What is the great idea of our government behind making it compulsary for schools to sing Vande Mataram only on centurian of Vande Mataram...
Why unnecessarily creating disputes and spoiling image of the muslim brothers when they oppose for certain words used in the said song.... Although it is definitely wrong to refuse singing national song, but we cannot make it compulsory for anybody to sing this song.
Every one know that there are anti national activists in our country and they always want such type of issues to occure so that they can easily misguide the common man who always suffer in such issues.
Govt should see how the gap between Hindu-Muslim can be reduced instead of creating such unnecessary issues.
I am a Christian and am really glad to know that a top cleric in the Muslim community is understandable and considers matters from a very broad view point. At a time when Muslims are looked upon with suspicion, these clarifications will definitely ease the mind and help in building confidence and faith alongwith all citizens....
I m a Shia Muslim and I strongly believe what Mr. Kalbe Sadiq has said. Islam is not against praising one' country or nation where one lives. These Muftis and Moulvis have given enough bad name to Islam not only in present time but right from the times when our beloved Prophet (p.b.u.h.) departed this world. I hope that muslims must think twice over what they says in today' time as a muslim can be branded a terrorist or unpatriotic as soon as he says some thing against some one.
I was shock to see the heading that no wrong in singing Vande Mantram in rediff mail. heading by muslim cleric...
As far is Islam is concern it is No to worhsip of any except Allah...
And as words Vande is worship it is unaccpetable for Muslim .. For those who call themself muslim and do all what ever is prohibited in Islam can recite but for sure if they do recite with heart then they are Musilm by Name only... Same as those terrosit of do all evil in the Name of Islam.
Last but not the least it all vote bank stuff for all parties n But Its evident tat those who call them patriotic most of them dosn't know the song n if some one knew it the there's hardly few who know the meaning if some one know the meaning then it for sure against basic teaching of Islam.
As far as non muslim are concern they can bow there head in infront of all Gods always... I like to reqeust all including media to stop targating the main coz of Islam.. which is hardly left out in Muslims..
RE:Biased Media
by kaviyarasu on Sep 07, 2006 04:26 PM Permalink
Hey...what are you talking about... what sadiq is saying is "vande" stands for "salute" and not for "workship"...
Even if you dont workship our country as we do..can't you even salute our nation...
He is telling that its not unislamic but you still talking about workship and saying the media to "dont target"
Anyhow Im happy that atleast there are few muslims like sadiq who believe that saluting the country and being patriotic is not unislamic
Its highly appreciable interview with proper perspective in the midst of the controversy.Absolutely with open mind and dialogue no issues will be a dead-lock.
You blaming BJP, this contraversy has been rasied by Muslim leaders. Later BJP just responded that what you are doing and I am doing in the same way. First shut the mouths of your Mullahs, Bhukhari's then blame others.
No doubt at all, Country is first than any other thing. And in fact in my view religion is the very last thing.
