This is highly ridiculous.I am not saying that Sandeep is not good but when we compare then no one can deny that Karunya is a great singer, he has the voice, pitch and yes...everything that matters to be 'X' factor. The judgement by the people's vote through sms and other medium is not a right decision.Mostly people don't consider talent when the question of their own state arises. Why can't they think as an Indian? And moreover, why can't such programs consider the judgement of prominent persons who are expert in their field and who can select the best among all contestants instead of asking any Tom,Dick and Harry to cast their vote. I must say...this TALENT SEARCH' by Sony Television has become a mere facade. If this program had been supervised by judges alone then KARUNYA would have been the Indian Idol. Doesn't matter, for millions like me...for whom music is something touches the soul, KARUNYA is Indian Idol and he is a rising star of our Music Industry. Amen.
It is very awkward positiong of Judges while they are judges but the decision is in the hands of people.
I hope you would have agree me that Karunya is a better singer with remakable confidence but the lack of support brings him defeat.
Of course Sandeep has also very sweet voice but not as good as of a Indian Idol. If this is a singing competation decision should be in the hands of eminent singer of the India but it is the competitation of Vote than?
RE:Indian Idol
by aasia on Apr 27, 2006 02:20 PM Permalink
I don't know who are you but i believe you are absolutely correct. I feel the same about Anu malik.
I just want to congratulate you for all the successes. ANd really appreciate you answering all the negative questions in the chat. That is true spirit of an Artist. Every one is talented and people who have nothing to do in life criticise others acheivements.
All the Best Expecting real good music in future as in past from you.
