We shouldnt get too emotional and violate the treaty aspect of it. If we can put him in a max security prison with zero communication, he is as good as dead.
If we violate any of this treaty we may never get other criminals extradited successfully. Its more important to control crime than to put criminals to death. There might be tons of information than salem may have that may enable the crime world to crumble. Frankly hes a good catch.
Hang the traitor. If he goes scot free then i think we should forget that any thing such justice is there in our country. Hang him as soon as possible.
he is the main source for Indian Intelligence/Police to nab/keep track of dawood and other don's activities as abu might have established good network by now. Authorities must use him for these purposes and they must nab corrupt officials/politicians involved in all the crimes/offences committed with the help of underworld. As of now he is an important route to most wanted dons of india and as well as Pakistan's ISI activities. Some corrupt officials/politicians/stars might already have feared of abu disclosing their names. They might try to influence death penalty to him to save themselves.
It should not become like another Veerappan's Case as he died without disclosing officials/politicians associated with him.
For the untold misery he has reaped on his victims, he should be handed a very hard/harsh punishment for the rest of his life, with no chance of a release. It should continuously serve as a reminder that to him all other criminals like him, that what goes around comes around eventually and with interest!
Extract all the information that CBI can get from him, establish evidence for Paki links to Mumbai Blasts and other terrorist activities and leave him on roads, he will anyway get killed. This way we can see this guy dead as well as we will not be breaking the condition on which Portugal extradited him.
Yes he should be hanged.He is not a human he doesnot deserve living. He has killed almost 200 people and is a threat for thousands.He even spoils many lives directly and indirectly. He slould be killed urgently