARTIES ARE HAVING A UNANIMOUS APPROACH ON THE ISSUE. tHERE SHOULD BE PLEBICITE ON SUCH ISSUES ONLY THEN ANY AMENDMENT SHOULD BE PERMITTED IN THE CONSTITUTION.
SECONDLY THE CREAMY LAYER SHOULD BE SEGREGATED FROM RESERVATION
THIRDLY WHEN ONCE PERSON HAS TAKEN THE BENEFIT OF RESERVATION HIS CHILDREN SHOULD NOT BE GIVEN THE BENEFIT OF RESERVATION
FOURTHLY THE RESRVATION SHOULD BE BASED ON ECONOMIC CONDITION AND NOT ON CASTE
