Discussion Board
Watch this board

Total 81 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
indion idol
by Neha on Apr 25, 2006 06:34 PM  Permalink 

Sandeep is the better choice than karunya. sandeep has 360 degree image, that karunya has not... What do you think? We all are very very happy, thanks for that moment.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
indian idol result
by hina on Apr 24, 2006 08:18 PM  Permalink 

Hello ,
Mr.Anu Malik,
My name is Hina haswari and i am writing you from london ( uk ) . The reason behind my writing is that i have been viewing indian idol rite from the day of audition till the last day of results . and you wont believe lining in london but yet every monday and tuesday sparing a time 4 indian idol reflects the level of interrest and seriousness that we have and we our fanily and our friends are extremely disappointed by indian idol result . we personally like both sandeep and karuniya but the well deserved person for the crwon of indian idol is karuniya not sandeep . althoug we were very disappointed when ammay datay was out n instead of him there was a guy of himachal was selected by public cuz frankly speaking the final n top 2 contestent should be ammay n karuniya cuz we believe they have learned music n they do justice with singing .we all like you alot specially your boldness to comment on performance of contestants it shows tat you take being a judge as a responsibility not a joy time .we like your humourous poetry too. i request you that indian idol was a talent compitition not an election the way rajistani people have supported it shows its election.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indian Idol
by mitali aneja on Apr 24, 2006 01:07 PM  Permalink 

Karunya was a far better talented and deserving candidate. It was highly disheartening to see him lose the title of the Indian Idol in spite of all the efforts he put in. It was always a treat to watch him perform during the Indian Idol rounds. At the same time, it was great to see him smile and taking his defeat so lighly, although he too must have high hopes of winning. We are more sorry for his parents who know that Karunya has actually won but not got the awards. It was always nice to watch Karunya's father's smile during his son's performances which were almost always excellent. But it was very disheartening to see that smile disappear when Karunya's name was not announced as a winner. The game seems unfair and requires changes in the format so that talent gets its due. Ravi and Amey also got voted out unfairly. No grudges against Sandeep but Karunya is a better deserving candidate for the title.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
being 2nd is the best
by Sushila Datta on Apr 24, 2006 12:51 PM  Permalink 

Hi Anuji,
The winner is always the best. But the runner will be the best. Look at Sushmita sen and Aishwarya rai. Both were contestents to Miss India. Aiswarya was number 2 and today she is number one.

I want you to pass this to Karunya.... He will be the Number 1

    Forward  |  Report abuse
indian Ideal
by K.Balaraman on Apr 24, 2006 10:10 AM  Permalink 

Please convey my congrats to sandeep... Please choose the title as hindi ideal.. This program is not popular in south TV chennals and unable to judge ideal


    Forward  |  Report abuse
karunya must have won the title
by Roopesh on Apr 24, 2006 10:08 AM  Permalink 

Hi,
I am not satisfied with the results of both Indian Idol. In the previous one Amit Sana was better than Abhijeet. And in Indian Idol-2 Karunya was the Best. The selection must be in the hands of judges only. As he is from South India he has not got so much votes, as here very less people watch hindi channels. I personally prefer at least at the final round judges must choose the best. Because the people will select those who are from their place ( ie., thier state and around ). This can affect his career. We missed a great singer who was absolutely fabulous.

But for me

"KARUNYA IS INDIAN IDOL"



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Regional Idol is dividing us Indians
by pradeep on Apr 24, 2006 09:48 AM  Permalink 

I feel these programs where audience vote like "Sare ga ma pa" or "Indian Idol" are making this regional feeling stronger and stronger.
Are you trying to awaken regional sentiments where he is a state representative.where goes our indianess feeling?Such programs need be immediately stopped airing.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
About Indian Idol
by Yagnik KN on Apr 24, 2006 09:42 AM  Permalink 

Indian Idol 2 is over. I take this opportunity to congratulate Sandeep Acharya for winning the crown.Certainly he had to put a very hard labour to comeup to this point. But still like so many of Indians I also feel Karunya is the Indian Idol. I do agree with Karunya's mother that the multi voting sytem is a big flaw with the format. This format has been developed by a foreign company who are organizing a similar competition "American Idol". They have devised the format for their people, an audience of a different gener. It has to be rectified in Indian perspective. Moreover, even after 60 yrs. of Independence and having voting rights, we are not quite mature in selecting the persons who are to govern our lives; how we are expected to select an artist, which needs more finer senes and approch. Yagnik KN, Lucknow

    Forward  |  Report abuse
hi
by arjun on Apr 24, 2006 09:31 AM  Permalink 

hi mate!!
i am really shocked the way people askin u stupid questions.i have never seen indian idol, i have beeen watchin australian one...
i think indian should be more interesting,,i cant believe people puttin alligations on u,, i just cant get over it.. i v heard ur so many songs, n i love them, i like one of ur answer,, "chill enjoy ur summer,, jus tryin to hide their failutres by commenting on others. thanks,,

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 81 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message