RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by alphy joseph on Apr 18, 2007 09:49 PM Permalink
Vivek i guess you have got the needed reply. Death is death,whoever it may be. A loss is a loss,whoever it may be.It is a vacuum only the family members feel.Show your good side Vivek(I guess you can)
RE:[object]
by Golden on Apr 18, 2007 09:58 PM Permalink
brother, i can understand your reaction when something demonic is said. but i insist, do you think the words you have used are worth using it. i know you have a difference between you and these two people but i shall request to maintain it too. dirty ponds will be every where and we dont keep on throwing stones in them. it only makes us dirty.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Girish Bhatia on Apr 18, 2007 09:38 PM Permalink
Mr. Vivek Kumar when you cant console someone or pray for their soul to rest in peace then atleast don't say these word either.... you are from India and we Indians are not heartless people....just mind your word next time...
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Golden on Apr 18, 2007 09:55 PM Permalink
he is the member of RSS... who only find chances to make a fuss out of any thing. they dont even leave the occasion of death of a woman from encashing it.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Vikram Sagar on Apr 18, 2007 09:37 PM Permalink
rightly said. i am an alumnus of Virginia Tech myself. having done my under-grad in a good college in india, i was baffled by the quality of students who made it to virginia tech. i do not know minal personally, but this is really being hyped up out of proportion.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by on Apr 18, 2007 09:49 PM Permalink
Does she have to be a quality student for us to mourn her? How callous can you get? People die everyday, agreed, and many of them unnaturally. And they all should be remembered and mourned. Nothing wrong with that. She is not being glorified, just talked about.
RE:[object]
by Kanchan on Apr 18, 2007 09:45 PM Permalink
Mr sagar..Its not the quality of being good/brilliant at studies which is important in defining a person, especially after they are gone. Its only the fondness and their personality that remain. I am sorry to say but you have definetely shown your standard.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Venkateshwar Reddy on Apr 18, 2007 09:54 PM Permalink
I wish people had done the same for the jawans who give away their lves for mother india, never saw an article on them in rediff....the sacrifices done by our jawans in kasmir and other places should also be given the same coverage as Minal's news ... And may god give peace to her soul .....
RE:[object]
by Golden on Apr 18, 2007 10:00 PM Permalink
now please dont change to topic. there are lot i can say on your off topic post. but this is not the right time neither is the right place. so i shall just request, please keep off topic messages off the blog.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Vikram Sagar on Apr 18, 2007 10:00 PM Permalink
ppl.. i guess i was misunderstood here, or i did not voice my opinion clearly. i am not taking anything away from the tragedy. i do very much hope that such incidents do not happen, and i am expressing my condolence. what beats me is why media is so intently following something that is happening only in the US. there was an incident in Tamil Nadu when a bus full of college students (all women) was burned, and there were no survivors. We do not know anything about the individuals. And, finally, justice has been done to them with capital punishment being awarded to the killers. Do you remember seeing any of this on rediff?
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Golden on Apr 18, 2007 10:11 PM Permalink
let me explain you something you are not trying to understand. first thing is, you are mentioning some incident which took place long before, i think at least 5 to 6 years before. you are also giving wrong idea i dont know why (may be to prove and intisify your point). there 5 girls dien not, all passengers (you are exaggerating). when this happend i dont think rediff.com had this blog availble. at that time only news used to come and no blog were available. when the justice was given to the culprits, are you sure rediff did not mention this in its news forum at all. please check again. it was an important judgment and i think it was well covered. last but not the least, even if some thing was not highleted, why will you condemn this news and this highlightment? you fight for the right but dont fight against the rights. may i know what minal had to do with that incident which took place almost 5 years back, though i believe that incident too was equally tragic and politically motivated as well (culprit was a supporter of jayalalitha's party and amazingly believes that amman will save him). if you fell something wrong has been done, fight against it but dont try to stop something right from happening out of your vengience. this is what the idea every body got about you and they are cursing you like anything. any way thanks that you explained. i hope now no body should have any ill feeling towards you.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Kanchan on Apr 18, 2007 09:41 PM Permalink
You are being pathetic. It could have been anyone, eevn one of your family. remebering and expressing sorrow is not glorifying. understand the difference before you make such ill sighted comments. just because media is highlighting,does not make it any more less significant or routine. it applies to each and everyone who has died. morever nobody loses anything by speaking some good about people ho have passed. change your attitude sir.. and concentrate on other subejects where media is really glorifying things-
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Karthik T on Apr 18, 2007 09:49 PM Permalink
Vivek,
We might still be living in a material world, but certianly we can be human enough to understand other's pain. Being practical is fine, but then don't have to be ovrtly practical to forget human emotions. Even Animals show some respite but guess this super human generation including each one of us have greed and self Pleasure to call this life as so called 'Be Practical'. Feel pity for you, me and everyone to be in this human race.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Golden on Apr 18, 2007 09:50 PM Permalink
yes, people die every day but we still mourn their death. because we are human, if you have any slightest of humanity then take your words back or if claim inhumanity then i have no blame on you. after someone is died no body says bad to him/her thats again a human nature which you are not able to tolerate and we dont call it grorifying. death is much more prominent and it comes to every body. but if we lose someone near and dear it pains. if someone dies tragic death it pains even to those who are not near to the deceased. it is law of nature and a proof that we are human and we have got a feeling towards other human being. if you dont have that then keep your ideas with you but please dont try to corrupt other people. let others remember the deceased and this way people also come closer to God as death is the only thing which no body even dares to defy in this world, otherwise in this materialistic life who cares about God. we only pray him and then even throw the idol in dustbin, i have seen this happening to Ganesha's idol. any way, if this bothers you then may i know what interests you. talk on Shilpa's kisses, controversial dance of Mallika or people or RSS and BJP attacking muslims and shouting slogans to remind them the conditions for living in india? i deeply regret the tragic death of Minal though i have firm belief that she died a natural death as every death is a natural death. no body can die any unnatural death. she was fated to die like that. i dont know how shall i die but i am sure that too will be a natural death of mine. yes her death was really tragic enough to jolt any man with alive conscience and a heart filled with feeling.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by Sumant Mishra on Apr 18, 2007 09:57 PM Permalink
u son of a bitch,somebody died for god sake ..!!u shud have reserved your stupid thoughts..u shud be ashamed..
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by SARBANANDA GATTANI on Apr 18, 2007 10:16 PM Permalink
I request rediff to close this or scan the massages .
We are not knowing Minal but she was a bright future and suddenly she is no more with us due to some ghastly incident .
What it feels when suddenly u find that the key person in ur family dies in a accident
We feel extremely shattered
Hence from what we read above and people are saying about her Orkut profile , she was a nice girl and had a great future
Even in her father death , she took proper care of her mother and also maintained her studies with highest marks
Hence we are discussing this things only today when she has suddenly left us
Afterwards many few will remember her , Even past sacrifices or unnatural death anyone hardly remembers
Only thing is that if some one stays in Borivili or in Mumbai , they must help her mother and other family members , some Doctors must check her mother for 6-7 months or even the Maharashtra Government could do some thing about it.
RE:Why go Ga Ga over her death
by arun k v on Apr 18, 2007 09:43 PM Permalink
looks like u r a saddist..... may be what u say is right, but not the right time to say......
To the family and friends of minal i extend my deepest condolences. what a tragic and sudden end to such a nice person. she didnt deserve it damn it. sorry to get emotional but cudnt help it.
I m lugubrious since i came to know her demise.I have prayed a lot when there were speculations about her whereabout.We and our nation and particularly our mumbai and Gujarati community lost a great talent in making. My question is why God Almighty afflict such things to innocents. May Allah Parmeshwar rest her soul in peace...Amen
