Must be Shahrukh, Salman, Madhuri and Aishwarya.Shahrukh started as a good actor but realized that money and fame is more important hence moved to masala movies which need no acting.Akshay kumar is just the opposite.his initial films were only stunts and no acting, but he has matured as an actor ever since Ajnabee. Salman, good in comedy roles but lacks expressions and variety.Can make a good model. Madhuri, danced her way to fame.Karishma, tabu, raveena and Kajol are far better than her. Aishwarya, good looks but no acting.
RE:India's most over-rated actor
by jaya dan on Mar 20, 2008 01:29 PM Permalink
Plz....Karishma's only claim to delivering goods is Zubeidaa and to some extentin Fiza..Just because she delivered some undeserving superhits with David Dhawan and Govinda can make her superior to Madhuri...Tabu is a superb actress and shes underrated for sure...Kajol is a good actress too but shes not as talented as Madhuri...And a debate is still going on as to how Raveena bagged the national award for Daman...So do include Karishma, Raveena, Kajol and Aishwarya in your overrated list and please exclude Madhuri...Dancing one's way to fame is difficult too...Why couldnt Mamta Kulkarni achieve it then?
RE:India's most over-rated actor
by Abhishek on Mar 20, 2008 01:46 PM Permalink
What talent does Mads possess ....Dancing one's way to fame doesn't make anyone a good actress .............all the actresses mentioned like Tabu , Kajol are much better than her
RE:india's most over-rated actor
by Farooq Khan on Mar 20, 2008 12:41 PM Permalink
they are not actors they are players.... Acting is apocryphal by nature and you mean to say these players act on Cricket ground.
Well if they then it could mean that all matches are fixed!!! :o
which proves that even Sachin Tendulkar is perfidious.
You are blaming Sachin Tendulkar for cheating...
My God Such a nonsense person you are....
Let's cut this crap... It was just messay time-paaas by me.. Keep players away from this article. he..he...hee...
Tamil - Rajnikant, Vijay, and quite a few Telugu - Nagarjuna and Chiranjeevi, definitely Hindi - Shahrukh, Salman, and quite a few Lady Actors - Aishwarya Rai 100%
RE:Shahrukh Khan
by kiran shetty on Mar 20, 2008 12:46 PM Permalink
beta shahrukh kya tera baap hai jo teen teen baar shahrukh likhta hai...abhi dhyan se dekh beta main bata tha hoon...
For the love of God, who else can be more over-rated than Shahrukh Khan. Just because he has got a handful of awards for doing cry baby roles in mush mush movies, doesnt bring him in the elite league of actors that have been mentioned in the list. Either the writer needs to take a crash course in acting and movies or go out and join Raj Thakre's MNS (all mouth and nothing else).
Cheers to Rediff for having such esteemed writers onboard!
RE:Who is India's most over-rated actor?
by amit pandey on Mar 20, 2008 12:35 PM Permalink
haha yaar that idiot raj thakre ..he is trying to divide us into regional biasing... he is not indian product i guess... he thinks mumbai is his!!! a bullshit crap..someone has to tall him by pulling his ears thats india is a secular country n mumbai comes in it...
