i think this guy ganesh is trying to play devils advocate.... anu malik being compared to ARR is a god damnnn JOKE. pls dont forget that anu malik shamelessly copied all of RAHMANS tune for GENTLEMAN and released the hindi version in his name.... dont forget MAKARENA that he copied and used in JUDWAA ..... what not has he copied? and finally u can see where its landed him....ON REALITY SHOWS where all judges are presently jobless and living in their past glory.... much like sourav ganguly and virender sehwag!!!!
lastly,rahman may not be the greatest indian musician but he sure is one of the finest and one who has taken indian music beyond boundaries....so lets not debate that and its time we went beyond the north- south barrier and appreciated indians who have tken india to the world!!!!!
RE:rajni
by Muthukumaran Moorthy on Jun 14, 2007 07:05 PM Permalink
Please Guys, stop debating for some useless topic, they all wre entertainers, and they are doing their work properly, to reduce our stress, tats it, and y we should waste our time in debating for this small things..lets njoy the time and start thinking about our work. It seems to be iam advicing, but its the reality....
RE:rajni
by Test on Jun 14, 2007 05:32 PM Permalink
What is this keralite, tamil, north, etc...Pls guys dont encourage groupism in our own country....We all r Indians ...thats all !!
RE:rajni
by Rm on Jun 14, 2007 08:34 PM Permalink
A.R.RAHMAN IS CHENNAIITE BY BIRTH. HIS PARENTS ALSO FROM CHENNAI ONLY. THEY ARE ORIGINALLY TAMIL HINDU MUDHALIAARS BEFORE CONVERTING TO ISLAM. HE EMBRACED ISLAM DUE TO SOME ILL FATE AFTER HIS FATHERS DEATH & DUE TO SOME MIRACLES HAPPENED TO HIS FAMILY THROUGH A SUFI SAINT WHEN HIS FAMILY WAS IN POVERTY. FOR CAREER SAKE INITIALLY HIS FATHER WAS DOING MALAYALAM FILMS & ASSISTING TAMIL FILMS TOO. RAHMAN STARTED HIS CAREER BY DOING JINGLES TO AD FILMS IN CHENNAI TILL ROJA (TAMIL MOVIE) GAVE HIM AN INTERNATIONAL BREAK. REGARDS
RE:rajni
by on Jul 07, 2007 08:08 AM Permalink
just stop this nonsense. Instead of discussing the person's genius and talent u r debating on the place of his birth. cmon guys dont go on this groupism kind of thing. Why can't u all just remember that we all are indians....simply indians and bye the way u ppl forgot to add Dr. APJ abdul kalam in the list u ought to remember him too.
RE:rajni
by Pradipta Sengupta on Jun 14, 2007 02:04 PM Permalink
Rehman is undoubtedly the most talented and innovative music directors of our country with an international class and flavour. But my friend it will take another 30 years to call him a LEGEND.
yesterday heard a news that northies wed southies for want of girls in north. S, I am talking about Haryanvi jats who prefer to marry a kerla girl because a kerala girl is soft, kind and respectful in all aspects.
If this mingling of cultures take place between north and south, north can understand more about south and appreciate instead of cursing and abusing without knowing the facts.
RE:Rahman is Zero
by Kumar Kirsten on Jun 14, 2007 01:16 PM Permalink
Ganesh are you GONE NUTS???? ANU MALIK is a joker....he is a copy cat and stole hit tunes from western music.
Ganesh,please get your mental health checked up with a psychology Specialist, Highly recommended for you....
Rahman A R is one of the finest composers on the earth as on today...it is acknowledged by world renowned personalities... But few of the guys like YOU dont acknowledge that. And try get a Idiotic Name like Anu Malik to compare AR Rahman...SHUT UP!
RE:Rahman is Zero
by Kumar Kirsten on Jun 14, 2007 02:17 PM Permalink
Arey yaar thu Aise nahin sudhrega...! Anu Malik ko bhi kahoge na ki woh India ka best composer hai, tho pagal ho jayega yaar....You have no facts with you I pity on your ignorance....
RE:Rahman is Zero
by karthik muthu on Jun 14, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
i think he is just kidding..He knew everything and he want us to abuse him. Even anu malik wont tell like that
RE:Rahman is Zero
by Krishna Kumar on Jun 14, 2007 05:39 PM Permalink
Ganesh, I couldn't stop rolling with laughter after reading your message. Grow up mate, and listen to some good music by AR Rahman !!!!
RE:Rahman is Zero
by on Jul 07, 2007 08:20 AM Permalink
Ganesh u know what u seriously need a psychiatrist. You've already had a great deal to hear abt ur opinion of anu malik but there is one thing i need to tell u abt Shankar Ehsaan and loy. if u have read any of their interviews u wd have heard them say that they simply love his music and idealise him so i have an advice for u just SHUT UP. and as for rahman he is simply superb
RE:Rahman is Zero
by soman prabhu on Jun 15, 2007 02:05 PM Permalink
thank God..u'd been in post only..jus pick one international project done by anu malik..
RE:Rahman is Zero
by varinder vashisht on Jun 14, 2007 02:38 PM Permalink
O hello.... Anu Mailk is a big cheater and everybody knows it.... he is not a true music composer as A.R Rehman is.......
RE:Rahman is Zero
by Vamsee Godavarthy on Jun 14, 2007 06:44 PM Permalink
Ganesh...I think you are a big NUT....!!!! Non on the Discussion has accepted Anu Malik is best than Rahman.... You duffer have some sense and come on the discussion boards, dont simply bark. Rahman even composed music for United Nations...He was the on the composed VANDEMATARAM Album. You must have heard about NUSHRATH FATEH ALI KHAN(Renowned Ghazal and Sufi Singer), he liked RAHMAN and made an album with him (GURUS of PEACE). Anu malik is one duffer and you r a Big duffer than him ;)
RE:Rahman is Zero
by suresh k on Jun 14, 2007 04:14 PM Permalink
Anu Malik is No.1? Ganeshji you are a BIG JOKER IN THIS EARTH. Dont forget Mr. Ganesh anu malik shamelessly copied all of RAHMANS tune for GENTLEMAN and released the hindi version in his name....
RE:Rahman is Zero
by MUBEEN AKHTAR on Jun 15, 2007 11:11 AM Permalink
Ganesh.. What a bloody joke.. By the way. lemme now ur age..... lolz And nationality as well.. I mean. are u from africa? have u spent all ur time in some bloody jungle with all means of communication to te outer world totally cut?? U duffer...... lolz.. what a thinking..lolz
RE:I love his music
by Mota Papeeta on Jun 14, 2007 01:42 PM Permalink
Minto,do you know the meaning of despicable..?? are you nuts and gone out of your mind..whats roots are you talking about..?...i think you are more despicable than the most despicable.
RE:I love his music
by Kumar Kirsten on Jun 14, 2007 07:12 PM Permalink
Minto!!! Subeh Subeh Minto fresh khakhey aye kya? We know that you have eniugh vocabulary with you...than GANESH(Chk the other fellow who says Anu Malik is great than Rahman);)
RE:DO NOT BUY ANYTHING FROM REDIFF
by Dipanjan Mukherjee on Jun 14, 2007 11:55 AM Permalink
Call this no ,its the order placement cell for Rediff.02225313535
A.R. Rehman is a Living Legend. He should be given Bharat Ratna at the earliest. He is a real GEM. He is one of the very few Gifted , Genuine and True Indians left in our country. GOD BLESS HIM !!!!
RE:Living legend
by Pradipta Sengupta on Jun 14, 2007 02:03 PM Permalink
Rehman is undoubtedly the most talented and innovative music directors of our country with an international class and flavour. But my friend it will take another 30 years to call him a LEGEND. Let his hairs become grey.
RE:Living legend
by syed hussain on Jun 14, 2007 04:14 PM Permalink
why do u think, a man needs to made his hair grey to become a legend. Dude, legends are not made, they are born legends.
