Discussion Board
Watch this board

Total 30 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Donation
by Haridutt on Apr 27, 2006 04:44 PM  Permalink 

Dear reporter

please regard the doner on the basis of a human being. We should regard his sentiments. He is a kind hearted man. Kindness is the outcome of every religion.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
taking us for a ride???
by mave on Apr 27, 2006 04:38 PM  Permalink 

The person who is ready to donate his kidneys is from BJP. They are doing some political stunts and u ppl are praising it. .. rediff as always adds spice saying "MUSLIM donates kidneys".....

god forgive us...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Media can't stop this game
by ANIL RAJAN on Apr 27, 2006 04:29 PM  Permalink 


Why is media always trying to find sensation from wrong places.
If the kidney is from Muslim or hindu or man or woman what is more important mahajan's life or religion tag with the kidney .
Stop this sensation game ..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Muslim Offers kidney to Mahajan
by S.Ramaswamy on Apr 27, 2006 04:28 PM  Permalink 

Divisive forces can try their game to their limit.gestures like these go to prove hat the fundamentals in this country are still strong
God bless the gentleman who has come forward to donate his kidney
S.ramaswamy

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Muslim offers kidneys to Mahajan
by Jayshankar on Apr 27, 2006 04:12 PM  Permalink  | Hide replies

You know how to sensationalise the matter by making the subject contraversial. IT is unfortunate that a good intention of a citizen of this country, who unfortunately thinks very high about politicians (nothing against Mr. Mahajan, with due respect), is shown in a communal way by rediff, which is very unfair. His personality need to be appreciated not his religion. What if a hindu would have come with a placard, would you have said that Hindu offers kidneys to mahajan???? All what media does is to colour events to make it colourful so that people enjoy any crap.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
RE:Muslim offers kidneys to Mahajan
by Ashraf Imam on Apr 29, 2006 11:36 AM  Permalink
You are right.
Pampering religious fraternity only through words and not through deeds are easy said than done.
You guyz need be pragmatic, okay?
Ashraf

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Irresponsible Reporting
by Jose on Apr 27, 2006 04:08 PM  Permalink 

A response to some insipid reporting by a site I like very much

"Muslim offers kidneys to Mahajan"

Sensationalism isn't something a site like your's needs to subscribe to. What the @#$% do you mean "Muslim offers kidney"? He's a national like all of us. Why is a religion angle being pushed so much. Just because Mahajan is a key member of a party that strongly advocates Hindutva? If this is meant to be a religion binder, then the premise is very shallow.

"Leader of the BJP Minority Morcha from Bihar offers kidney to Mahajan" is politically correct. But it probably may not induce the number of clicks the reporter may have intended.

It'll be pathetic if you continue to indulge in such sensationalism. It shows everybody in a poor light. The community, for no fault of its will be shown as trying hard to please. BJP will shower gifts on every related person. OR It might even snub the whole affair.

Here's hoping for better reporting.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
was it necessary
by rishi on Apr 27, 2006 04:06 PM  Permalink 

was it necessary for rediff to give the religion of the donor. now who is
creating the divide. biologically and chemically every human being is the
same. dont give a colour to this great gesture. doesnt matter who is
willing to donate, what matters is atleast someone has the faith when
everyone seems to be loosing hope in the politicians.
Haider saab i appreciate you kind gesture.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Good Decision !
by vijay kumar on Apr 27, 2006 04:03 PM  Permalink 


I am proud of you and such act on your part can not be compensated with any reward. I will pray for you. It is only a BIHARI BHAI who can have such courage to donate
kidneys, I remember that day when Pramod Mahajan himself spoke against BIHARI , now it is BIHARI who is ready to save him. GO ahead , the entire world is with you and even I will pray for you and Mr. Mahajan because I have always been respecing Mr. Mahajan but right now to me
you are great , true and real hero. I salute you .

Thanks - vijay


    Forward  |  Report abuse
This isn't fair?
by Melwin Paul on Apr 27, 2006 03:59 PM  Permalink 

I still don't understand why Rediff gave the title "Muslim Offers Kidneys to Mahajan".Doesn't a Muslim qualify to be just like any other human being.Is it because BJP has a Hindutva agenda that the people at Rediff considered it apt to stress the word "Muslim".But this isn't fair.Why are responsible people like Rediff creating a negative trend of this sort.Titles can be flashy but definitely not at a cost.
I wonder whether Rediff people would ever take notice of my comment?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kidneys
by Ramesh M on Apr 27, 2006 03:50 PM  Permalink 

This is very touching; and the most humane of all gestures anyone could offer.

God bless all.

Ramesh M

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 30 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message