Discussion Board
Watch this board

Total 16 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2
Madrassa sings patriotic song
by Sharath on Sep 07, 2006 07:42 PM  Permalink 

What a master stroke. I was thinking about this, if Muslims cannot sing "Vanda Matharam" for some religious reasons - then they could sing the national anthem or some other patriotic song; was glad some Muslims have done just that. Thus they remained true to their nation and also to their religion - Smart move.

Sharath
Atlanta/US



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Vande Mataram
by D Shukla on Sep 07, 2006 07:20 PM  Permalink 

If a citizen of a nation cannot sing a song worshipping his nation then he should be directed to go , live, earn his livelihood and use the facilities provided by any other nation on earth and not INDIA. This shameful act of not singing VANDE MATARAM can only be done by shameless person and INDIA doesn't need these kind of shameless here. Any true patriot will never use religion as an excuse for not singing VANDE MATARAM. Governments and political parties must stop this policy of appeasement and take strict action against those who are declared unpatriotics.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
VHP should use their resource judiciously.
by Jam on Sep 07, 2006 07:17 PM  Permalink 

It is a known fact that the masses in the nation are asses. They go by the emotions aroused by the VHP members akin to those raised by muslim fundamentalist worldwide.

VHP does not have sanctity to raise the issue as they are a non entity in the freedom strugggle. Their forefathers (Godse's) have infact murdered the father of the nation. Should'nt we call them anti-national.

Any party whether muslim,Hindus or secular who wishes to divide the country on such lines should be called anti national.

Vande Mataram (only first two paragraph) was adopted as national song.Any leaders wanting to cahnge it now (BJP) shoud be termed anti-national.

VHP leaders should use their energy and resources at uplifting the down trodden instead of raising the bogey of Vandemataram.

India is a democratic country and everbody is free to practice their religion. similarly everyone is free to decide if they want to sing Vande Mataram or not.

The honourable High Court has also accepted this. If VHP leaders still insist then they should be pulled up for dishonouring the orders of the court.

VHP cannot use their mob mentality and play Hindu vote bank Politics at the cost of muslims.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Madrassa sings patriotic song
by suman on Sep 07, 2006 07:04 PM  Permalink 

sonia is playing with vote bank politics, with the sentiments of poor voters.recently there was news report that SPM PM both are worried about minority community.
it is congress/HRD minister started the politisisation of this song. GOI should send notice with meaning of song so that ppl have the knowledge that song
has inoting to with any religion. when imam bukari and dioband objeceted,mulla urjun backtracked.
media presenting bjp has commited a crime asking everybody to sing the song.
cong + commes united paagal alliance is curse to india.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 16 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2
Write a message