Glossy New York scenes do not make a movie...RDB & Munabhai are examples of this..This is a movie which has everything but still lacks something...The Ups and downs are very extreme and illogical. How come a race driver who earns lakhs of dollars suddenly becomes bankrupt. All the typical Bollywood emotions which looks totally hollow are present in this...When you see this movie, you feel that you've seen it already..Salaam Namaste had some novel things and Sydney was much better than New York..We're fed up of watching same New York locations in every movie..Jaaneman, Salaam-E-Ishq etc...Also some of the things like children eating from garbage are very badly written. Overall, an OK movie..can see if you've nothing better to see.
RE:Movie without a Soul!
by gurdeep kohli on May 03, 2007 10:00 AM Permalink
I think u.. forget that in movie they are shown as us citizen from india.. They are not indian citizen even if they prform bad they will still get advertisement contract... In NY people live for day only.... that's what it is shown.. to save money not to splash out.... also it is shown man is lasy .. lazy fellow.. not saving money.. and also not educated..... anything can happen any tie..
The title is perfect, The Movie is Awesome. Excellent Pairing, Nice Songs. Sidarth Excellent Direction after your Debut in Salaam Namaste. 2007's Second Guaranteed Hit after Guru. Its an Guaranteed Summer - Block Buster.
I want to know how much Yash Chopra and Karan Johar pay Rediff movie critics for praising their films because it looks like a lucrative job and maybe I too can make some money like them. Sukanya Verma has given 4 stars to this flop movie which got a poor opening. Obviously the media is obsessed with the NRI trash full of overhyped and overrated actors like Saif, Shahrukh, Rani and Preeti Zinta courtesy Yash and Karan. No wonder Indian films suck at Oscars
RE:media is biased towards Yash and Karan
by parthesh shah on May 06, 2007 12:37 AM Permalink
hey dear, y do u compare our movies in oscars ?? 1st of all , ask urself, r u ready 2 understand d movies like oscar winning.. r u matured enough ??
RE:media is biased towards Yash and Karan
by ashwini prashanth on May 22, 2007 12:34 PM Permalink
Amit.... u r one junk person i have ever seen.... all u have been scraping is "total crap" first of all learn some english... then interact with some sensible people to get sensible thoughts... Gokul made some good coments on the movie... thts all the business runs on. each individual has his own review...gr8 he came up with the right ones.... lets look other topic with ur perspective "have u reproduced any human being (movie...in ur argument"? then why are u commenting on one" wht a joke.... I don't know even if u understood something from this.... may god help u survive in this world
RE:media is biased towards Yash and Karan
by on May 02, 2007 07:20 PM Permalink
Especially for gokul. 1.Did you ever won some award in your life. 2.Did you ever tried to act. 3.Did you ever seen you picture on screen. 4 Did you ever got a chance to review some movie. 5. Do have any experience in making judgements. So,If your answer to one of these questions is No?then you have no right to say wrong about other people work.
RE:media is biased towards Yash and Karan
by vipin santh on May 03, 2007 04:24 PM Permalink
all have the right to comment... so shut up... if gokul have a comment on something then who the hell are you to stop him... carry on gokul you can express your views fearlessly... we got independence on 1947 i think this crap doesnt know it till now. so gokul i too agree with you...media is biased towards some powerful persons.. tara rum pum is not bad... it makes you feel good...
RE:media is biased towards Yash and Karan
by amit on May 04, 2007 07:14 AM Permalink
I am not stopping him i am just only comment on those things in which u are expert. secondly i am also indian i know what it mean. Having a freedom doesnt mean you u can take adavantage of it.i am really shameful on you for thinking like that....
RE:Ta Ra Rum Pum
by Dhruv Shah on May 02, 2007 11:00 PM Permalink
hello....what did u say...race car scenes are tackily executed..what shit.... u r talking about scenes where is comes 1st from last position when only 2 laps remains.. do you know what racing is.. ohh i forgot u must be talking about the scene where saif's face was always greased after race...HOWS THAT POSSIBLE?????
RE:Ta Ra Rum Pum
by on May 03, 2007 02:15 AM Permalink
dont use abousing language.. In indian democracy everything is possible... Dont keep your finger in bad key...
RE:Ta Ra Rum Pum
by Prajwal Rajgopal on May 02, 2007 03:49 PM Permalink
i completely agree with you .this sukanya reviews films accordingly and then gives compliments or gives a bad impression about good movies.why don't you join the polar bears and give them company in hibernating?
I have worked in a TV channel for sometime. Whenever we had a new series coming up, we would hire Rediff to promote the program. I think the same happens with Rediff reviews. If Yash Chopra pays them money, they will speak his tongue. Rediff has very little sense of ethics. Don't take their reviews seriously. This Sukanya girl is just earning her bread by doing what she is asked to.
