RE:is KJ g*a*y?
by Vijay Advani on Aug 04, 2007 02:30 PM Permalink
u guys r off your ----. Please discuss cash and not yr pre-conceived notions regarding some celebrities sexual preferences.Pl hv some deceny guys.
Reviewers employed by Rediff never give a clear-cut verdict on any movie. When you have adopted a 5 star rating system, why not use it properly. What am I suppose to make out of 1 1/2 stars when no explanation is provided for what 1/2 star means. If it is so difficult to give a verdict using 5 stars, then use 7 or 10 star rating system.
Please employ people who can be decisive with their verdict and have the guts to stand by it as opposed to Mr Sen, who doesnt know himself if the film is good or bad!
Your English and review was ghastly,uncomprehandable, appaling , sturdy , throny,intricate and prosaic . I dont have any propensity for your assesement . Do mail me arshadred@rediffmail.com if any doubts in understanding what I said
RE:@ Raja
by Vijay Advani on Aug 03, 2007 05:28 PM Permalink
What is throny please enlighten. Physician heal thyself. Lets look at our own knowledge (or lack of it) of the language before criticising others.Hope this is comprehended arshad!
RE:@ Raja
by Hide Seek on Aug 03, 2007 05:37 PM Permalink
I think u r first time reading the review of this Bullshit Raja Sen..........he appreciate only the movies of Gay SRK or Karan Johar.....so do exercise first then appraise this guy....you are totally blind.
RE:@ Raja
by Vijay Advani on Aug 03, 2007 05:47 PM Permalink
Who is blind and who is cockeyed? How easily u hv used the word gay fr SRK and KJ! Wonder if u hv been privy to something confidential. Bullshit- please use clean words-Hide Seek.
RE:@ Raja
by Vijay Advani on Aug 03, 2007 05:56 PM Permalink
Hide Seek- U better hide before u seek. If u can't stand criticism u get lost instead of advising me. My business is not to criticise others without reason. But i believe that nobody has a right to unnecessarily and needlessly and mindlessly criticise others.
RE:@ Raja
by Hide Seek on Aug 03, 2007 05:51 PM Permalink
hey the Prof. of english its a discussion board and every one has right to express his or perception....ok u can't point out any one...u did tht's y i point u out. don't teach me ok....so mind ur own business or get lost.
RE:@ Raja
by Rekha Menon on Aug 03, 2007 05:53 PM Permalink
Really! If just stringing big words together mde a sentence then the thesaurus would win the booker prize.
Just try and understand what the reviewer has written. Might take you a little while, but hopefully you'll start appreciating the humour. and meaning.
Remember, the beauty of any language lies in its usage.
RE:RE:@ Raja
by Vijay Advani on Aug 03, 2007 05:57 PM Permalink
Very well said. Really appreciate what u r trying to convey.Hope HIDE SEEK gets it in the right spirit.
RE:@ Raja
by Indian on Aug 03, 2007 10:01 PM Permalink
Rediff readership comprises of all levels of English users. Raja Sen's language may be fit for a Booker or Nobel prize, for all I care; but it is definitely unfit for a non-native speaker/reader of the language. More so there is less contents and more literature in it.
Also, more importantly, if the message is not conveyed, then whats the point of putting it forth? And Rekha or Vijay, just as you advised the guys Hide Seek, you should also do a bit more homework before criticizing anyone. Go see the reader's comments for other reviews by Raja Sen. This is an age old problem with the guy. Also, there are really lots of rumours for reasons of KJ having only SRK for his hero. Some say the scene in Page 3 was motivated by this one.
RE:RE:@ Raja
by Vijay Advani on Aug 04, 2007 02:35 PM Permalink
Do u advise Raja to write in broken English? Its always a pleasure to read well written English. If we cant understand the fault lies with us. And I dont think the language can be called Booker or Nobel level by any yardstick. And pl stop this nonsensical discusion rega K.J. and SRK. Its firstly between two individuals(if at all). Secondly it doesn't concern us. Thirdly we r discussing cash film. Hope u get the msg dude.
I hv gone through most of the comments on Raja\'s review. THe criticism by some of the persons contributing to this discussion seem to be absolutely pedestrian and irrelevant. Raja\'s English is criticised cause people do not seem to comprehend it. I am no English expert but I did not find even one word which could be called hi-fi. Friends lets contribute something intelligent instead of \'slashing \'Raja etc as one of the persons just wrote.Raja-pl keep up the good work. Probably some people want you to write in Hindi and not in English.What say dude?
RE:Good Review
by santosh satpathy on Aug 03, 2007 07:15 PM Permalink
U seems to like poetry,alas,its a movie review section.But,i must say that the review is better today
Ya,, I also feel like that bcz.. such a wonderfull movie acted by Ajay devgan and he has given only 0ne and half star to this movie .. very bad .. i feel it should be atleast 3 and half star ..
